Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 18 · 2 May 1902
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 18.

(continued from page 3)

. . . on account of the brazen hypocrisy as on account of the brazen threats which, as if in mockery, they have the audacity to address to the poor victims of Roumanian legislation.

The one idea, however, has called forth enormous astonishment and bewilderment among the Jews: how does the Roumanian Government know the ideas and intentions of the "Alliance israélite"? It would be unheard of if the Roumanian Government permitted itself to invent this; still more unheard of, however, if it should rest upon truth!

The truth, however, will, it is to be hoped, soon come to light. —t—

The General Meeting of the "Israelitische Allianz."

On Sunday, the 27th of April of this year, the annual General Meeting of the "Israelitische Allianz" took place. A body of Zionist members, making up about half of those present, had come to hear a report on the past, and indications as to the future, activity of the "Allianz," since it is unhappily to be presumed that larger actions of the "Allianz" may again become necessary, and this association has hitherto shown itself by no means equal to its tasks. After the reading of the statement of accounts, the motion was first put from the Zionist side that a factual and truthful report of this General Meeting be sent to all the members of the "Allianz," since these had never hitherto been informed of the proceedings at the General Meeting. The chairman, Mr. D. v. Gutmann, at once agreed to this.

Thereupon Dr. Herzl addressed some questions to the Board, chiefly as to whether the consultation of all the "Allianzen," which he had suggested at a preliminary conference with the Board of the "Allianz," had taken place, and if so, whether the Board was disposed to give information on the resolutions adopted; further, whether the Board of the "Allianz" had intervened with any Government for the purpose of preventing the emigration of the distressed Roumanian Jews.

Before the chairman replied, several speakers brought other subjects into the discussion. On the Zionist side Dr. L. Werner and Mr. Max Bernhard spoke. Dr. L. Werner, as President of the "First Jewish Gymnastic Club," found fault with the Board of the Allianz for not supporting a Jewish association whose object is the education of the people in a higher sense, as is that of the Jewish Gymnastic Club. Mr. M. Bernhard pointed out that the Jewish students' associations receive no subsidy from the Allianz, while students' societies in which even anti-Semitic tendencies have come to light receive support. Unhappily the following speakers used the opportunity to turn the debate into entirely different channels. Dr. Marcell Hoffmann came forward and alleged that the Jewish Colonial Bank had 65 million Kronen (!) and was doing pawnbroking business with it instead of giving money for the Roumanian Jews. This plainly spiteful distortion of facts well known to all Zionists led to a veritable storm of indignation, which was only with great difficulty allayed. Quiet was restored only when Dr. Hoffmann renounced speaking further. Then Dr. Bloch told of the imprisonment of five families in Galicia who stand accused of having murdered a Jewish boy who had gone over to Christianity, whereas this boy was in fact safe and sound in America. Dr. Bloch called upon the Board of the Allianz to intervene with the Minister of Justice. Dr. Minz urged the Board to take its stand on the Treaty of Berlin and to demand from the Roumanian Government the observance of the paragraphs on equality of rights.

To all these questions and suggestions Dr. Alfred Stern, the Vice-President of the Allianz, replied first. He took up the certainly original position that resolutions might not be introduced at a General Meeting of the Allianz, because these resolutions contained a disguised motion. These were the resolutions of Dr. Werner and Mr. Bernhard, to the effect that the meeting should call upon the Board to do something, in a worthy manner, for the support of the said Jewish associations.

Dr. Stern, who has worked so long in various representative bodies, thus denies the right of a meeting to pass resolutions. That is very characteristic. Dr. Stern denied that anti-Semitic tendencies existed in the Aid Society for Needy and Deserving Students of Law at the Imperial-Royal University in Vienna, and reproached the Zionist associations with sowing discord among the Jews.

The question of Dr. Herzl was answered by the President, Mr. D. v. Gutmann, by his asking the questioner to forgo an answer, since for reasons of expediency not everything could be brought forward in this discussion.

Dr. Herzl, who thereupon took the concluding word, declared that he did not wish to cause the Board any embarrassment, if he could be convinced that something had really been done to relieve the Roumanian distress; he insisted, however, on one single question only, to which he asked merely a short answer, "yes" or "no"; this question was whether the "Allianz" had intervened with any Government for the purpose of not letting the Roumanian Jews emigrate from Roumania. To this Dr. Kuranda, Vice-President of the "Allianz," replied with a loud and distinct "No." Dr. Herzl took note of this declaration with thanks and summed up the standpoint of the Zionists in the following manner:

The Zionists, he said, must indeed long since have come to the conviction in the course of the years that they find no hearing and no understanding in the "Allianz." People simply would not understand that the Zionist solution is the only one that promises real relief. This year's annual report of the "Allianz," it is true, already contains everything that the Zionists think about the present condition of the oppressed Jews, since it is admitted that the Jewish stock is in many cases persecuted as such, and since the situation of the Roumanian Jews, too, is explained by the fact that the so-called "aliens" cannot point to reciprocity in their homeland, because they have no homeland, etc.

Although by these and other remarks the premises of Zionism appear expressly admitted, the "Allianz," he said, would nevertheless not draw the compelling conclusions from them. Dr. Herzl