Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 39 · 25 September 1903
5printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 39 — "Die Welt" — Page 5

(continued from page 4)

…of the movement, the shadings by party became ever more pronounced; they grew with the movement like the individual cells of a complete and single organism. The grouping by parties was anything but regrettable; it enabled all adherents of the movement to strive towards the one goal without doing violence to their convictions or disowning them before the world.

The resolution of the Congress has shifted the boundaries and thrown the existing parties into confusion. It has wounded what is dearest to us, struck our chief and fundamental aim to the heart, and grievously injured the liveliest and most violently pulsing nerve of our self-consciousness. The struggle of parties, that living and fruitful struggle, came to an end; a schism set in. Members of one and the same faction divided and ranged themselves in hostility against one another. While the Misrachist Rabbi Reines, the father, voted with the majority for East Africa, Rabbi Reines, the son, joined the minority of the "Nay-sayers," that famous minority which showed so much courage for the preservation of our ideal, and to which the most distinguished of its opponents — among them Herzl and Nordau too — were obliged to bear witness that it embodied the national aspiration of the Jewish people. And many of the "Cherus" group protested energetically against Syrkin when he sought to speak for East Africa in their name.

Since the close of the Congress the dismay of the Palestinian Zionists grows greater with every day. In their innermost being they feel, as it were, an oppression that weighs heavily upon their conviction. They have hitherto been accustomed to hold fast to the conviction that the rebirth of the people is bound up with that of the land, so that the slightest attempt to separate the one from the other calls forth the most vehement resistance. We regard the resolution on the East Africa commission as such an attempt, and our national feeling rebels against every possibility, even against the remotest suggestion, of such an attempt to separate the rebirth of the people from that of the land. It was out of this feeling and out of this national insight that we fought the Cyprus project years ago; from this insight flows the strength that drives us back from the Africa project.

The consolation that a Jewish State in Africa does not exclude one in Zion cannot set our minds at rest. The settlement of an uncultivated country requires an enormous sum of gigantic energies. Once our people has exhausted its strength upon it, it will scarcely be in a position any longer to labour for its rebirth in the homeland. We do indeed trust in the marvellous vitality of our people, and believe in its giant strength and its capacity to realise the ideal of two thousand years, the ideal of returning to its historic land and resuming its political life there. But we do not believe that our people is equal to such an exertion when it is a question of settling a new country, foreign to it, with which no historic bond from the past unites it.

— But if you do not believe in the success of East Africa, we shall be told, why then all this noise?

Those who ask thus forget one thing: whether the colonisation succeeds or not, it will in any case exhaust the strength of the people, and the people will never again muster strength enough to attain its chief goal, Zion.

— East Africa, we are told, will be a "night-shelter," a preliminary station, where our people will prepare itself for political life in its historic home.

Nor can this console us. The national life of a people, the Jewish people included, does not rest upon politics alone. It is made up of many other socio-economic factors, which play at least as important a part as politics. Even if one could educate a people politically in one country for another country — which does not sufficiently commend itself to our understanding — it is nevertheless impossible to prepare a people in one country for the social and economic life of another country in which different geographical and climatic conditions prevail. We do not, to be sure, neglect to educate our people in the lands of its dispersion for its political and socio-economic life in Palestine. But it is in this dispersion that we happen to live, and we cannot help ourselves otherwise. We know how hard it is to educate our people in the Golus for national life in all its directions; but we did not come here of our own free will. We know it: our life here is abnormal, and so is the education of our people; therefore we seek to attain the very least. But to tear a people out of one country and lead it into another Golus, even an autonomous one, for the purpose of political education for yet another country — this we hold to be a Utopia, a nursery tale. And therefore — in spite of all the assurances of our Leader that Africa is not Zion and never will be — we regard the resolution to send an expedition to Africa as an attempt to sever the renaissance of our people from that of our land, and we do not agree that the question should have been laid before the Zionist Congress at all.

Zionism strives for a home for the Jewish people in Palestine secured by public law. The founding of a home, even a secured one, for a part of the people in another country does not belong within the sphere of Zionism. It contradicts the Basle Programme. We by no means hold that this programme is a second written tradition which may not be shaken; but so long as the Basle Programme has not been altered, not a hair's breadth may be departed from it.

We do not possess Palestine, and what are we to do until we have attained it? To this we reply: Palestine is dearer to us than any other country with charter and autonomy. If we cannot obtain the charter for Palestine, we must work there without it; we must seek to obtain from the Sultan the possibility of continuing the work of colonisation hitherto carried on, under better conditions. Above all, an economic centre must be created on the basis of agriculture, industry and commerce. With the growth of the centre new forces too will be added; the extension and development of the economic centre will make the political element necessary within it, and will also make it possible for this centre to become a political Jewish State. An economic centre in Africa likewise means a Golus, as in any other country. Even an autonomous Golus remains always a Golus.

For fifteen years we have waged a struggle against the "Ica," because instead of centralising the people, as we Zionists desire, it scatters it still further. But now we wish to attempt a new dispersion, and may not accuse others on that account. It is said: the "Ica" does not colonise upon a political basis, it works without any political plan, whereas we have a political plan. But we stand before a dilemma: either Palestine is to be exchanged for Uganda and a Jewish centre created in the latter — in which case this contradicts the Basle Programme. Or else Africa is merely a night-shelter, where we are to be protected for the time being and