Page 2. — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 4.
Morning Sitting.
Tuesday, 25 August 1903.
The Bureau is greeted with applause. The President opens the sitting at 10 o'clock.
Dr. Bernstein: On behalf of the Credentials Committee I have the following to report: We have discharged our mandate, the examination of the validity of the elections held for the Sixth Congress, in several sittings, and we find that the elections were, on the whole, conducted in proper order. Of 1079 delegates elected, 592 had appeared here by this morning, whose election we have examined and found correct. Some protests were lodged, which were not upheld. It should be mentioned that the election contested by the central committee of a South Russian town could be recognised as valid. In the course of our labours, however, certain questions have arisen concerning the powers of the territorial organisations and of the shekel-payers in electoral matters, which make a more precise wording of the Organisation Statute appear desirable. The Credentials Committee therefore intends to lay proposals to this effect before the Organisation Committee, with a view to securing greater regularity and preventing failures and needless friction. In general, a praiseworthy advance may be noted in the drawing up of the election returns and in their confirmation by the territorial organisation. We must, however, remark upon two very serious shortcomings, to which we wish to direct the most particular attention of the Congress. It must be censured that the election returns, with the exception of precisely the smallest territorial groups, contained no lists of shekel-payers, and further, that the proper time-limit for sending them in was not observed. The seventeenth paragraph of the Organisation Statute reads: Every Land Committee shall keep its own list of its shekel-payers, which, together with the names of the delegates elected, it must communicate to the A.-C. at least 4 weeks before each Congress. We therefore insist that these two conditions be observed with great punctuality in future, since otherwise an exhaustive and impartial examination of the individual mandates cannot be achieved.
Wortsmann questions the Credentials Committee concerning the recognition of an election in Russia.
The report of the Credentials Committee is approved.
President Dr. Herzl: At the close of yesterday's sitting two delegates from America addressed an inquiry to me, which I first laid before the Greater A.-C. The Greater A.-C. has come to the following resolution: For various reasons, which are for the most part known to you, the delegates, we do not consider it fitting to bring the documents in our possession before the Congress for the purpose of discussion. Nevertheless the A.-C. desires, within such limits as carry no harm to our movement, to give the Congress an opportunity, while it is still in session, of acquainting itself with the most important of these documents. Prof. Gottheil, the one American delegate, has inquired into the grounds of my statements regarding the attitude of the Russian Government. The other American delegate, Mr. Sulzberger, has likewise asked for the production of the British documents. The A.-C. has resolved to hand the documents relating to our negotiations with the English Government, in the first instance, only to the commission which will be appointed by the Congress for the East African question, and not to permit any debate upon them in the Congress. (Applause.) The Russian document, however, which is a declaration of the Government, it has resolved to publish this morning in the official organ of our movement, in "Die Welt." This has been done, and I shall not permit a debate upon it either (applause).
President Dr. Herzl replies to a question from Mr. Bentwich.
Mr. Bentwich asks to whom the documents will be handed if no commission for East Africa is appointed. In the first place, we have received word from the various territorial groups that they are in favour of appointing a commission (assent); should the Congress, however, not so resolve, the question will lie before us whether we should not elect a commission to which we would show the documents.
Dr. Bodenheimer reads a selection of telegrams of greeting from: Montreal, Johannesburg, Jaffa Buenos-Ayres, Riga, Lions City, Chicago ("Knights of Zion"), Philadelphia, Cleveland, Pittsburg, Jaffa, Tiflis, Johannesburg, Klerksdorp (South Africa), New-York ("United Zionists"), NishnijNowgorod, Kaifa, Cincinnati, Louisville, another from Louisville, Baltimore, New-York, Haifa (Ussischkin), Perm, Zandvoort, Pribram (Bohemia), from a number of communities in Austria — in Pilsen prayers were offered for the Congress in the temple on Saturday —, San Francisco.
Tschlenoff announces that the community in Mirgorod has inscribed Dr. Herzl in the Golden Book.
Isr. Zangwill (greeted with lively applause) speaks in English on Zionism and Charitable Institutions. (See yesterday's number.)
Dr. Nordau translates the above speech into German. During his speech Zangwill was the centre of tumultuous ovations.
Chairman Dr. Herzl. It is desired that the speech of our friend Zangwill be translated into Russian as well; but I do not think that the short time of our Congress suffices for that. There is no doubt, however, that the Russian translation will appear in print within the shortest time. Dr. Nossig has asked to speak on a point of order.
Dr. Nossig. Is it permitted to speak on the question "Zionism and Charitable Institutions"?
Dr. Herzl. Certainly, there will be a discussion upon it, but not now. Dr. Sokolow, too, cannot deliver his report now. I make an exception only for Dr. Elias of Mülhausen, who has been on the list for a long time and must leave again.
Dr. Nossig. Will Mr. Oppenheimer's report take place?
Dr. Herzl. I hope to be able to fix it for to-morrow. I now call upon Dr. Elias.
Dr. Elias. I should like to take up the communications which our honoured leader, Dr. Herzl, made yesterday. The Ica is said to have declared that it is prepared to work with us in a manner yet to be determined. I do not believe that we shall ever, or for the time being, be able to draw up a common programme with the present directors of the Ica for the relief of Jewish distress; for our views differ too widely. In their conviction we have too many national attributes, in ours they have too few. Nor are we agreed upon the means of raising them. They see the solution of the Jewish question in assimilation, in the surrender of our national individuality; we in regeneration, on a national basis, of our duties and in the raising of all the qualities which stamp us as a people. Our policy is a national one, theirs an international one. The road we have taken is passable; whether it will lead to the goal, the future will decide; upon their hopes and their ways judgment has been passed. A people must not abandon the hope of a future of its own; like a single individual, it has duties towards itself. Assimilation is to be condemned on grounds of national morality; it is, moreover, impossible; for the proof of this has been furnished by the Ica itself, and by the Alliance. Philanthropic societies have done everything to carry assimilation through; but all their means have so far shown no result. They have taken the standpoint that a people can be dissolved into molecules like a dead substance. But a people consists of living beings, of beings who think, who have a tradition and an ideal, and be this people broken up into ever so small groups, never will it be able to assimilate under such conditions as the Ica desires. It was possible for the Ica and the Alliance to stimulate emigrations from Russia and Roumania. Beside the old ghettos they have founded new ones on the banks of the Thames and in America. They have declared that the old ghetto will be depopulated, that where the Jews dwell in excess their number will diminish. But though 20, 30, up to 40,000 Jews emigrate from Russia, yet from year to