No. 43. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
...for that is what it is in fact. We are Zionists because we are Nationalists; I hope none of us is a Nationalist merely because he is a Zionist. And if I have said that this offer of the British Government is a great step towards Palestine, it was because it signifies the recognition of the national principle for which we have always fought. Had the British Government possessed Palestine, we should be negotiating with it for that country. The British Government has very practically recognised our claim to be a nation by saying to us: "We will give you a tract of land which shall be Jewish, and a colony which shall be governed by a local Jewish authority."
Now many Zionists and others have spoken and written about East Africa, and some have sought to excuse Dr. Herzl for his attention to the British offer. They say that the offer had been made and Dr. Herzl could not have declined it out of hand without at least laying it before the Congress. I do not in the least agree with this view. I am convinced that if Dr. Herzl had believed the offer not to be in the interest of the Jewish people, or if he had been of the opinion that it was a step backward, then he could, might and would beg the British Government's pardon for being unable to entertain this offer of theirs. For my own part I can say that, had I not perceived this project to be one that carries us forward, nearer to the goal of our hope, I should not have urged Dr. Herzl to entertain it and submit it to the Congress. I have never professed to be a party man who clings stubbornly and obstinately to the single idea of Palestine and rejects everything else outside the Zionist goal. I have always striven to do all I could, and to employ our movement for everything that is good for our people. And when I now saw that here there offered itself a possibility of lightening a little the pressure from which our people suffers, I urged Dr. Herzl to consider the British offer very seriously. I share with him the view that the East Africa plan is a good plan. Let me name some of the reasons why it has value for us. In the first place it may bring a great political advantage, because, as I have already said, it will be the recognition of our people as a nation. From this point the whole future of our people must proceed: for the first time after 1800 years a nation has negotiated with the Jewish people. There were negotiations before, it is true, but the Jew's face was always turned away from him with whom he was negotiating. The British Government has entered into negotiations with the Jews in order, among much else, to increase the number of Jews in its territories, and that alone I hold to be a great triumph for Dr. Herzl and the Zionist movement. Let us suppose that the colony is already there, and that we have colonised a tract of land which can in the end support a million or half a million people. You will say it is no very high figure compared with the whole number of the Jews, but even this number would considerably relieve the situation in Eastern Europe. We should at last be rid of a part of the migratory mass of Jewry, which will certainly cause us much difficulty in the near future. Here in England we have an ever-growing number of arrivals, which will doubtless be a source of unrest, owing to the prejudices of certain people or their stupid inability to see the Jews as they are. The appointment of the Aliens Commission and the report it has rendered prove that England suffers a little from a want of digestion of the Jews. We may laugh at that, but we must reckon with the facts, and I say it is far better that the migration should be directed into a Jewish colony and away from the slums of Leeds, London or New York. We must take the facts as they are. And when we see that in the course of 20 or 25 years about a million Jews have left Eastern Europe in order to settle in the worst quarters of the towns of England and America, it would be better to give those who have not yet emigrated the possibility of a colony in East Africa, where the climatic conditions would be favourable and the prospects of development good, and where they could live as Jews and not as aliens.
When one cries "Palestine or nothing," one easily forgets that to-day we have one of the most fearful of alternatives. To-day there is: Palestine, a hope, or the land of misery, a certainty; and if we can create a third alternative in East Africa, many of our people will surely accept East Africa with joy. Then I foresee that the Jewish settlement will be a preparatory school and a drilling-ground for Jewish national life. Indeed, it is always said that we are forever quarrelling. We have not yet had the opportunity of showing the world that as a people we can govern ourselves. I do not know whether we proved it at our Congress, but in the Jewish colony, as it is planned, we shall be able to prove to the world that we can be a self-governing people. This kind of criticism has not been practised by other peoples alone. There are petty little Jews who say: "Why do you try to obtain Palestine? When you get there you will be perpetually at one another's throats; Jews will never be able to deal among themselves and make a livelihood." Let us show in East Africa that all this is mere lampoon; let us prove to the world that we can govern ourselves as well as the Belgians or the Swiss. I do not doubt at all that when the world comes to see that the Jews can form an independent Jewish colony, that we can govern ourselves and are capable of living like men and not of being treated like beasts, the world will then come and say: "Now we can entrust Palestine to them." If, therefore, we can show that the Jews can administer themselves, we shall remove one of the strongest objections to our return to Palestine. And now I will look a little further ahead. I believe in the depths of my heart that the Jews will sooner or later obtain Palestine, and that one fine day the people of God will be in the land of God. I do not say that it will come to pass in our days, or even in those of the youngest among us here, but I am convinced that this land is reserved for the Jewish people. If that be so, why should we not look further about us in the meantime? The development of Egypt, of South Africa and of other parts of the continent indicates that in the future East Africa will attain the greatest importance. It is easy to foresee that through the colony in East Africa we shall have a community of Jews on this continent which will be in touch with its mother country, and that it will therefore have an immense connexion when we shall have obtained Palestine. Let us ask ourselves: What will those who come after us say of us if, merely for sentimental reasons, we do not accept the offer? They will say: "Our