Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 1 · 2 January 1903
4printed page
scan 4 of 20

Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 1

(continued from page 3)

...brought to the Mediterranean coast, would yet have vanished prematurely, like the other countless Hamito-Semitic stocks and fragments of stocks that moved upon the land-bridge between Asia and Africa. Pharisaism, it is true, caused Judaism to stiffen within itself, but at the same time it preserved it and carried it over, out of the tremendous ethnic surf of those days, into modern times. It is therefore, in far greater measure even than the Mosaic code and the theocratic constitution of the pre-Babylonian period had been, to be regarded as an outflow of the racial instincts, and indeed as the last, desperate clinging of these instincts to a fixed system of life and a theocratic order, with whose collapse they knew themselves lost. This point of view is misjudged by Lagarde, and still by virtually all the investigators and critics of the ancient Jewish faith. The former writes (loc. cit.): "The cold, venomous arrogance which flowed from the observance of these (Pharisaic) commandments was heightened still further by giving it a patriotic pretext in the lawyer-like belief in the election of the vaunted people by Jahveh, and a metaphysico-theological abutment in the doctrine of the unity of God, unknown to the ancients, even rejected in the childhood of Israel, and devoid of all religious value." Lagarde here touches upon the problem with which we are dealing, without seeing through it. He does not observe that religion is in the first place not to be measured and appraised by an ethic at all, that so long as it is "cult" it has at bottom nothing whatever to do with ethics, but is to be regarded as the highest, spiritualised expression of the vital instincts and of the instinct of self-preservation. From this "instinctive" point of view Pharisaism too must be appreciated, and from it alone can one do it justice. Under the political and ethnic conditions then prevailing in Palestine, in which the Jews found themselves hemmed in, it was the only conceivable and possible form in which they could preserve and perpetuate their ethos, their racially instinctive law of life, in which indeed they succeeded. Under any other they would have been lost. And their hatred of the Nazarene was therefore a well-founded, an instinctive one. They felt at once that his teaching, though it created a higher ethical basis of life, at the same time meant the destruction of the Jewish race. And this the Pharisees resisted with all the energy of which their race was capable; therefore they nailed the Nazarene to the cross.

So much for the historical development and racial psychology of the Hebrews. Bunsen distinguishes two types which play a part in the Old Testament and stand in religious opposition to one another. The one served Jehovah, the other Elohim. The former, whose chief representatives were the Galileans, introduced, according to the Belgian scholar Emil Burnouf, the symbolic element into the cult of the Hebrew people. From it came forth the Prophets, from Melchisedech down to the Babylonian captivity; to it we owe the religious element in the Psalms of David, as well as the ever-recurring lamentations of the Prophets over the stiff-necked people that hardened itself against their lofty teachings and roused their wrath by its repeated relapse into superstition and the worship of Baal. Among more recent scholars, Luschan distinguishes three types among the ancient Israelites, namely the Semitic stock proper, of dark complexion; the light-coloured, red-blond and blue-eyed Amorites (the Amaur or Tamehu of the Egyptians), to whom he ascribes Aryan descent; and the Armenoid Hittites, to whom he traces the round-headed type with the hooked nose among the Jews of to-day. With this we pass from the ethnological factors to the anthropological characteristics of the Jewish race, which in fact divides into a round-headed and a long-headed type, a distinction which seems to us the most valid and apt, since according to the results of Otto Ammon's researches the formation of the skull everywhere stands in correlation with mental disposition. As is well known, the European Jews are divided into the Spanish-Portuguese branch of the Sephardim and the German-Polish branch of the Ashkenazim, and to the former is ascribed the higher intellectual endowment, to the latter the superior sense for business and practical affairs. The Sephardim have produced the scholars, philosophers and thinkers of the Jewish race, and Spinoza is their crown. Now it is not admitted that there is a corresponding distinction by skull formation, such that the long head would predominantly belong to the Sephardim and the round head to the Ashkenazim, as would correspond to the "mental and spiritual disposition" of these two branches. Even though this may not be proved, or may not be demonstrably established, since the transitions and intermediate stages are naturally countless, as in every racial gradation, the inference from mental and spiritual disposition in general to skull formation is nevertheless just as justified as the converse, and the origin of the two branches, namely the respective route which each took on its entry into Europe, confirms this inference. The Sephardim came to Spain by way of North Africa; on this route they crossed with the long-headed Moorish-Arab — perhaps also with the likewise long-headed Negritic — element, and in the Pyrenean peninsula they met, in addition, with the Germanic. The religious persecutions of the 16th and 17th centuries occasioned numerous conversions of Jews to Catholicism there.

Although these were mostly only of an outward nature and made for appearance' sake, they nevertheless brought in their train numerous crossings with the dominant Spanish stratum of the population, which was predominantly of Germanic blood. All these elements which we have here enumerated, namely two, perhaps three, long-headed racial types, are thus represented in the Sephardim, and there can surely no longer be any question that the long head is the characteristic of the latter, standing at the same time in correlation with their mental and spiritual disposition. The Ashkenazim, on the other hand, took the route through Asia Minor and Russia and on it demonstrably crossed with the Mongolian element, of which the Khazars furnish a living document, a Tatar tribe in the Crimea which during the 8th century had taken up Jewish blood in so great a measure that it went over to Judaism and adopted the cult of Jehovah. From this intermingling the Karaim arose. The German-Polish branch now shows an unmistakably Mongoloid type; it is chamaeprosopic, broad-faced, with strongly projecting cheek-bones, thick-set body, short broad hands, whereas the Spanish-Portuguese is leptoprosopic, narrow-faced, and of taller, slender stature with long narrow hands. All these are marks of the traces of blood which the one type as well as the other received and carried with it on its long route to Europe. For dolichocephaly, leptoprosopy and leptocheiry stand in correlation with one another, just as do brachycephaly, chamaeprosopy and chamaecheiry. Naturally long-headed races, such as the Germans and Arabs, have long, narrow faces with taller stature wherever their type appears pure; short-headed ones, such as the