Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 43
(continued from page 1)
. . . compelled to enlighten our Jewish brethren — even those who are our opponents — as to the true state of affairs. Let us choose a typical example: Sir Marcus Samuel of London, a wealthy Jew, has lately been elected Lord Mayor of the City. Since Sir Marcus was tactful enough to proclaim himself a Jew in his address and to point to the difference between the treatment of the Jews in England and in other countries, we Jews certainly have reason to rejoice at this distinction conferred upon a Jew. Whether it is not too much when a paper writes on this occasion: "The heights are reached, the chasms bridged!" we shall leave to our readers to judge. But one ought at least to examine whether the individual so distinguished, whose glory is supposed to cast its reflection upon the whole Jewish people, has also kept his heart for his people and his faith.
Thus in Trieste Herr M. Luzzatto was elected an honorary citizen of the town, which the Jewish Gotha almanacs naturally greeted with resounding jubilation. They forgot, however, to reproduce the correction of the "Corriere Israelitico," that the gentleman in question had long since left the Jewish religious community.
Roumania, that cruel land of barbarians, in order to throw dust in the eyes of the Jewish stock-jobbers, has appointed a Jew, Herr Leopold Dreyfus, its Consul in Paris, and Herr Dreyfus had not the courage to fling the proffered dignity back in Roumania's face, as a member of another nationality would, mutatis mutandis, certainly have done.
Further, Herr Leopold Pollak, Imperial Councillor and Commercial Councillor, President of the Board of the Viennese Merchants and member of the Vienna Jewish Community Board, has been distinguished with the Commander's Cross of the Order of Franz Joseph. We naturally congratulate this gentleman heartily, since his services to the Fatherland are surely great and important. But has Judaism also every reason to rejoice at this distinction? Had Imperial Councillor Pollak, for example, performed no other great deed than his well-known antisemitic conduct during the competition for the building of the Vereinshaus, had he done nothing else than all but stand godfather to his son at baptism while at the same time remaining a member of the Community Board (which, of course, the flattering Jewish press passes over in silence, although it is well informed), that alone would be sufficient.
Let one more drastic example be mentioned: the seventieth birthday of a Jewish lady (whose name I consider it superfluous to mention), who plays a certain part in public life, was lately celebrated by the Jewish organs with the customary emphasis. Now the remarkable case occurred that the lady whose jubilee it was felt, precisely on her seventieth birthday, the urge to be received into the bosom of the one saving Church. It may perhaps be objected: Yes, but how could these newspapers have known that? Well, the answer is very simple: had the lady all her life long cherished any lively feeling for Judaism, she would not have cast it contemptuously from her in her seventieth year. And if all her life long she has done nothing for Judaism, then Judaism, too, has no occasion to celebrate her ...
Otherwise the Germans would have to rejoice that the high officialdom of one of the greatest empires of Eastern Europe bears German names and is therefore undoubtedly of Germanic descent. And what else binds us to such Jews, who take no part in our life, who share with us neither sorrow and woe nor our hopes and the hard struggle for our ideals? Need we be proud at all of such Jews, who have by some means or other attained a certain eminent position and shun us? By no means. Only he who does not respect himself, who has no "I" of his own, hunts after recognition from without. We, however, possess a national soul that stands higher than the isolated individual; we have our national self-consciousness, and do not wish to press ourselves upon those who live apart from us. We national Jews are consistent and follow our doctrine of the people as an organic whole and of the subordinate position of the individual in relation to the community — a doctrine which corresponds to the thought of our people from the most ancient sages down to the most recent: Steinthal and Lazarus — and thus we also stand upon a scientific basis. Jewish culture, the Jewish spirit, and civilised Jews, clever Jews, are not always coinciding conceptions . . . .
"The heights are reached, the chasms bridged," that paper exclaims. What logic! Five times already have Jews been raised to the same dignity, that of Lord Mayor, and nevertheless, in spite of the "heights reached and chasms bridged," it is precisely now that antisemitism is awakening in England, precisely now that a movement is astir to close the gates of England against Jewish immigrants, precisely now that "riots," that is, disturbances against the Jews, are threatened in the East End of London! And as though such cases were so rare in Jewish history! In the time of Louis XVI, the Most Catholic, a Jew named S. Bernard had risen to high honours because he was immensely rich; indeed, the proud King himself doffed his hat to the Jewish Croesus. In Austria and Germany there were Court Jews, and even in the Kingdom of Poland of blessed memory there were protected Jews who at times exercised great influence, as, for example, the celebrated Meyer Jesofowicz. Did the privileged position of these individual men have any effect, any decisive influence, upon the fate of the Jewish people as a whole? The whole Jewish martyrology instructs us on that point. And now Messrs. Rothschild, Cassel, Samuel are not called simply protected Jews, nor is it said to their faces that homage is paid only to Mammon, whose priests they are — the twentieth century is too well-bred and tactful for that. But: "Tant plus que ça change, tant plus est la même chose," says the Frenchman. (The more it changes, the more it remains the same.) Everywhere Jewish distress such as few periods of our history of suffering have known; everywhere the Jews groan and starve, thirst for material and spiritual nourishment, wander about without shelter or rest; here a massacre of Jews in Czenstochau, there an anti-Jewish demonstration in New-York — but what of that? Herr X. has, after all, received a high decoration, and Sir Ernestus Cassel (who, by the way, is baptised) has become a Privy Councillor! Have not, then, the millions of disinherited in Eastern Europe, etc., reason to count themselves happy that they have such great "brethren in the faith"? If not, so much the worse for them!
Vienna.
Coralnik.
Christian Statesmen and Scholars on Zionism.
In No. 35 of the "Welt" (of 29 August 1902) we reproduced the views of eminent Russians on Zionism, which the respected Russian review "Russkaja Mysl" (Russian Thought) had collected. In connection therewith, let the opinions obtained by the same journal from several non-Russian Christian authorities, namely