Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 37.
Zangwill's Consolation.
But perhaps there are some here who shared their anguish. To these I say, as I would have said to the Russians: "My children! Let us suppose that the day on which, for the first time in 1800 years, you have received a fair and fruitful land to dwell in under a Jewish head and under the protection of the British flag — let us suppose that this day is a new Tischah be Ab.
But even this day has not yet come. And when the commission returns with the report that the land is suitable for Jewish colonisation, then another Congress must decide whether we accept the plan at all. Unite your forces, appeal to Zionist public opinion, and when it comes to the vote, make yourselves a majority.
Or if you insist on keeping a new Tischah be Ab, you should have done so one or two months ago, when it was resolved in Russia to hold Zionism down, as was confirmed by the secret circular published in the "Times." You could also read it in the letter to Dr. Herzl. Herr von Plehwe will have no Zionism if it is merely an organisation that fosters Jewish national consciousness. He will not tolerate it if it is not a real, living movement for the emigration of the Jews from Russia. Therefore, if you do not show that you are conveying people out of Russia, the organisation will be destroyed, the shares confiscated, the meetings forbidden; and since Turkey will not permit immigration into Palestine, and England and New York will likewise shut their gates, it would be a blessing for you to have East Africa to send the people to, so that Russia would let your movement live while you await the opening of the gates of Palestine. And why did you not keep this Tischah be Ab some years ago, when the Sultan closed the gates of Palestine? If you were not so childish, you ought to have wept then. Yes, the gates of Palestine are closed. And when the door is shut in your face, what would you do? The only way is to come in by the back door. Now, as you see, Dr. Herzl thought of El Arish. But there is yet another way of acting in such a case, namely, to walk away. That is especially necessary when it is a question of a door behind which an Oriental has something to sell. I myself have bargained in a Turkish shop, and when I had lost patience and walked away, the proprietor ran after me. But now let us assume the worst case, that the dreadful Tischah be Ab had come on which the Zionist leaders feel themselves compelled to found a Zionist colony in British East Africa. Is that a step backward? No, it is a step forward. Palestine may remain closed to us for centuries; must we therefore stand still? It is certainly a long detour by way of East Africa, but sometimes the short cut is the longest way, and the longest — the shortest. Many Zionists who are against East Africa would raise no objection to Cyprus or Chaldea, because they lie nearer; and Dr. Gaster himself took part in the colonisation scheme for Anatolia and the neighbouring countries. But there is not only a geographical, a spatial nearness, but a moral one as well. A man in London with a ten-pound note is nearer to New York than a man in Chicago without a dollar. And a flourishing Jewish community on the fertile soil of 18 000 square miles will be nearer to Palestine than all the Zionist societies that talk the whole day long. Not that I am of opinion that the Jewish East Africans would have to emigrate to Palestine; but their territory would become the centre of Jewish power, and a part of its surplus of energy and population could go thither. In Judaism everything is topsy-turvy, and whereas with other peoples the mother country founds a colony, here the colony would find the mother country.
East Africa a Second Basle.
East Africa is not Palestine, but neither is Basle. Why did we go to Basle? I wonder that some Zionists did not insist on the Congress being held in Jerusalem. East Africa might become our Basle. For eighteen centuries we have prayed for Palestine, and now that we have once resolved to work for this goal, why are we so impatient, why do we again expect miracles? We have only begun our march to Zion. The affairs of peoples are reckoned not by years but by centuries. The Almighty Himself needed forty years to lead our forefathers to Palestine, and Moische Rabbenu could only behold the Promised Land. Why, indeed, should you weep if you cannot get there? Rather be glad that you are preparing the way for your great-grandchildren! Remember the noble saying of the Talmud: "It is not thine to complete the work, neither hast thou the right to desist from it!" Oh yes, I know that some Zionists fear the offer will be too good, so that the Jews will feel comfortable and forget Zion. But what a poor opinion they have of Zionism! Does not Dr. Herzl feel comfortable enough in Vienna? And has he forgotten Zion? All four quarters of the globe are represented at the Congress. I myself have received mandates from Roumania, Cochin-China, Canada and Cape Town. We have even seen picturesquely clad delegates from the Caucasus, on whose breasts daggers and cartridges glittered. Will all these lands think of Zion, and this one Jewish land alone, with Jewish customs and a Jewish head, forget Zion? The South African millionaires are well enough off, and yet it is a South African Zionist millionaire who has just given the money to call the great Hebrew Encyclopaedia into being. Do you believe there will be no East African millionaire to support the colonisation of Palestine? Remember further that the Zionists are not paying a Heller for the East African Commission. The Shekolim were collected for Palestine alone, and everyone admits that until the shekel-payers consent to the money being used for East Africa, we may not take a single Heller from our treasury. The new costs will be met from a new fund. An American who is among us has made the beginning, and at the moment the vote for the commission was cast pressed 500 Francs into my hand. Perhaps Mr. Mosely, who sends out so many commissions for England, will see the beauty of the task of helping England and the Jews at a single stroke. In any case I believe that even the capital for the East African colonisation will be found without drawing upon our present finances. Many people who can see the necessity of a colony with Jewish customs surely grasp the necessity of a Jewish place of refuge, a night-shelter. Our plan answers to both purposes, like the well-known piece of furniture that serves as a bed by night and a chest of drawers by day. Dr. Gaster, in his otherwise very fine appeal to us, in which he demands that we hold fast to our hopes of Zion, commits a curious oversight when he says that it should be the highest aspiration of a Jew to become an Englishman or an American citizen. But it is precisely inhabitants of these countries who are beginning to strike at us! And when the British Government, with its wise policy, offers us uninhabited territory, we surely must not let slip the opportunity of making this territory as Jewish as possible.