Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 39 · 25 September 1903
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 39

(continued from page 5)

…could educate the people — in which case we ourselves create a new Golus, we Zionists ourselves, who demand first and foremost a centre in our homeland.

"With all the travelling money that the Jewish people spends upon its wanderings, it could long since have founded a Jewish State." So, roughly, Zangwill expressed himself. And he is only too right. But his reproach applies not to the "Ica" alone, but in equal measure to the Africa project. If it is a matter of indifference to Zangwill whether it be Palestine or Uganda, so long as we have a Jewish State, then he is no Zionist. But if he holds Uganda to be a night-shelter, then he is recommending a new wandering...

*

It is true that thousands of wretched and hungry people stand in need of protection; but Zionism must not be degraded into a philanthropic undertaking. It is hoped to divert to Africa the thousands who emigrate yearly to America, and with them to found the Jewish State. These emigrants, however, go to a civilised, well-ordered State, in the confidence of finding their bread there at once, without having to give up anything of their habits of life. Do the adherents of Africa really believe that this stream of wanderers will allow itself to be turned away from America and towards Africa, where no civilisation exists, where such must first be newly created? Do they really believe that they can found a Jewish State with these wanderers? What driving force do they then presuppose in them, that should spur them on to transform a waste, uncultivated land into one of civilisation? The very same England that promises us autonomy in Africa has deprived a small people, which for centuries lived for its freedom, of the right of self-determination. And we do not believe that the word autonomy, however fine it may sound, is capable of enticing a great part of a people to go to an unknown, wholly uncultivated country, which has not the faintest relation to its history and its past, in order to create civilisation there. Still more incredible does it seem to us that this word should possess such magic that a people would undertake the gigantic exertion of bringing life into an uncultivated country in the consciousness that, the work once accomplished, it is to leave this country and go to its homeland.

*

Twice Herzl negotiated with the Porte. The concessions made to him did not correspond to the requirements of the Basle Programme, and Herzl saw himself obliged to reject them. Now England offers us something which likewise is not in harmony with the Basle Programme, and yet Herzl brought it before the Congress. "It is not Zion and never will be!" he himself said with reference to England's offer, when it was moved that the Colonial Bank be drawn upon for East Africa. From this it follows that Africa does not correspond to the Basle Programme. We find ourselves once more before a dilemma: certainly, the Turkish offer lacked the concession of the point "secured by public law," as the Basle Programme requires, and therefore it could not be accepted. But now the English offer lacks the point "Palestine," and for that reason it does not correspond to the Basle Programme. How then could the Turkish offer be rejected on account of its contradiction with the Basle Programme?

*

An Africa speaker permitted himself the following logic from the platform of the Congress: "The Basle Programme demands a 'home' and 'Palestine.' Now England gives us a part of it, the home; this we ought to accept." He forgot in so saying that a night-shelter is no synonym for a home. And again a dilemma: Either the "Africans" want an "asylum," and their first and last aspiration remains, as before, "Zion" — but in England's offer they have neither "Zion" nor a home; or they see in Africa a real home, not a mere night-shelter — but then they set it in the place of Zion. In any case the Africa proposal stands in no nearer relation to Zionism than the proposal of Turkey.

*

Some are of opinion that at the Congress it was not a question of the colonisation of East Africa at all, but merely of the dispatch of an expedition. Nordau himself was of this view, and divided the question into three points: the dispatch of an expedition, the question of the night-shelter, and the question of settlement in East Africa. Nordau protested against the reproach of Talmudic hair-splitting. And yet we cannot spare him the reproach of paradox. Above all the Congress ought to have been asked whether it could approve the founding of a night-shelter; only then could the question be put whether a commission should be appointed. The rejection of the first question would have made the putting of the second impossible. It is surely clear. An expedition to explore the country is not sent out from a purely geographical and scientific interest, but for the purpose of ascertaining whether the country is suited to the founding of a Jewish State. If the expedition finds the country suitable, we shall, as a matter of course, settle it. On this supposition we ought first to have been asked whether we desire a night-shelter. The adoption of the motion for the appointment of a commission therefore involved an affirmative answer to the second question, that of founding a night-shelter. The matter cannot be taken otherwise. We know it: if the commission judges the country favourably, the affair will be submitted to the Congress. If, as has been said, we hold this settlement to be contrary to the Basle Programme, then for the same reason we ought to have refrained from the vote as well.

We are often inclined to do things that we abhor in others. The "Ica" sends expeditions year in, year out, to remote regions to explore their fitness for purposes of colonisation. Now we commit the same error. To-day we send out an expedition to explore East Africa, to-morrow we shall have Brazil explored; to-day we turn to England, to-morrow we shall turn to some other Government. Wherein, then, do we differ from the "Ica," which we combat — with full right — as anti-Zionist, nay, as anti-national? As often as we raise against the "Ica" the — just — reproach that it needlessly squanders its strength in other countries, while there is after all so much fruitful work to be done in Palestine, the "Ica" answers us that it is not possible at present to work in Palestine. This answer did not deter us from fighting the "Ica," in the consciousness that something can after all be done in Palestine. Now we have the "Ica's" answer in our own mouths and do the very thing it has done. We say: in Palestine we cannot work according to our preconceived plan, so we must seek out and explore a night-shelter elsewhere. That our foundation is distinguished from those of the "Ica" by autonomy alters nothing in the matter. Autonomy would have value for us only in our own land, not abroad, in a "night-shelter." And we persist in the thought which will not leave our minds: in a night-shelter