No. 39 — "Die Welt" — Page 11
(continued from page 10)
…they become mightier than before.^{10}) Seemingly reconciling themselves with the other parties, they seek their scapegoat elsewhere, namely in the "Judaeo-Masonic Party", as the Church papers express it in their flowery language. Over the heads of the Jews hangs the sword of Damocles, and that is antisemitism. The Italian State is really only in the process of becoming; it has still much to do to consolidate itself, and, like every young State, has as yet no settled traditions graven in bronze; it still moves amid contradictions. Ferrero^{11}) rightly points out how remarkable it is that in this country kings and royalists raise a monument to obdurate republicans like Mazzini, and that anarchist poets, provided only they write verses of classical beauty, become professors or senators. But all countries follow, more or less, one and the same line of development. When France, in the period from 1830 to 1848, was writhing in inward convulsions, when the social question there awoke with all its force and relentlessness and thrust the political question into the background, the first antisemitic movement on a grand scale began; pamphlets such as "La dynastie Rothschild" and "Les juifs rois de l'époque" circulated among the people and incited it against the Jews. A Jewish minister, Fould, at whose appointment the Jewish hearts of France no doubt revelled in bliss, prepared the ground for the appearance of Drumont.^{12}) And perhaps in Italy too — once the first period of storm and stress of new creation is past, and the country has entered upon the phase of developing its forces and resources — the fatal question called antisemitism will, as is unhappily to be feared, unroll itself. For there is no lack of signs, of the sheet-lightning that commonly flickers forth before the outbreak of a storm. Both in life and in literature the question of the Jews, the general thesis of antisemitism, is very frequently treated, in sharper or milder, hostile or benevolent form. Apart from the sallies of the papal organs "Civiltà Cattolica" in Turin and "Unità Cattolica" — which lately, on the occasion of the appointment of Gen. Ottolenghi as Minister of War, also raised a protest against it^{13}) — which let slip no opportunity of attacking the Jews openly or insidiously and of falling upon the "Judaising tendency of the Government"; apart from the regular antisemitic propaganda which a clerical organ in Ancona^{14}), the "Patria", opened last year, in which it resorted to the sharpest means, namely the boycotting of Jewish businesses, etc., and was reduced to silence only by legal process, on the initiative of the president of the Ancona congregation, S. Almagià, and of the well-known and capable Zionist Adv. R. Ascoli — apart from all this, there exists an antisemitic literature sui generis, which openly holds out its hand to its neighbours Drumont and Ahlwardt. Among these are to be noted the Jesuitically crafty work of P. Vannuttelli, "Israel"; but the most pronounced and most remarkable is the book of Dr. Panonzi, "L'Ebro attraverso i secoli e la sua posizione nelle società moderne".^{15}) The book might be described as a companion-piece to "La France juive". For the author, all the evils that afflict Italy come solely from the Jews; literature is Judaised; under Jewish influence a godless tendency has been adopted in poetry and in life; materialism is passed off as a Jewish doctrine; Jacob Moleschott, the author of the "Kreislauf des Lebens", is declared a Jew; the Talmud is treated and quoted à la Rohling; nay, even the blood-libel is repeated. Among the Judaising poets and writers he counts even the best, such as Carducci, Rapisardi, nay, even Gaboriele d'Annunzio! This last-named poet, who feels himself called to give new laws to art, is incidentally a colleague of the Comtesse Martel (Gyp), that is to say, an antisemite. And truly! How can he — he, the individualist, who preaches "egoarchy", Nietzscheanism in its most exaggerated form, who idealises sensual self-indulgence, he who calls the Latin race the greatest of the living and fancies himself the greatest of all Latins — how can he harmonise with the Jewish spirit?! For despite his adaptability, his capacity for acclimatisation, the Jew in the ground of his being remains, among all ages and peoples, under all circumstances, still — like himself. "Lombroso," says the acute Italian writer Ferrero^{16}), "has acutely pointed out that the Jew, like a transparent polyp, takes on the colour of the water in which he finds himself; that in the Venetian territory he is talkative like the Venetian, in Piedmont silent and reserved, and so forth; but this observation is defective. Between the Jew and the Aryan^{17}) there is a profound psychological difference . . . Few writers in the last five-and-twenty years have so stirred Italy as Lombroso, and yet scarcely anyone is less Italian in spirit than Lombroso."
These ineffaceable ethnic traits, his deep ethical sense, his outlook upon life, which differs entirely from that of the other peoples, form for the Jew — to whatever country he may belong and whatever tongue he may speak — an impassable boundary wall and at the same time a talisman that saves him from absorption, from disappearance. The inner conflict of the Jew between what he is and what he would like to be forms the tragic side of the soul-life of the modern Jew. In Germany it brought forth the brilliant, suffering mocker Heine; in Italy, Giuseppe Revere, who falls far behind him in talent, though not in the love of mockery and in suffering within the mockery — the suffering of a second spirit tormenting itself in inner struggle.
To draw the conclusion from all the facts and observations which we have set forth in the course of this study, one need not exactly lay claim to prophetic gifts. "Science," says Aug. Comte, "means: to see in order to foresee (voir pour prévoir)." And that is the case, too, with the science of society, sociology. Antisemitism, as we have seen, has cast its seeds in Italy also, and finds there a suitable soil; we have seen that the political position of the Jews in Italy is a product of the general economic and political conditions of the country, and that with their alteration it must necessarily alter too. The life of the Jews is indeed a closed circle — from Judaism, from national life, it passes beyond its bounds, becomes cosmopolitan, universally human, and then it is — and sometimes in a very brutal fashion — thrust back again within its natural bounds; but it returns to the old river-bed with new strength, renewed and refreshed by all the streams it has met on its way and taken into itself: this is a circulus, but not vitiosus — rather gloriosus.
And now, before we close, the last question: How does Italian Jewry stand towards its national rebirth, towards Zionism? Has it intuitively perceived in it the right solution of all questions, the untying of the Gordian knot of Jewish existence? Although the Zionist idea has not yet found due appreciation in Italy, the Jewish milieu is nevertheless daily growing more inclined towards it, and at last even the careless Italian Jews are beginning to become aware that in the azure sky of their beautiful fatherland, too, many a cloud is forming, and that over their heads, too, there hangs a sword of Damocles.
- ^{10}) Cf. G. Negri: Rumori mondani, 1894.
- ^{11}) Europa Giovane by Guglielmo Ferrero.
- ^{12}) Cf. K. Marx: The Civil War in France, p. 27 ff.
- ^{13}) Cf. "Avanti" of May 1902.
- ^{14}) One of the towns most densely inhabited by Jews.
- ^{15}) Cf. also Lattes: Logni d'un Antisemita (A reply to the work of Panzoni).
- ^{16}) l. c. 358 ff.
- ^{17}) I.e. non-Jews, for according to the most recent anthropological researches the antithesis Aryan–Semite has fallen.
