No. 46 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 9
(continued from page 8)
…legally secured home in Palestine" — that is to say, a national and political rebirth!
Zionism, on its first appearance, met with a great deal of ridicule both within and without the Jewish community. Although this movement has grown considerably in recent years, the "Frankfurter Zeitung" declares that it is a matter of nothing but utopias and fantasies. For that paper "there is no longer a Jewish people", but only "adherents of the Jewish religion". The Jews, it holds, have everywhere long since become assimilated in the lands where they dwell, and have grown into them nationally as well. — This optimistic view is altogether mistaken. The Jewish people has been preserved as a physical race and has remained unchanged. The intermixtures with other peoples during the Dispersion have been only slight and transient. Where, however, a mixture is not renewed again and again, and the types are fixed by subsequent in-breeding, a separation and elimination of the less numerous foreign racial elements very readily takes place. That is an old experience of the animal breeder, and no less a lesson of history.
The Jewish race does indeed represent a mixed type, but one that must have arisen in Palestine and the adjoining districts before the destruction of Jerusalem. In these intermixtures, perhaps in consequence of the predominant racial potency of the Hittites, a good mixed type was formed, above all in its physiognomy, which allows the specifically Jewish character to be so readily recognised. The Zionists have become conscious of their Jewish racial individuality, in contrast to the "assimilationists", who wish to be absorbed into the other peoples. "Assimilation," said a speaker at the Congress, "is to be judged on grounds of the morality of nations; it is also impossible. Philanthropic societies have done everything to bring about assimilation, but all their means have so far produced no result."
That Zionism has become a public and political factor is shown most clearly by the fact that the governments of states enter into negotiations with its official representatives. Dr. Herzl, the President of the Zionist Committee, had an interview with the Russian Minister von Plehwe. The Russian Government naturally cannot tolerate a Jewish-national movement within the frontiers of Russia. "So long, however," runs the Minister's letter, "as Zionism consisted in the will to create an independent State in Palestine, and so long as it promised to organise the emigration of a certain number of Jewish subjects from Russia, the Russian Government could very well be favourable to it." Should the old programme of action be upheld, Russia would support the Zionist plenipotentiaries before the Ottoman Government. Meanwhile the Sultan has hitherto maintained an attitude of refusal towards the Zionist demands. The English Government was more accommodating. It offers the Jews a tract of land in East Africa for colonisation, and that on the basis of a Jewish autonomy under British suzerainty. The declaration of the English Government states that it takes an interest in every well-considered plan which "aims at the amelioration of the position of the Jewish race". The details of the plan are: "The grant of a considerable tract of land, the appointment of a Jewish official as chief of the local administration, and the guarantee to the colony of full freedom of action in municipal legislation and in the regulation of religious and purely internal administrative affairs; this right of local self-government must, however, leave unimpaired the right of the English Government to exercise a general superintendence."
Over the East Africa project a heated battle of words arose at the Congress. Its opponents saw in it an abandonment of the Zionist goal, an offence against the Basle Programme; the supporters of the project, who formed the majority, sought by it, however, only to create a preparatory aid, a "night-shelter" for the poorest of the Jews, a school for further action on the road to Zion. Gernandt now quotes the principal passages from Nordau's speech and continues:
The Africa project is to be regarded as a necessary stage of transition towards the realisation of the Zionist ideas. Indeed, it is out of the question from the outset to accommodate nearly twelve million people in Palestine. The Jews will have to gather at various points of the globe, in order from thence gradually to conquer Zion by one way or another, whether by economic colonisation or by the intervention of the governments of the states upon the collapse of the Turkish Empire. "None of our roads," said a delegate, "are the shortest and smallest; we must very often go round about and make detours in order to reach the goal. For nearly two thousand years we have been on our way home, to Zion. We wander thither through America, Brazil, Australia, through the steppes of Russia, through every clime. Why should we not also, if it must be, wander to Zion by way of East Africa?"
No soberly thinking man can withhold his recognition from the enthusiasm, the zeal, and the spirit of sacrifice of the Zionists. When a people such as the Jewish people comes to a consciousness of itself and rouses itself to national union and action, that is a momentous moment in the history of the world. For the social part which the Jews have played as an economic and intellectual element among the other peoples would thereby undergo a transformation which one is justified in hoping will redound to the welfare both of the Jewish and of the other races. The history of the nations is entering upon the stage of "unmixing", and the governments of the states ought to co-operate by international negotiations in putting an end to the unworthy condition in which a great part of Jewry finds itself. That this help can consist only in separation, and not in fusion, anthropology and history may well have sufficiently proved.
An East Africa Debate at the Maccabean Club in London.
On Sunday, the 8th of this month, Dr. Max Bernstein lectured in London at the "Maccabean Club" on "The Expansion of Zionism and the East African Question". After some general remarks on the Jewish question, the lecturer said: The resolution of the Congress to send a commission to East Africa gave rise to stormy scenes at the Congress... The reason for these scenes was as follows: Zionism, though still very young, already has behind it a history of feverish activity and progress; in the course of a few years it has called into being a powerful organisation, it has created the Congress, established the Jewish Colonial Bank, created the institution of the National Fund, it has awakened a great movement in favour of the revival of the study of the Hebrew language and of its use as a living tongue, it has organised the masses, instilled into them the spirit of national discipline, created a press of its own, conjured forth countless symptoms of the rejuvenation of the Jewish nation — and all this on the basis of its own programme, the practical recovery of Palestine, and of Palestine alone. On the foundation of the Palestinian idea Zionism united all the elements of Jewry, the educated and the uneducated, the masses and the classes, the believers and the unbelievers, atheists and rabbis. The new proposal, the settlement in East Africa, arose suddenly, unexpectedly, unforeseen, and thrust itself into the Zionist programme, not gradually, like a young bud among old flowers, not like a new, subsidiary theme among the questions we have to consider, but with brute force, overwhelmingly, and demanded the first place, the greatest attention, the urgency — it pressed Palestine, with all the hopes, all the steps and deeds undertaken until now, to the wall. At any other time such an intruder would have been thrown out and thrust aside without ceremony. But it was born under a different star. The panic of Kishineff, the Alien Immigration, the loss of the little liberty that had been left to the Jews, that of wandering, the dull sound of the heavy doors of the places of refuge being slammed in the face of the Jews — these were the circumstances that attended its birth. It came at a time when the Jews had risen above their narrow local interests, and the whole of Jewry in its distress was looking about for someone who could counsel and help it. And their eyes naturally fell upon the Zionists, the only ones who were organised and willing to work But Zionism is not an institution of panic and its consequences, and has never intended to hang the alarm-bell at the door and ring it whenever a fire has broken out in Jewry. It has been said by us repeatedly that our policy is not the policy of panic, but a policy of its prevention, by procuring for the Jewish people a secure home, secure against the evil consequences of terror and the still worse ones of peaceful slumber — of assimilation, of absorption. We have warned the Jews with the most compelling arguments, with the whole force of our eloquence and feeling, to help us to build this home and not to wait for catastrophes. Did we not tell you that, according to our knowledge and our experience, the present system