Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 37 · 11 September 1903
2printed page
scan 2 of 20
Facsimile · scan 2 of 20
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 37.

(continued from page 1)

...Jews has been since the downfall of our kingdom, if they would recall our embittered life in the ghettos, which in the words of Shylock's sufferings was the whole brand of our race; if they would remember all the persecutions by fire and sword, the yellow badges of shame we were forced to wear, all the parts of buffoon forced upon us during the Christian carnival; if they would remember that the heads of the communities had to appear yearly in the Christian city in order to receive a box on the ear, that the English Jews were but bondmen of the King, of which the prayer for the royal family in the prayer-books still bears witness; if they would reflect that for fully four centuries the Jews had no right of residence at all, under what difficulties we were permitted to return, what hard struggle we had to fight out for our rights; and then finally, if they would now consider the offer made to us, to choose for ourselves the fairest and most valuable land in East Africa, there to establish a British colony with Jewish home rule, Jewish national customs and a Jewish governor — then even the bitterest opponents of the new project will admit that the mere offer is already a triumph for our organisation. And it signifies not only a triumph for Zionism; it is also a moral triumph for England and a victory for humanity. Not we Jews alone, but the men of all lands who strive for the uplifting of the human race, will surely be grateful for it to the great nation which with this ray of light has illumined the dark gloom of our time.

The Schehechejonu of the Opponents of the Proposal.

What wonder, then, that even the opposing members of the Actions Committee said a Schehechejonu at the reading of the letter from the Foreign Office! "Ex Africa semper quid novi," says the Latin proverb. And the dark continent still holds many surprises. Perhaps it is reserved for it to be the continent of light. But it is not only on the fact that we are now a recognised political body, called to negotiate on colonisation and one that will also be in a position some day to negotiate on colonisation in Palestine — not on this alone does my assertion rest that we are nearer to Palestine.

Von Plehwe's Letter and the Ica.

The Congress brought yet another historic document to light: the letter of Herr von Plehwe, which clearly defines Russia's policy towards Zionism. It must surely have caused consternation among those who hold fast to the principle that the Jewish question can be solved only in Russia. To us Zionists, however, it is nothing new.

Did I not make public at a Zionist meeting the secret agreement between Russia and the Jewish Colonization Association, under which Russia declared herself willing to help the Jews to emigrate? Do you not remember the proposal of the Council of Ministers to pay 5 roubles 84 kopecks for every emigrating Jew? It was not Russia that then refused to consent, but the Ica. Russia now goes so far as to promise to use her diplomatic influence so that we may obtain Palestine.

Russia's Good Will and Her Advantage.

I do not doubt Russia's good will at all, for it is beyond question that the proposal of an emigration is meant to serve only her own advantage. It is Russia's national policy to Russify her whole population. But to Russify the Jewish Pale of Settlement is beyond even Russia's strength. Against the Jew force is useless. Freedom alone could Russify the Jew. It is true that if all the Jews were transplanted to Palestine, Russia might feel the loss keenly and even regret it; but such a transaction can never take place. I believe that even the most emphatic Zionist orators do not picture the thing to themselves as a sudden, magical change, somewhat thus: on Monday morning 5 millions of Jews in Russia, and on Thursday afternoon 5 millions in Palestine. The most that can happen is a slow movement from Russia to Palestine. By opening her doors of exit Russia will find it easier to digest the Pale of Settlement without causing a sudden dislocation in her industry and her finances. Palestine, in turn, by opening her gates of entry, will gradually rise in prosperity, to the profit and benefit of the Sultan's revenues. Indeed, quite apart from all religious feeling, and from the political standpoint alone, the Basle Programme is so reasonable that some day it must be carried out. Russia has a population which she does not need; Palestine, her neighbour beyond the Black Sea, is very thinly peopled. Our solution is so simple, stands in such harmony with Russia's present policy, is of such advantage to Turkey, so soothing to the mutual jealousy of the Powers, so useful to England and America, whose immigration problems it solves at a stroke, that if this manifestly clear plan were not put into effect, it must be a mad world in which we live.

The Attitude of Turkey. — El Arish.

And I have the feeling that if only our Jews would unite all their thoughts and millions, all their forces upon a single point, and bring their whole influence to bear, we could say with certainty: "Next year in Jerusalem." Since the Fifth Congress our beloved leader Dr. Herzl had twice been summoned by the Sultan to Constantinople. The Sultan, however, despite his sympathetic attitude towards our people, was not yet ready to recognise fully the advantages that would accrue to him from home rule in Palestine; he has not yet perceived that our wish to go to Palestine would also mean a great advantage for him. When a man asks a woman to be his wife, it is not only he who takes; he also gives himself. When we approach the Sultan for Palestine, we present him with a valuable, tax-paying population. His Majesty is evidently agreeable to our settling here and there, without Jewish rights of our own; but to dwell here or there and be regarded as strangers is not the Zionist solution of the Jewish question, even though these plots of land were in Palestine. Therefore Dr. Herzl resolved upon a new step. Only after our leader despaired of changing the Sultan's views within any foreseeable time, only when he believed that, if we must wait for Palestine, any place would be better suited than Russia, and when he had come to the view that, if we could obtain Jewish rights, this recognition of Jewish nationality must shorten our road to Palestine by half and make of us, instead of a motley crowd, a people — only then did he turn to Sinai. There lies a small part of Egypt, called El Arish, which formerly formed part of Palestine. Here Dr. Herzl believed he could take a step forward on truly Palestinian soil. El Arish itself, apart from other disadvantages, is too small to have any practical importance for colonisation; therefore Dr. Herzl turned his attention to the whole Sinai Peninsula. A great religious interest binds Sinai to the memory of our great Lawgiver, while the nearness of the peninsula, as far as Palestine is con-