Die Welt · Vol. VII, No. 45 · 6 November 1903
6printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 45

A dead word, a rigid dogma? Oh no, it is the outline of our entire work, the child of sharp struggle and hard labour of thought. We hold the conviction that the Jewish people can say of the articles of the Basle Programme: כּי הם חיינוּ וארך ימינוּ they are our life and the length of our days. And having once recognised our way as the right one, we must remain true to it. We see well enough that here and there a little path leads off to the side, but it is not for us to take it. Our life's work is to go towards our goal on the high road, by the shortest way, and no impetuous clamouring for so-called practical work may lead us away from it. Our strength lies precisely in our not frittering it away; we do not wish the stream to become a thousand rivulets, and therefore we dam it in on both sides with high walls. Woe to us if we ourselves tear down these walls!

Were Zionism to let itself be led into taking the colonisation into its own hands, then the saying that we shall not meanwhile forget Zion would in truth be a mere phrase. For it would be a work which for many decades would claim all the working forces and means of Zionism. And, however optimistically we may think of our capacity, we have not strength enough to work in two directions, upon two giant undertakings, each of which alone might dishearten us.

It may sound hard-hearted when we say: Charitable colonisation is not our work. But everyone knows that the Zionist does his duty in charity too; only it does not belong to our party as such, for we should very soon be at the end of our strength, and our people would not be helped.

This stands unshakably firm for us. And therefore it was superfluous to sweeten the pill for us and to seek to convince Zionism of the necessity of its intervention by the advantages of this autonomous colonisation. The principal speaker on the East Africa question at the Congress, Max Nordau, already laid strong emphasis on the national value of such a colony. In this colony we shall gather the most valuable experience, we shall learn to govern ourselves and to administer a country. A considerable part of the Jewish proletariat will be transformed into sturdy husbandmen, a culture true to our stock will develop — in short, we shall have a national preparatory school which one day, when we begin in Palestine with the establishment of our commonwealth, will furnish the élite of our human material. — For the present we must somewhat restrict these hopes. To me, at least, the direct benefit which Palestine is to draw from East Africa has not become quite clear. For it is a utopia to believe in a transplanting of human material in any considerable quantity from the colony to the mother country, and with that a great part of the expectations falls away. It is true, however, that we shall receive priceless lessons in self-government and in the shaping of our internal affairs of State.

But for all the world, how can one conclude from this that Zionism must itself set about the colonisation, must itself build this asylum? Shall we learn less if others gather this experience? The experience hitherto gained in Palestine, too, was not gained by us, and yet in future we shall make use of every piece of it, even the smallest.

Further, it has been said at the Congress, and since then everywhere in the Jewish press in every key: Zionism must, besides its more distant goal, take up this work at once, because the distress of the moment presses too terribly. Help must be given at once, if numerous Jews are not simply to go to ruin or to be lost to the Jewish people through aimless emigration. But let us not be taken by surprise in this: Is East Africa really this immediate help? Consider: the territory to be settled is as good as unknown, and in any case wholly undeveloped. Primeval forests must first of all be cleared and the most primitive roads laid. Let us not deceive ourselves: a generation and more will pass before Jews can be settled there in any appreciable number. Let us but look at the opening-up of the comparable parts of Australia, which took place in modern times, and which even now has only gathered 5 millions of people upon a far larger area. Whoever does not take this thought into account is projecting into the blue. The hungry man who cries for bread cannot be referred to the date-stone from which he must first raise the palm. Yes, Canada or the Argentine may perhaps be an immediate help, but not East Africa.

Does it follow from all this that nothing at all is to come of the whole project, that Herzl is to declare flatly to the English Government: The Jewish people has no use for your offer?

Consider what that would mean. A signal opportunity to give effective help to hundreds of thousands of wretched people would have passed by unused through the fault of the Zionists. A storm of indignation, of justified indignation without equal, would come roaring down upon us and sweep us away from the ranks of those who fight for our people. It would be a fall from which we should never recover, and our work for Palestine, too, would be as good as impossible, for we should have lost the confidence of great masses. And what should we have gained for the cause? Truly, it was not for the sake of Herzl's beautiful eyes that England resolved upon her offer, and there is not the trace of a reason why she should not conclude the contract which the Jewish Colonial Bank refuses with the "Ica," if the latter offers itself — and that it will certainly do. And then? Where does Zionism stand then? Make that quite clear to yourselves!

There is no turning back any more! Forward — let us see what is to be done. The Zionist party must take over the part of mediator, and it has already done so. It is on the right road.

Should the report of the expedition prove favourable, then the Seventh Zionist Congress, specially convened, will resolve that the colonisation of East Africa is not the work of Zionism. It will resolve that a general Jewish Congress, or a joint assembly of the organisations which come into consideration here, is to be convened. And only this Congress will come to a decision upon the work itself.

Think of the words of Zangwill: "Thank God there is not only Zionism, but also the charitable institutions."

There come into consideration above all the "Ica," the "Alliance," the B'nai B'rith Lodges and the national relief societies. Zionism, as the spiritual father of the undertaking, will also, as its spiritual guide, claim and obtain a leading voice. Its care must be to shape the undertaking in a national sense and spirit. But its organising and material resources it may not commit, not even in small part.

Our conception of the question also shows the way to an understanding between Yes-sayers and No-sayers — the only way. Over in Russia, too, it is already being entered upon half unconsciously; this is shown to the point of evidence by two opinions published in the "Welt." There Dr. Awinowitzki, the Yes-sayer, and Dr. Sapir, the No-sayer, express themselves upon the question. The Yes-sayer admits that