No. 46 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…earnestness even take themselves for radical politicians. And for that reason, if for no other, and quite apart from all the strokes of genius they may otherwise commit, they are the men to whom the calotte would be due, the sans-calottes of whom we have spoken.
Dr. Alexander Marmorek.
(On our portrait.)
On Tuesday, 17 November, Dr. Alexander Marmorek delivered before the Paris Académie de Médecine his eagerly awaited report on the tuberculosis serum he has discovered. The Académie de Médecine is the most distinguished medical body in France. Before it, on repeated occasions, researches were first reported which afterwards brought the most beneficent consequences for all mankind. It was therefore a special distinction for Marmorek, an Austrian, to be able to communicate to the whole world from this very place the provisional result of his many years of research. Many hopes will attach themselves to Dr. Marmorek's publication. He therefore long hesitated to publish his work, and has resolved to do so only now, because he believes he has brought his experiments, not on animals alone but on human beings as well, to a scientifically mature conclusion. He had previously applied the remedy he discovered with success in Paris clinics and in the clinics of other countries, and only after such a series of experiments, obtained under the most varied conditions and circumstances, will the entire scientific public now be in a position to exercise criticism and to assess the results. In any case the new serum, which originated in Marmorek's laboratory, will arouse the keenest interest, for its success, once confirmed by scientific examination, would be a blessing for all mankind, an inestimable achievement of natural science. Marmorek is no unknown. At the Pasteur Institute, although he was a foreigner, he was appointed head of a department after a short time, and he had already established his name in medical science through the antistreptococcus serum.
He had come to Paris from Vienna, where he had pursued his medical studies and for many years perfected his clinical training at the General Hospital. Dr. Marmorek is the son of Dr. Josef Marmorek, a physician very well known in Vienna, who only a few years ago was torn by a sudden death from the calling he loved with such devotion.
Of Dr. A. Marmorek's lecture the Viennese papers report as follows:
Dr. Marmorek read his communication, which, in accordance with the custom prevailing in the Academy, was kept very brief, in a clear voice, while the public and the savants followed him in silence and with intense interest. Dr. Marmorek began his lecture with the remark that in his address before the Academy today he did not intend to give a complete account of his many years' labours, but only to communicate the conclusions at which he had arrived. He gives even these communications only in the broadest outline. A detailed report on the experience he has gathered he would publish within a few days in the competent German and French scientific organs. Dr. Marmorek then entered upon the character of his work. He believes he has arrived at the certain result that Koch's tuberculin is not the true toxin of tuberculosis. Tuberculin, he said, is only a preparatory substance, a stage on the way to the genuine toxin, which he has found. The preparation of the serum which he has recognised as effective against tuberculosis requires a very complicated procedure. His serum is not, like Koch's tuberculin, obtained merely from a nutrient fluid. Dr. Marmorek first prepares the toxin of tuberculosis. To this end he cultivates tubercle bacilli on a culture medium consisting of the blood serum of the calf and a nutrient fluid. With the toxin of the bacilli thus obtained, which contains the active metabolic products of the pathogenic organisms, he immunises horses, and only this serum obtained from the horse, which is an immune serum, a serum free of poison, is used for purposes of treatment in men and animals.
As to the results achieved by the injection of his serum, Dr. Marmorek declares that in tuberculous meningitis he has observed no cure; yet he believes that in these cases he always came too late with his serum. In tuberculosis of the bones, tuberculosis of the joints, in tuberculous lymph glands and even in pulmonary tuberculosis, however, he has achieved indisputable successes. In the cases of advanced pulmonary tuberculosis treated by him a visible improvement set in. The expectoration and the quantity of bacilli diminished, the shortness of breath disappeared. Less advanced tuberculosis was completely cured. On the application of the new serum Dr. Marmorek remarked that the quantities of serum injected must be fairly large and distributed over a series of doses. The serum causes neither fever nor other reactions.
At the close of his lecture Dr. Marmorek remarked that he well knew the difficulties of his undertaking, and that only the repetition of his experiments by other investigators as well could yield a definitive judgment on the value of his serum. Such experiments are now being carried out in France and abroad by trustworthy men of science; his successes hitherto, however, extending over more than a year, entitled him to lay his discovery before the Académie de Médecine already today. He considered himself all the more entitled to do so as the harmlessness of his serum has been established in absolute fashion, so that all physicians can therefore employ it without having to fear dangerous consequences. He himself called upon physicians to employ his serum, in order thereby to widen still further the field of experience. Dr. Marmorek then further remarked expressly:
"At this point I beg the Academy to permit me a personal remark. A member of the Pasteur Institute for many years, I have found myself scientifically not in agreement with its direction upon several points of these investigations. In order to relieve the latter entirely, I have held it my duty to tender my resignation as head of the laboratory, so as to bear alone the whole moral and scientific responsibility for this work."
The reception of the lecture in the Academy.
The meeting at which Dr. Marmorek delivered his lecture was brilliantly attended. Every medical notability Paris possesses was present. The address made a great impression on the savants present, in particular the declaration that Dr. Marmorek assumed the full scientific and moral responsibility for his discovery, as well as the measured language concerning the results obtained and the express mention of the absence of results in certain cases that were from the outset to be regarded as lost.