Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 42 · 16 October 1903
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 42 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

…mortal danger for our movement. Since an enormous number of Zionist workers see in every resolution of the Congress a law that suffers no commentary, the Zionists will regard Africa as the chief object of their activity and will divert their chief attention, perhaps for many years, from the chief task, that is, from the work for Zion. Such a diversion to one side on the part of some would provoke a deep split. In the souls of those Zionists who are conscious of their task the Africa question will provoke a division, which easily leads to disillusionment, which paralyses energy and self-confidence."

"Do you believe that Dr. Herzl has lost something of his prestige?"

S.: "If Dr. Herzl's standing has somewhat declined with a certain section of the Zionists, it has risen immeasurably in the eyes of Jewry as a whole. His untiring energy, his flaming love, his sympathy, his faithfulness have opened all hearts to him and made him a national hero; that even his opponents cannot deny."

"How do you explain the circumstance that only the Russian delegates voted against East Africa?"

S.: "That is a very complicated question. I will say only that here the difference in the outlook upon the world of our Eastern and Western Zionists came plainly to light. The Western ones wanted merely a national centre, wherever it might be; Palestine was merely "dear" to them. If one cannot get Palestine and Africa seems attainable, then one can put up with Africa too. Many of them openly confessed that it was a matter of complete indifference to them where the Jewish State should be, in Palestine or in Africa. But the Russian delegates, who stand nearer to the mass of the people, have grown up with the traditions of the people, and know more closely the spirit of the Jewish teaching as well as of Jewish history, know that the sympathies of the people lie on the side of Zion, that its ideals are closely bound up with its unforgettable homeland, and, faithfully serving the views of their people, they withstood the temptation, and like Napoleon they said: "To thee I give half the world, but Zion I keep for myself alone."

"What must the Nay-sayers do now?"

S.: "We Nay-sayers will by no means oppose the realisation of the Chamberlain project. Judaeus sum et nihil judaei mihi alienum est. We merely find that Zionists who have inscribed Zion upon their banner may not devote their forces to this cause. Even the poor prospects for the near future by no means give us the right to undertake something new. Precisely in view of the danger we must cling fast to our banner; the storm-clouds will pass, and our star will shine brightly once again. In this sense we Nay-sayers will also work. We must also take into consideration that the East Africa question is only in the phase of diplomatic negotiations, which lie outside the sphere of activity of the societies. The latter can therefore set this question aside, without harm to it, and continue their former work.

To withdraw East Africa from the field of vision of our societies must now be our task. Further, the transplanting of a certain part of the Jewish people to Africa does not belong to the Basle Programme. This standpoint must be made clear to all who let themselves be seduced by the new project. We must now proceed zealously to the elucidation of the essence of the Zionist doctrine, of its historical foundation, of its connection with the ideals of the people and with the way of thinking of the masses. It is necessary that Zion should fill the whole soul of the Zionist; all other aspirations will then be crowded out of themselves.

Let the whole mighty non-Zionist mass, which until now has stood aloof from the national interests, be interested in the East Africa project. This mass alone has strength enough to carry out the mightiest plans. We Zionists must preserve our forces for our own cause."

Dr. Sapir's personal opinion of the Congress might be summed up as follows:

England's proposal is naturally a very gratifying fact and deserves to be carried out at once, should the conditions permit. But in view of the fact that the Basle Programme sees the solution of the Jewish question only in Zion, that the transfer of large masses of the people to Africa will demand the exertion of all our forces and means and may draw the bankruptcy of Zionism in its train, the realisation of this important project ought to be laid before a general Jewish Congress (heads of communities, representatives of the charitable and colonisation societies, Alliance, Allianz, B'nei B'rith) scholars and so forth, which would be convened upon our initiative. This Congress, which would have to concentrate all that is living and strong in Jewry, in intellectual and financial respects, will realise this project in grandiose dimensions. The Zionists, however, without leaving off their Zionist work, will take part in the Africa affair only in so far as it may be necessary in order that the emigration bear a national character. Only in this way will it be possible to win for our national interests people who have nothing in common with pure Zionism and do not wish to take part in Zionist Congresses; by taking the initiative in this matter upon ourselves we shall preserve our standing in the eyes of Jewry as a whole, but only if we hold our banner high not in words alone but also in deed. "As Zionists we stepped upon the stage of history, as Zionists we stirred up the whole of Jewry, as Zionists we must also live and work hereafter," cried Dr. Sapir with enthusiasm. "In our banner is our strength, in opportunism is our death!"

A. B.

*

In the Berlin newspaper Tägliche Rundschau Karl Peters discusses Zionism and the East Africa project as follows:

Our age is a period of national movements. The longing for national unity lay at the root of the German and the Italian question in the last century; it is this that ever feeds the fire of the Balkan crisis anew; it heats men's minds to the struggle between Germans and Poles in our Eastern Marches. Zionism is nothing but the expression of the same stirring of the will within Jewry. Here, indeed, it looks as though an old willow-tree, apparently long since dead, were beginning once more, under the influence of the spring sun, to put forth leaves and blossoms.

We have so often heard that Jewry is no longer a national but merely a confessional conception. There are, it was said, Jewish Germans, Englishmen, Frenchmen, and so forth, just as there are Catholic and Protestant Germans, Englishmen and Frenchmen; but at the beginning of the twentieth century there no longer existed anywhere Hebrews in the sense of the Old Testament as a people apart. The orthodox Jews, to be sure, held tenaciously to the ancient prophecies of the new glory of the "chosen people," of the future Jerusalem with its Messiah. But these were interpreted rather in a spiritual sense; and it was thought that their fulfilment would be brought about precisely through the dispersion of the Jews among the Gojim, the "nations" of the earth. "Thou shalt consume all the peoples which the Lord thy God