Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 38 · 19 September 1902
11printed page
scan 11 of 16

No. 38 — "Die Welt" — Page 11.

(continued from page 10)

…wn soil deserves the respect of all who are free from prejudice."

It was in the year 1897 that the adherents of the Zionist idea came together for the first time in Basle, in order to resolve upon the means to be adopted. Reports were rendered there on the situation of the Jews in the several countries. They unrolled no pleasant picture. Long debates were further held on the necessity of an organisation and a closer union. The chief object, however, was to submit the whole question to the widest public for discussion. All the world was to know what Zionism strives for, and none was to be able to accuse it of secret conspiracy. The result of these deliberations was: for the Jews, who are nowhere at home, who long for work and find none, a home secured by public law is to be created on the soil of Palestine. Here the elements that are a burden to the several nations are to win from the soil its treasures by toilsome, diligent labour. The idea has meanwhile found many adherents everywhere in Jewry, in the East as well as in the West; non-Jewish circles too regard it with entire sympathy. For the practical carrying out of the aims pursued, it was resolved to create an instrument by means of which the colonisation of Palestine, as well as the preparatory work in general, could be accomplished. The founding of a Colonial Bank was proposed, which may justly be called a people's bank, since its capital was to be made up of the very smallest shares. The capital was estimated at 40 million marks. On attaining one-sixth of this capital the bank becomes capable of operation. At the same time, already at the First Congress in the year 1897, the founding of a National Fund was proposed.

In December 1901 a Zionist Congress now took place for the fifth time. The flaming enthusiasm which the first time had brought together men and women from all the countries of the earth and from all callings showed no abatement this time either. This Fifth Congress, however, was already able to offer more that was positive than its predecessors. The Bank has meanwhile become capable of operation. It is shortly to begin its activity; the establishment of branches in France and Russia was resolved upon. At this Congress too it was emphatically stressed that the projected work of the Zionists is not to be regarded as a humanitarian endeavour. Not charity is to bring redemption, but self-help, the hard labour of the needy themselves. The earlier attempts at colonisation, it was said, had failed because they were all based upon charity. Zionism, on the contrary, wishes to help the masses themselves to rebuild their existence. It wishes, as the President of the Actions Committee, Dr. Herzl, set forth in his opening address, that the settlers shall in future "live upon the soil from the soil, not anxiously peer after the market price as feeble traders. They are to seek the market only with the produce they have over and above their own needs. Each settlement is to govern itself as an agricultural productive co-operative society, on the principles which experience and science already place in our hands to-day ... What shall rise upon this broad, firm substructure of a working agricultural population, what modern and habitable edifice, will depend upon the people itself, once we shall have procured for it the self-determination of its destinies..."

Are, then, the ultimate aims of Zionism attainable?

It is not to be denied that an enormous abundance of difficulties of many kinds stands in the way. The land into which Zionism proposes to transplant a compact mass of Jews has for centuries been a hotly contested possession. It is the "Holy Land," the cradle of the religions of all Christian nations. In this circumstance alone an obstacle to the realisation of the Zionist hopes may already be perceived. Yet precisely the fact that it is not an autonomous body belonging to Christendom that is to arise on the soil of Palestine may well mitigate this difficulty. But however great the ideal and material hindrances that stand in the way of the goal pursued, there is no doubt that the realisation of the Zionist idea would achieve an immense advance not only for the Jews themselves, but that the nations in whose midst great masses of Jews now live would also derive advantage from the altered state of affairs; the surplus portion of the Jews would, through settled life and the cultivation of their own soil, be led to new work of civilisation, whose fruits would undoubtedly benefit in the first place the West, the lands where the emigrated Jews were educated. It must not, to be sure, be overlooked that a whole series of Great Powers are not without pretensions to the Holy Land.

France has from of old believed herself to have certain political claims upon Palestine. But Palestine and Syria form so valuable a piece of the earth that none of the Great Powers would ungrudgingly allow another its possession. Herein already lies the guarantee of a recognition of the neutrality of Palestine by the Powers.

If Russia for her part to-day carries on an Orthodox propaganda in the Holy Land through the founding of schools in great numbers, one cannot conclude from this that it forms the first step towards a later political annexation. Turkey and all the Powers which oppose the subjugation of Turkey by Russia will for their part endeavour to hold back as far as possible the advance of the Russian sphere of interest in Palestine. It must further be considered that through the economic opening-up of Palestine the finances of Turkey would undergo a substantial improvement, and that thanks to this circumstance the influence both of France and of Russia would be weakened. Russia's zeal calls forth precisely the vigilance of the other Powers, and must ripen in them the wish to possess in Palestine a neutral factor which gravitates in no direction. Moreover, it is not at all to be supposed that Russia entertains any expansionist desires with regard to Palestine and Syria. The mighty empire of the Tsar has its hands full in suppressing the ferment within, in mastering the discontent and the revolutionary machinations of its own subjects. How little, moreover, the governing circles of Russia see in Zionism an aspiration contrary to the interests of the Government is evident already from the fact that, whereas all other public meetings and associations there are restricted to a minimum and scarcely tolerated, the Zionist organisations are permitted to act freely. What guides the Russian Government in this is the correct consideration that precisely in its country there exists a proletarian Jewish population numbering millions, from which almost every possibility of livelihood is cut off, and that these desperate people, who have nothing more to lose, form the most willing following of the revolutionary movement. In Zionism, therefore, the Russian Government sees a welcome means of diverting a considerable part of its proletariat from revolt against the régime.

Of the other Powers, the possible attitude of England must of course be taken into account. But England, too, has no political aspirations upon Palestine. Endeavours for the economic and cultural advancement of the Holy Land must be all the more welcome to this State since Egypt, by reason of its proximity, can only derive economic advantages from the flourishing neighbouring land. England will, however, hesitate to take the initiative herself, if only so as not to become involved in disagreeable complications, of perhaps the most far-reaching consequences, with the other States which, like herself, are interested in Palestine. Moreover, Salisbury only recently expressed himself very sympathetically regarding these aims of the young-Jewish movement.

As regards, finally, Germany, her prestige in the Orient, which even to-day undoubtedly exists, can only ga-