Page 10 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 6
(continued from page 9)
…pointed. These are rather prescribed to them: the Actions Committee. That is the remarkable thing: alongside the entry of this "joint-stock company" in the commercial register, an agreement is concluded whereby the holders of the founders' shares bind themselves not to act otherwise than as the A. C. wills. You see, then, that you need have no fear of the shareholders.
You have now to decide whether the purpose of the National Fund, as we have defined it in Point II, appears acceptable to you; and, should you have so decided, further to determine whether the limit which we have fixed for the beginning of land purchase, namely 200,000 Lst., or possibly 125,000 Lst., is acceptable to you.
We further beg you to leave the details to the National Fund Commission.
We do indeed believe that we have laid before you a statute which, just as it now stands, can be legalised almost completely. Nevertheless we beg you to refrain from this for the moment, and to have regard to the motion of the Russian delegates, who have urged that this work, already finished, be put aside, and to leave the decision to the next Congress. The two principal motions, I believe, are very well suited for adoption. And should you be unable to resolve upon adopting the motion of the National Fund Commission, I recommend to you to take once more into consideration the much simpler formulation which Mr. Bentwich and I have proposed.
Dr. Kohan-Bernstein states that it does the Congress no honour that, on so important a question, the hall should be half empty. When it is a matter of making opposition or of singing od le owdo, people are on the spot. (Applause.) He thanks the reporter, Mr. Kremenetzki, for his pains, and says that he would like to add a few words on the 1st and 2nd reports and to make a motion thereon. The curves in the report of the Commission show that on the whole the rise in the collection for the National Fund is nevertheless small. The cause is the weak agitation. The yield of the National Fund amounts in all countries to 86,000 roubles. That is little. Russia alone has 66,000 roubles. And even that is no proof that Russia has worked much. On page 6 Mr. Kremenetzki shows that in the course of 19 months it comes to two kopecks a head.
The "Golden Book," which is meant to spur the rich to give somewhat more, has not brought in even 75,000 roubles. And of the newspapers — I do not speak of "Die Welt," our official organ — a Russian newspaper, which has after all criticised the Basle Programme, has brought in the most money.
The National Fund is not yet well understood by the Zionists. I therefore make an educational motion. I propose that every Zionist declare in his society what his annual expenditure is — for himself personally, not for his family — and give 2 % of this annual expenditure to the National Fund. (Applause.)
Zlotopolski (speaks Russian) says that the receipts from stamps, together with donations, in Russia are somewhat more than those of the Golden Book.
Samuel Pineles associates himself with Kremenetzki regarding the raising of the value of the National Fund stamps, and moves that a stamp of the value of one shekel be prepared.
Jackson moves that every Zionist should be obliged, just as with the shekel, to pay a sum to be fixed, perhaps 40 kopecks; for the National Fund must have a definite sum yearly and not be dependent upon chance donations.
Jakob Marain moves 1) that every Zionist should put up a National Fund box in his house and in his shop, 2) that, since the Russian members of the A. C. have determined that the ninth day of the month of Ab shall be a general day for the National Fund in Russia, this day should accordingly be appointed among the whole Jewish people for a collection for the National Fund. He further asks — since donations are often printed incorrectly in the newspapers, and so there is no control — that in the several national sections a centre be formed to which the lists of donations shall be sent. He speaks earnestly against the issue of stamps of higher value; for these are much more likely to be forged.
F. Aschkenasi (speaks Jargon).
Advocate Rosenbaum (applause) has questions to put with reference to what Kremenetzki said. In what proportion do the receipts of the Golden Book stand as between the various groups, such as societies, synagogues, etc., and how large are they from individual persons? In order that we may obtain a clear picture, it is necessary to know how far persons have inscribed themselves, or whether groups have inscribed themselves It then says under expenditure: 5 % commission to the Colonial Bank. That is a sum which is not otherwise customary; there then follows a small sum for the newspapers; the chief sum goes to "Die Welt," and, what surprises me particularly, 5 % commission for the Territorial Centres. With regard to the stamps I have the following to remark: It is dangerous to have stamps of different sizes; for we have a guarantee against forgery only where the stamps are of small value. In my opinion, too, there lies a great legal difficulty in our permitting ourselves a system of stamps before we are even in Palestine. The simplest thing would be to introduce a system of receipts, so that one would have the right to issue receipts. As regards the report of Dr. Farbstein, you will know from the report that many projects were ready, but that the jurists were not yet agreed as to which form was the best. It will be best if you adopt the motion of the Commission, with a small alteration. I believe it would suffice if the nine members of the Commission examined the matter further, and I beg you to agree to it with the restriction which the Commission makes. (Applause.)
Rabinowitsch argues that it would be more dignified to inscribe in the Golden Book societies of a charitable, idealistic character, rather than, as is the custom, rich people, in order to please them. It also happens on various occasions that the anti-Zionist is inscribed in this book, which will for a long time become historical; that is unworthy.
Dr. Bruzkus criticises in the Russian language several passages of the report of the National Fund.
Dr. Tschlenoff: As has already rightly been said, much has already been spoken about the Jewish National Fund, but little as yet done for it. I am head of a district in Russia which works neither less nor more than the others, and I can say that in the course of time this district has contributed 12 % of the total sum. But I must nevertheless say that I am not satisfied with the activity of my district on behalf of the National Fund; but neither am I satisfied with my colleagues in the other countries.