No. 21 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
...fed by these institutions, as the British fleet receives its recruits from the training-ships, or as the provinces are supplied with rabbis from the Jewish seminaries. A direct line would thus have led from education to emigration. But no! The "Ica" wishes at the same time to legalise its illegal loan banks, as well as industries, factories, etc., and so these too are doubtless "calculated to fit Jews for emigration"! How a loan bank "educates Jews for emigration," except by encouraging them to run away with their debts, I do not understand, and industries and factories surely help to hold them fast at home in work. Model dwelling-houses are not the most obvious way of promoting emigration; factories for artificial flowers hardly train real gardeners. It will tax the whole of Mr. Lousada's ingenuity to fit all his 193 institutions into the present Bill, even if he gets it through, nor will Mr. Weinberg, the wandering angel of the "Ica," be able to find anyone on the whole earth to bless. But if the "Ica" is honest about "education for emigration," the Bill is quite superfluous.
"Indirect" Institutions.
No one will deny that to make the colonists fit for emigration falls within the lawful range of a colonisation society's sphere of action. Far from questioning this, I have always maintained that it was Baron Hirsch's great mistake to take his colonists unripe. Therefore, if the institutions of the Ica really made the colonists fit for emigration, Sir Edward Fry — of this I am sure — would never have declared these institutions indirect, since the original Memorandum clearly permits the formation of emigration agencies and aid societies occupied with the training of emigrants, and these institutions would thereby lead directly from training to emigration. What Sir Edward Fry does describe as unlawful, however, are such institutions as are so indirect that they do not lead thither. Hence the new Bill that is demanded is either not necessary, or it is a deception, and when it has happily passed both Houses of Parliament, it will only make the chief activity of the "Ica" appear all the more unlawful. So much for Mr. Lousada's cleverness.
The Millions of the Anglo-Jewish Association.
But I have not yet done with the Bill; for the second edition contains a still more important alteration. You know that two million pounds sterling form the original capital of the "Ica," while seven millions came to it later by deed of trust. Mr. Lousada's first Bill embraced both sums and both documents. In the second edition the 7 millions and the deed of trust have dropped out, and Mr. Lousada declares to the "Anglo-Jewish Association" that they could do what they liked with the seven millions — which were expressly bequeathed for the benefit of the Russian Jews — and that the whole purpose of the Bill was really only to enable the "Ica" to do with the 2 millions all that it is already entitled to do with the 7. Mr. Lousada errs once again. I have had the deed of trust before my eyes, and it does indeed declare that the 7 millions are to be applied to the welfare of the Russian Jews in general, but it adds: " . . . . and principally to the promotion of the emigration of the Russian Jews."
The Height of Irony.
Mr. Lousada lays the chief stress "on, for the welfare"; I lay the stress where it actually belongs: on the word "principally."
What does "principally" mean? Principally does not mean the half — 3 out of 7; — it means about 5 out of 7. So long, therefore, as Mr. Lousada cannot prove that five-sevenths of the income from this source are applied to the emigration of the Russian Jews — and I know the balance-sheet of the "Ica" well enough to know that he can prove nothing of the kind — he had better make haste to put this torn-out piece back into the Bill and produce a third edition of it. The confession made in the first edition cannot be recanted in the second, and must be restored in the third. But what am I saying? In the fourth edition, for there is already a third, with the words "except in Europe," which were added to prevent the immigrants from being brought here. This precaution, against which eminent philanthropists like Mr. F. D. Mocatta and Mr, Hermann Landau raised objections on large-hearted grounds, is the only one which faithfully corresponds to Baron Hirsch's wishes, and its insertion in the "Ica" Bill is the height of irony.
Baron Hirsch and the "Ica".
Baron Hirsch was so anxious to get the oppressed Jews out of Europe that he would not allow them to be conveyed from one country into another. His trustees follow him conscientiously; they will not bring the Jews from one country of Europe into another, but neither will they bring them anywhere else. This recalls the story of the young Christian servant-girl whose mistress had impressed upon her not to boil the fowl in milk. When the meal is served, no fowl appears. "Where is the fowl?" asks the mistress of the house. "It is uncooked; you told me not to boil it in milk." And so Mary has not cooked it at all.
As matters now stand, the "Ica" asks for permission to support schools, farms, loan banks, factories, etc., which may be regarded as suitable for making Jews fit for emigration and for promoting their settlement anywhere except in Europe. But how can any institution make you fit for emigration anywhere except Europe? If you are fit to toil in Canada and till the soil, you are also fit to toil in England and till the soil. One might as well speak of a training-ship that brings up sailors who can serve on any ship except British ships; or of a cookery school that teaches its pupils to boil fowls, "except in milk."
But mark well, this is a point that concerns not emigrants but education. And since the assertion that education is promoted for the purpose of emigration is a deception, and since a deception always avenges itself, we arrive at the curious result that a Jew who has attended an "Ica school" in Russia, Roumania or Galicia, or has worked in its workshops, or has borrowed money from its loan banks, or has lived in the model dwellings, or has made artificial flowers, or has gone schnorring to Mr. Weinberg, is for ever excluded from being settled in any other part of Europe, for he has been, in the words