No. 13 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
Mr. Marcus welcomed the meeting and set forth its purpose, whereupon Director Weber delivered the address. Taking as his point of departure a saying of Dr. Joel, Rabbi in Breslau, "The old rabbi has perished," he drew a parallel between the old and the modern rabbinate which by no means fell out in favour of the latter. The old rabbi was the true father of his congregation. A pattern of piety and goodness of heart. He was the judge in the community. He comforted the suffering, raised up the bowed down, put courage into the sick, and by his social activity won the confidence of all. The modern rabbis, on the other hand, do none of all this; instead they have borrowed from other confessions the gown and other externals. The speaker then turned against the abuse of dividing the members of the congregation into classes on solemn and mournful occasions alike, and reproached the rabbis in particular with neglecting the education of the young. The blame for these abuses lay with the manner in which rabbinical posts were filled, where not ability and fitness but patronage, and patronage alone, was decisive. But in other respects, too, the system of the trial sermon was not the right one. One must observe the rabbi's work on the spot, and appoint the best proven among the capable. (Cries of bravo and applause. The speaker is congratulated.) Thereupon Mr. Krausz, editor, took the floor. Scarcely, however, had he attempted to establish the right of the national parties to convene the meeting, when the long-prepared uproar broke loose on the part of the officials, who saw in the word "national" a challenge and an affront, since the chairman had declared that the rabbinical question would be considered only from a purely Jewish standpoint. For minutes the din, staged by a few brawlers, continued, and it almost seemed as though the opposition would break up the meeting. Only with difficulty were the gentlemen brought to order. Mr. Krausz then went on: "Under the statute of the Israelite Congregation we should properly have no right to hold today's meeting, since we are neither experts nor trustees. But experts and trustees are appointed by the Board of the Congregation, and are consequently recruited last of all from among those who have an interest in the filling of the rabbinical posts. Had interested parties really been called upon, why then not the Zionists and the other national groups, who surely have a lively interest in the appointment? The rabbinical question had already been acute two years ago. But since at that time only one post was to be filled, and both Dr. Güdemann and Dr. Bloch wished to place their protégés, no agreement was reached. Now a compromise had been concluded, and no protest would avail any longer. But this proceeding must be made known. And yet the Vienna Rabbinical Seminary has pupils who would be an ornament to any congregation. Why, then, roam afar? Why set oneself in opposition to so compact a body as the national groups?"
The next speaker, Mr. Fleischmann, is a representative of Viennese Orthodoxy. He took Dr. Güdemann's part, declared that one might be a good Jew and yet not be national, and moved a resolution that the Board of the Congregation be urged to keep the Jewish element in view in deciding the rabbinical question.
Professor Ehrmann took the floor and declared that criticism might well be exercised, but that the bona fides of the Board of the Congregation should not be called in question. Each of the candidates set every lever in motion to get through; but no one could maintain that patronage and prejudice held sway. The rabbi was a functionary of religion. National sentiment was not required, but neither did it constitute a ground for exclusion.
Thereupon Dr. L. Kahn delivered one of his most felicitous and brilliant agitational speeches, to which the success of the meeting is in no small part to be ascribed. He turned especially against the Orthodox, and set forth that in Judaism there had never been any distinction between religion and national feeling. If at one time religion had saved the nation from destruction (Jochanan ben Sakkai), at another national feeling had rendered the same service to religion (the Maccabees). What no one had succeeded in doing, Zionism accomplished. It gave the Jewish youth an ideal and led it back to Judaism. For this very reason, however, the educators of the young must also be pious, religious, national; they must be Zionists.
After a correction by Director Heller, who assured the Zionists of his sympathies and, by a story from his period of office in Düsseldorf, attempted to excuse Dr. David, Dr. Bernhardt in a few words moved the following resolution:
In consideration of the fact that for decades, in ever-increasing measure, the process of religious apostasy and betrayal of the people has been going on within the Jewish population of Vienna, and above all in the circles of the academic intelligentsia and the well-to-do middle class,
in consideration of the fact that knowledge of our glorious history of culture and of our religious and national tradition is ever declining,
in consideration of the fact that almost everywhere we meet with rigid and unconquerable indolence towards public Jewish affairs,
in consideration of the fact that the impoverishment of the broad Jewish masses, and in particular of the artisan class, is assuming appalling proportions,
in consideration of the fact that all these lamentable phenomena could not have come to light had the rabbis, through the influence due to them, prevented the servile flattery of the moneyed aristocracy and the neglect and contempt of the less prosperous classes of the people, the inexcusable neglect of the Jewish education of the young, or even the systematic working towards a Germanizing de-Judaization,
in consideration of the fact that the mighty national movement, which of late has set in ever more powerfully and embraces the whole globe, and which strives to secure for millions of our brethren the long-desired homestead and for West European Jewry the return to a Jewish nationhood grown foreign to it, may meet with hostile opposition from no honest Jew,
today's meeting protests against the unworthy manner of filling the Vienna rabbinate, and against the back-stairs politics and the jobbery of patronage asserting themselves on this occasion, and raises its voice at the eleventh hour to hold all competent factors responsible should the office of rabbi be entrusted to persons who, contrary to the precepts of the Jewish religion, combat Zionism in zealot fashion, misuse the pulpit for un-Jewish propaganda, even in the presence of child listeners, and disturb the peace laboriously preserved in our congregation,
