Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 44.
(continued from page 7)
…can Jewry enriches, while we have been made the poorer by it, I described American Judaism as an illogical chaos. The phrase aroused indignation, was called provocative, was denied — all to excess. What it means is that "Reform" was not preceded by a critical analysis of the Jewish idea and conceptions, and that it accordingly owes its origin to the accident of occasion and to the individual caprice of its leading spirits.
My illustration was simple and clear. The abolition of the dietary laws was arbitrary; the examination and rejection of the theory of revealed legislation did not precede it and did not ground it. The dilemma is obvious: either God gave the laws on Mount Sinai, or He did not. If He did, how dare you abolish so much? If He did not, why do you not abolish more — or rather, why do you not remould and interpret in the spirit of Moses and of his reforming successors, the Rabbis? To quote my own humble instance: if you already permit oysters, why do you not forbid lobsters, on the ground that they are boiled alive? Mendelsohn translated the Bible into German, but no one has translated it into practical life. Your Reform sacrifices the continuity of history to mere mechanical alterations, without laying down any philosophical idea as its foundation — always excepting the formula "Washington is our Zion," which, by the way, contrasts agreeably with the cowardly confusion of our "priests" here, who disapprove of the movement for the realisation of that for which they pray.
Do not think that I see salvation in a merely mechanical reaction towards Orthodoxy. This too would have to be preceded by a critical inquiry and would have to create a new Biblical criticism — one, however, that would not be a question of texts and dates to be answered by archaeology, but a question of psychology and philosophy. Without this sincere consideration Judaism remains as much a superstition as Christianity, and Orthodoxy will remain just as much a fashion, and will pass away, like everything that is not founded upon the eternal rock.
With the best New Year's wishes to you and your readers, and greetings to my Zionist friends, yours faithfully, Israel Zangwill.
From the English House of Commons. Sir Howard Vincent last week submitted the following motion: "I desire to call the attention of the House to the increase and the dangers of an unrestricted immigration of destitute and dangerous aliens from the Continent into Great Britain — the great number of jurisdictions exercised by the criminal courts here over aliens is proof of this — and to move a resolution: that in the opinion of this House labour should be protected not merely by tariffs, but as far as possible also by prohibiting the landing of workmen who come under contract, or of those also who come over freely but represent so low a standard of the necessities of life that they underbid the native workmen in the labour market and press them down to a lower level."
Major Evans-Gordon asks the First Lord of the Treasury whether the correspondence concerning the Note of the American Government regarding the treatment of the Jews in Roumania will be published, and whether the House will be given an opportunity of discussing the question. Mr. Balfour's answer: The correspondence to which my honourable friend refers is not complete, and I am therefore not in a position to answer this question.
Hamburg. It is reported that the Royal Ministry of War has conferred upon the local "Talmud-Thora School" the right to issue the certificate of qualification for the one-year volunteer service.
Vienna Jewish Toynbee Hall.
The Jewish Toynbee Hall, XX., Karajangasse 20, began its third year last Saturday with the first society evening. The society's premises were filled to the last little seat, and many guests had to be refused admission for want of room. It deserves particular emphasis that the official circles of the Vienna Jewish community too are beginning to turn their attention to the Toynbee Hall. Among the numerous notables were observed, among others, the Vice-President of the Vienna Jewish Community, Provincial School Inspector Dr. Gustav Kohn, District School Inspector Dr. Markus Spitzer, Baurat Stiassny, Imperial Councillor Dr. Lieben, most of the rabbis of the community, etc. The opening address was delivered by the chairman of the Toynbee Hall, Seminary Rector Prof. Dr. Adolf Schwarz.
The speaker showed that the modern institution of the Toynbee Hall is akin to a principle of the most ancient Judaism, namely the principle of the equalisation of social contrasts. Because the Jewish people was from time immemorial meant to form a closely knit unity, it sought to bridge the social differences in its midst. Historical Judaism knows no disinherited, and even the poorest Jew need not fear comparison with the non-Jew standing on the same social level. It is certainly not to be denied that we have some rich men in our midst upon whom we may look with pride; but if one would recognise in its essence the difference which does after all exist between the Jewish people and the other nations, and which makes all assimilation impossible, then one must not compare the rich Jew with the rich non-Jew — one must compare the poor Jews with the poor non-Jews. The indestructible, most vigorous roots of the Jewish stock lie in those strata of the people which are bedded lowest. The striving to rise to the heights in intellectual respects guarantees us in the long run the power of rejuvenation of the Jewish stock. The Sinaitic fundamental law with its democratic basis, the Jewish constitution, which knows no distinction between man and man, has taken care that even he who has nothing is something. The Jewish "Zedakah" is more than benevolence and charity, more than active love of mankind, for Jewish giving was a mutual giving. Through the principle of mutuality the Jewish tribal consciousness was to be heightened. The aim of Arnold Toynbee, to make the achievements and creations of science and art the common possession of all classes, shows many kindred features with that which the Jews have striven after for thousands of years. Therefore our Toynbee Hall must be, before all and after all, a Jewish institution. That it is through the spirit and the heart of the man who called it into being here in Vienna, and who, for all the modesty with which he keeps in the background, stands at its head and forms its very soul. (Lively applause.) (By this apostrophe the speaker means the founder of the Vienna Jewish Toynbee Hall, Professor Kellner. Reporter's note.) That it has always been through the harmonious co-operation of refined and art-loving Jewish women with strong-willed, energetic Jewish men, and that it will remain in the future. It seeks to equalise the social contrasts within our national community, all the more so as, it seems, the right method has not always been applied to this equalisation in recent decades. It was indeed founded by a party conscious of its aims, but from the outset it devoted itself to the welfare of the whole community without distinction of party. In order to fulfil its tasks completely, it must develop into a communal institution in the old Jewish sense.
After Prof. Dr. Schwarz's address, which was received with unanimous and lively applause, there followed vocal and musical performances by Chief Cantor Béla Gutmann, the composers Ignaz Brüll and Josef Sulzer (piano and violoncello), Chief Cantor Don Fuchs and the violoncellist J. Auber, all of whom enjoyed stormy applause.
In conclusion Provincial School Inspector Dr. Gustav Kohn took the floor to address a warm appeal to the assembly to further the philanthropic aims and purposes of the Toynbee Hall intellectually and materially, and moreover to make propaganda for it among their acquaintance, so that the intention of establishing branches in other districts as well might be carried out as soon as possible. A subvention from the Board of the Jewish Community might well be contemplated, Dr. Kohn added, but the widest circles of Jewry must actively co-operate if the Toynbee Hall is to be in a position to meet the demands made upon it.
Personal News.
Vienna. On Monday, the 26th of October, our worthy comrade in the cause, Mr. J. L. Deiner, was borne to his grave. A stately procession of mourning friends rendered to the Ver-
