No. 39 — "Die Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
…we need no autonomy. If we are to have autonomy, it cannot be in a night-shelter, but in a firmly founded settlement that we may call our own for ever, in the new State of the Jewish people, upon its ancient soil, for which it has yearned for two thousand years.
Already at the Congress the adherents of the East Africa project met us with many a curious line of argument. Thus some held: all nations have colonies; why should we have no colonies and pursue no colonial policy? The others, to be sure, each have their mother country as well, but with us Jews many things are wont to happen the other way about, and so we might found colonies first and a metropolis afterwards. We confess that we can combat such an argument in no other way than with a shrug of the shoulders, with a feeling of astonishment and pity. An unhappy people like ourselves, which calls nothing in the world its own, is actually to pursue a colonial policy! For decades the United States of North America stood aloof from all colonial policy, and only under the compulsion of mighty events of war were they swept along by the current of colonial policy. This, however, altered the political life of the American Republic from the ground up. Do our politicians not know that it is one of the most important requirements of a colonial policy that a powerful navy should always stand ready for its protection?
From these and similar absurdities we learn one thing: the strange inclination towards politics which has taken such strong hold of us in recent years has led us into the false step of the East Africa project, and everyone who declares a sound policy to be dependent upon social and economic conditions is decried as unpolitical.
The social and economic basis must be created first. The political will follow of itself, as the urgent outflow of life. This basis cannot be in Africa, but only in Palestine. There our work of liberation can proceed rapidly. If, on the other hand, we found ever so many Jewish colonies, even autonomous ones, which do not lie in our fatherland, we shall remain in the Golus none the less — even if "with autonomy!"
*
In his review of the Sixth Congress, Dr. Ernst Tuch writes as follows on the East Africa project in the "Freistatt" (Munich):
"The English Government has offered the Zionists a territory in East Africa lying between Nairobi and the Nau Escarpment, on the railway that comes from Mombassa, for 'an autonomous settlement with Jewish administration, Jewish local government and a Jewish chief official at its head, all, of course, under British sovereign supervision. — No one who did not attend the Congress can picture to himself the tremendous impression this offer made upon those present. It was at once rightly recognised that the mere discussion of this so magnanimous proposal signified a departure from the Basle Programme, which contemplates Palestine, and Palestine only, for the settlement. All the delegates stood before the question of conscience whether, by accepting the proposal, nay, even by the mere dispatch of a commission to examine the territory, they were not surrendering the ideal they had defended for six years with such boundless devotion. When, after a long and spirited debate, the dispatch of a commission to East Africa was resolved upon by a roll-call vote of 295 to 177, the minority left the session in protest. The scenes of agitation, of despair that by this resolution the dear ideal of Zion might be torn from the hearts of the Jews, were positively harrowing. They show with what primal love the Russian Jews in particular cling to 'the land of the fathers,' which they wish to make the land of their children. But they show also how much the whole movement is still borne along by feelings, and how little political understanding is present in wide circles of Zionism. It is not yet possible to foresee what verdict the commission will pronounce, nor whether the next Congress, even in the event of a favourable decision, would finally consent to an East African colonisation. In any case this new turn of affairs has created for Zionism a great extension of its field of work; yet on the other hand it cannot be deemed out of the question that a mighty wedge will be driven into the masses of mutually antagonistic elements, welded together only with difficulty by the fascinating personality of the Leader."
*
An Interview with Sir H. H. Johnston on East Africa. (From the Jewish Chron.)
Sir Johnston is, as is well known, an authority on African affairs, and on East African affairs in particular. He is by no means hostilely disposed towards the Jews, since he is even related to Jews by family ties. The interview of the correspondent of the "Jew. Chr." with Sir Johnson is therefore certainly of interest:
"I believe," asked the correspondent, "you approve of the plan of founding a Jewish colony in British East Africa?"
"Oh no" — was the emphatic answer — "I regard it as altogether impracticable and unwise."
Sir Harry Johnston then began to enumerate a series of reasons against the whole plan.
"If one," he said, pacing excitedly up and down, "if one takes into account the great area of the country which, by virtue of treaties or other rights, must be left to the natives, Negroes and Negroids, there certainly remains not enough room for a Jewish colony of any size whatever, if one is at the same time to consider the claims of the resident British subjects. By British subjects I understand immigrants of all races, colours and religions who betake themselves from any part of the British Empire to the healthy highlands of East Africa in order to settle there. I regard the Jew who lives in any part of the British Empire as a British subject of equal standing in law. Such a man could go to East Africa as I or you might, obtain land from the Government by purchase or grant, and settle under the ordinary forms of British settlement, without requiring a community of his own with special laws. For the non-British Jews I naturally care much less, and I believe it would not be just to hand over a large part of the land in East Africa accessible to European colonisation to a foreign community, that is, to non-British Jews — a land that was acquired at the dear price of the money and blood of British subjects — Jews, Mohammedans and Hindus."
"If I understand you rightly, Sir Harry, there are Jews there already?"
"Naturally. Several officers were Jews, I am sure of that, although I do not concern myself with religion."
"In all questions concerning settlement in East Africa," declared Sir Harry Johnston, "we must take two claims into account: those of the natives, and of the Hindus or Indian subjects, who everything
