Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 35
(continued from page 3)
…mighty thirst for freedom, it is for me a real phenomenon, a great concern of life. From the depths of my soul I wish the Jewish people, and all other men as well, that they may put the powers of the spirit into this dream, clothe it in flesh, and, steeped in hot blood, conquer all that is unjust, savage and banal."
The celebrated Russian political economist M. Tugan-Baranowskij expresses himself as follows: "With my whole heart I sympathise with the Zionist movement as a protest against the deeply revolting treatment of the Jews which prevails in modern society. The Zionist movement also awakens my sympathies because I see in it the expression of a lofty ideal. It is true that no historical state has yet been founded in the way the Zionists intend with the restoration of the Jewish kingdom; but the past cannot teach lessons to the future. The founding of a Jewish kingdom would be one of the greatest achievements of the human spirit that history knows. The success of this cause would signify the dawn of a new era in the history of the world. I find no reasons to doubt absolutely the realisation of the Zionist cause. From the depths of my heart I wish the cause of the Zionists success."
The most eminent historian of culture in Russia, Professor P. Milgukow, writes as follows: "I sympathise entirely with the bold idea of Zionism, and wish that Zionism may overcome all the obstacles and contradictions which arise at every attempt to advance. Even these inner contradictions between the national-political and the traditional elements of the question only prove to me that Zionism has powerfully seized the consciousness of the people. And independently of its practical task, Zionism can exercise a mighty and beneficent influence upon the raising of the cultural level of the Jewish masses. These circumstances make it possible, nay, they even impose the duty, to greet Zionism heartily; and this even those must do who should not be in agreement with Zionism in its ultimate aims."
The well-known critic, Town Councillor K. Arssenjew, writes: "The Zionist movement appears to me very sympathetic. And it is desirable that the movement should nowhere meet with artificial obstacles."
The eminent Moscow art critic and publicist W. Golzen says in his answer: "I often spoke about the Jewish question, that is, about the Jewish people, with my dear friend W. Solowjew (the greatest Russian thinker, who died not long ago). We were of one mind on it. As a Russian I am deeply revolted by the Jew-baiting in our press. Zionism is a most sympathetic movement. Even if not all the Jews, but only some millions of them, settle in Palestine, it would be a great support for the Jews in general."
The notable Russo-Armenian publicist Totomianz writes: "The fortunes of the unhappy Jewish people remind me of the poor Armenian people, which is oppressed. But while the Armenians are leaving their native villages in Turkey, there has arisen among the Jews a mighty movement towards their ancient home, Palestine, in order to bring about the flourishing of this home by constant and honest labour. The guarantee of the success of this movement is furnished by the co-operative principle which serves as the foundation of this work."
Councillor of State Mordowzew, whose remarks on Zionism we have already published, says in his answer, among other things: "I am firmly convinced that the Jewish people, in possession of Palestine, with its unusual gifts and astonishing energy of mind, will found a mighty and wealthy state there, where once the commercial life of the Phoenicians bubbled forth. And this will be realised, I firmly believe it: the people will not perish which, under terrible oppression, has known how to preserve its ideals through thousands of years."
Some other eminent writers of Russia have in their answers doubted the realisation of the Zionist idea on financial grounds, while unquestionably acknowledging the high value of the idea itself.
The well-known sociologist N. Michailowskij, for example, writes as follows in his answer: "It seems to me that the realisation of the Zionist task demands enormous material means, which could hardly be raised. It would also be deeply regrettable if Europe were deprived of so energetic and capable an element as the Jews."
Wladimir Korolenko writes, among other things: "Zionism is indisputably a sweet dream, and it is impossible to feel no sympathy with the endeavour of the persecuted people to found a fatherland of its own. But the whole question lies in the practical realisation, and on that I cannot form a definite opinion, because I do not know this side of the question exactly."
The well-known writer Melschin, author of the sensational book "From the World of the Outcasts," expresses himself in his answer as follows: "I will gladly believe in the practical possibility of founding a new Jewish kingdom in Palestine. I hope the European governments themselves, in spite of their antagonism (or more correctly, thanks to their antagonism), will render the Jews active help in the realisation of their plan. But in that very thing I see a great evil. Not all the Jews will be able to go to Palestine. The greater part of the Jews will remain in their old places. These, however, will be oppressed still more, in order to compel them too to emigrate to Palestine. That might create a source of new hatred against the Jews."
These misgivings as to the consequences of Zionism, which only two writers raise, furnish one proof more that the Zionist idea is advancing with seven-league strides on the road to realisation. The financial side of Zionism can be overcome by the self-sacrificing spirit of the Jewish people. All other misgivings may perhaps appear sound from the standpoint of those little initiated into the mainsprings of the Zionist movement; but to the initiated it should be clear that Zionism, along all lines, promises the Jewish people the only possible salvation. Gt.
The Roumanian Jewish Question.
The Roumanian Emigrants in Basle.
"I cannot turn my gaze from you" — this poet's word will not leave my mind, and again and again I see in spirit before me the scenes of tragic misery which I beheld a few days ago at the old railway station in Basle, having come over from Freiburg i. Br. Week after week a stream of Roumanian emigrants passes through here. In Basle a halt of one day is made; then the journey goes on, by way of Paris and Havre to America, into an uncertain future which, as the Basle appeal to the congregations aptly says, differs from an unbearable present essentially in this, that it is wrapped in a merciful veil. A part of the emigrants is forwarded at the cost of the Alliance israélite (? Ed.); for them sufficient provision has been made. Besides
