Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 35 · 29 August 1902
2printed page
scan 2 of 16

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 35

(continued from page 1)

…proletariat. We remind the gentlemen of the Union what an increase Jewish misery has undergone in the last decade, and we ask whether, so far as human foresight can tell, it will become better or worse.

The Union cannot get beyond this question, unless we are soon to hear it snoring. It cannot be a relief bureau for every single one of the hundred thousand desperadoes; for its hitherto purposeless purposes enough others are at work.

With its means the Union cannot reach far, for with appeals to "esteemed co-religionists" one does not coax a single crown from behind the counter in religiously indifferent Austria. The Union would first have to create for itself Jews ready for sacrifice, through the feeling of belonging together. Whether it would not be advisable to carry on and to promote national agitation, we leave to its own consideration. It may well be time to stop handling the Jewish question like a hot plate. A hearty national word will frighten nobody any longer.

It is doubtful what the Union could do with its means. Relief works, factories and alms would turn the largest sums into thin air. To create work here for the vast Jewish proletariat, even the boldest could hardly hope. Perhaps, gentlemen of the Union, you will study the problem of help for all Jews by all Jews.

—y.

Press Opinions on the Constantinople Negotiations.

Zionism of To-day.

The "Jewish World" of London writes under this title concerning the announced result of the recent negotiations in Constantinople:

" . . . . To the impartial observer it would appear that Dr. Herzl and his friends have accomplished a considerable work in that the Zionist leader was received by the ruler of Turkey, his Prime Minister and other high officials of that Empire. Whatever may be said against the Sultan, and however the comparison with the Great Powers of Europe may turn out, he is still a power to be reckoned with, and neither he nor the Grand Vizier is accessible and at home to everyone who makes a cheap excursion to Constantinople and knocks at the palace gate. There have been accredited ambassadors who had to wait for an audience, and well-known persons who did not find the mightiest ruler of the East at their mere request. Dr. Herzl and all who are active with him in the Zionist movement deserve the reward of recognition. Nevertheless the Sultan, after mature consideration, said "No." But that he consented to enter into the matter, as he undoubtedly did — to have achieved that is already a great thing for a man who holds no official position in the diplomatic world. We have no wish to please either the party of the severe critics or that of the defenders of Zionism. We consider it the task of a newspaper to give its readers a true and clear account of events, with a commentary resting upon a complete study and perhaps a deeper knowledge of the attendant circumstances than is otherwise accessible to the average man, and so to help him to form a judgment for himself.

"The question which most people will now ask will be this: 'What influence will the answer of the Porte have upon the Zionist movement?' With many the answer will follow the wish that is father to the thought, and Zionism will either be summarily declared dead, slain and thrice destroyed, without any hope of resurrection, or, on the other hand, the hope will be expressed of a complete success in the not too distant future, to use Dr. Herzl's own phrase. Further information about the Constantinople negotiations confirms that the Sultan was the reverse of hostile, that he offered the Zionist leader something, far more than many would have thought possible a few years ago. But the leader decided that it was not enough to meet the Zionist programme. The refusal proves that hope has not been immediately destroyed, and it certainly proves a considerable strength of character not to accept what the Sultan was prepared to grant. Dr. Herzl and his friends have at any rate covered a long stretch upon the road which they have been travelling for five or six years, and the one fact that the Zionist plans are being seriously considered by the Turkish Government and the ruler of that Empire justifies the optimistic expressions of the head of this movement . . ."

*

The "Jewish Exponent" of Philadelphia on the Constantinople Negotiations.

" . . . . There are journals and journalists — unhappily they are almost without exception Jewish ones — who howl aloud for joy at every piece of news that reports a check to the Zionist aspirations. Not all intolerance is non-Jewish or anti-Jewish, as the anathemas of the last five years have abundantly proved. But the true Zionist is not easily discouraged, for he knows that the undertaking he has begun is not an affair of a month or a year, but a campaign hard and toilsome as few have been. When the anti-Zionist newspapers begin to pour their choicest sarcasms and invectives upon his head, the genuine Zionist will only stiffen his will the more and set to work the more energetically.

"At the moment when the anti-Zionist press represented Rabbi Meyer's recent lecture on Palestine at the Chautauqua University*) as the 'death-blow' of Zionism, the Zionists answered honestly and loyally that most of the charges were justified, and argued from them, quite logically, the justice of the demand for a regulation and control of the Palestinian question such as only a well-conducted organisation on the spot can provide.

"With regard to the recent episode in Constantinople it is undoubtedly established that the Sultan entertains sympathies towards the Zionists, even though the concessions which he is prepared to make do not ent-


*) The Jewish Chautauqua University is a Jewish popular school in the United States, that is, an association which every year during the holidays arranges cycles of lectures on Jewish subjects, in different cities in turn. This year the course took place in Philadelphia. Rabbi Meyer, who was recently in Jerusalem, dealt with the sad conditions in that city, but also condemned very energetically the work of the Alliance there as "un-Jewish and immoral." The anti-Zionist press overlooked the latter judgment and merely exulted that Palestine is said to be unsuited for colonisation. The Editors.