Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 21 · 23 May 1902
8printed page
scan 8 of 16
Facsimile · scan 8 of 16
Scan of p. 8
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 21.

(continued from page 7)

…ity everywhere, in Spain and Scotland, in Bengal and Pensylvania, as indeed they do; but never did they found a State, never did they raise themselves into a ruling caste, never did they shake off from their necks the yoke of far inferior races and win a ruling people as their constant protectors. Truly, a successful people! Verily, in reading their modern history we might almost fall into the blasphemous superstition which regards a Corsican vendetta as a punishment of the All-Merciful, and imagines that the Lord eternally avenges upon the innocent the guilt which our ancient forefathers took upon themselves by the crucifixion of Christ."

So far we declare ourselves entirely in agreement with Mr. Zangwill; but we do not feel so completely satisfied with his explanation of the success of individual Jews. This success is so extraordinarily great and lasting, especially in the accumulation of capital, that the ridiculous delusion has spread through Europe that the Jews are all rich, which gave rise to the proverb "As rich as a Jew," and whereby there arose on the Continent a secret but powerfully operative fear that, unless a social boycott and legal restrictions were imposed upon the Jews, they would claim exclusively for themselves all the professions, all the professorial chairs, all the newspapers, and almost every seat in the parliaments. That is the excuse which intelligent Russians always find for their frightful laws of exclusion; the Germans declare that the attempt of the Jews at monopolisation is in progress and must be checked, while the antisemites of France assert with curses that France, unless she drives out every Jew, will shortly fall to them as an inheritance. This panic terror is simply ridiculous; for the Jews have created nothing in war, and nothing remarkable either in art, literature and the practical sciences; and, as Mr. Zangwill shows us, even in money-getting they are far outstripped by the impassive Anglo-Saxons. Any Jew in the United States may become as rich as he pleases without falling under the ban or under lynch law. But the American millionaires who only lately threw the world into a childish excitement are not Jews. Mr. Rockefeller, Mr. Carnegie, Mr. Pierpont Morgan, the Vanderbilts and the Astors are none of them Jews, nor even remotely related to them, and at least two of these plutocrats rank higher in the possession of immediately available capital than any single member of the greatest Jewish firms. Yet many Jews have quite exceptional successes to show, and the contrast between their position and that of their parent people is remarkable enough to give rise to further questions. Mr. Zangwill answers them by recapitulating the general economic advantages of the Jewish race. "The Jews are thrifty, sober, and brought up to money-getting, and are therefore influential millionaires." We do not quite see this. These qualities explain the Jewish millionaires to us in part, but then they explain far too much, for if all Jews are industrious, intelligent, honest and temperate, and inclined to trust those brought up in the same school, why does the enormous majority of the Jews so openly go bankrupt in the struggle for existence? "Oh!" says Mr. Zangwill, "that is the result of oppression from without." That is understandable. But are not the Jews who get on oppressed just as much as those who stay behind — the former having nevertheless worked their way up, with the prospect of repaying like with like? Heaven knows the Jews in Whitechaple are free enough, and yet there is no group of human beings more wretched, more overworked and more downtrodden. We should rather maintain that in this matter of money-getting a law of the Jews is in force which comes to light in their earliest history and is connected with their quite peculiar clinging nature. Never was there a nation in which individuals so unmistakably towered above the mass, never a people which clung more to the earthly and produced more exalted souls. The Prophets, who held aloft the torch of monotheism, sprang from a race which was ever inclined to hanker after the polytheistic creeds of the other Semites. The most unpoetical of peoples brought forth the poets whose songs had already become the consolation of the world when Christianity destroyed their seclusion. The mass of the Jews advocated and pressed for the execution of Christ, but from their rabble there came forth two Jews who clothed the teaching of Christ in the doctrines which became the final laws of the white race, which is now the master of the world. The Jewish nation is a morass out of which, under conditions which the naturalist is not yet wholly able to explain, mighty oaks may grow up. If we read the history of Judaism, the following undoubted fact is marvellous: while the mass of the Jews for ages acquired no money, a few of their individuals showed an astonishing skill in it. One would truly not expect that Anselm Rothschild came out of the Frankfort Ghetto; but still more incredible does it seem to us that Moses Mendelssohn came from a Dessau school, and that Heine issued from the hopeless Philistines of Hamburg, who would gladly have strangled him for his singing.


It is said that if all civic rights were granted to the Jews of the Transvaal, every one of them would show the capacity to become a millionaire.

They would probably fail in freedom*) where they failed in slavery, with the exception of a very few who might perhaps rise to great heights of business, possibly even to half the height of the Dutch-American Rockefeller. Exceptional Jews get on in an exceptional way; but the reason why everything succeeds with them is the exceedingly slight resistance they meet within their sphere of activity. The alarm at the idea of their equal rights, which haunts like a spectre even some clear minds, seems to us quite groundless. Individuals among them may indeed get on splendidly and become as secure reservoirs of capital as a Rockefeller or a Vanderbilt; but the race as such will remain an ordinary one, with but one special quality: that of producing eminent individualities.

Tribune.

Dr. A. Elias, Mühlhausen i. E., requests all confidential agents in the several towns to inform him without delay of the result of the Alliance elections.

*

To the Jewish Students from the South Slav Lands!

To meet a long-felt want, an association of Jewish university students from the South Slav lands, "Bar Giora," has been founded.

*) By freedom is here meant equality of rights.