Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 48
(continued from page 3)
…preserved, became loyal citizens of their homeland, warm and highly esteemed friends of the native people, but never bartered away their name and their nationality for alleged political advantages. Not merely individuals, but the community as a whole has attained standing and prosperity. Of the 365 Armenian families of Hungary 57 are noble, and it testifies to their prosperity that in the chief seat of the Armenians of Hungary, the County of Szolnok-Doboka, 41 of the 211 highest taxpayers are Armenians, i.e. 20 per cent, whereas they make up merely 1.5 per cent of the population. But not only in Hungary — throughout the whole world the Armenians have faithfully preserved their nationality and language for centuries and have everywhere attained the greatest influence. In Galicia and the Bukovina there live at most 6000 Armenians, and yet these Armeno-Poles are leaders of the political parties — for example, the Abrahamovicz family — and even form among the great landowners of the Bukovina a distinct and decisive party with four members of the Diet. There are 150 times as many Jews in these lands, and let one compare the position of these Poles and Germans of the Mosaic confession with the position of the Armenians who have remained true to their nationality. And this comparison might be carried on in every land under the sun.
Everywhere the Armenians fare splendidly, and their position nowhere leaves anything to be desired; and yet they have not forgotten their distant homeland, their unhappy brethren in the Turkish Empire. A movement of their own, like Zionism in Jewry, has indeed not arisen among the Armenians; not, however, because the Armenians who have attained prosperity, standing and power have no feeling for the venerable homeland by the Caspian Sea, no heart for their poor, oppressed brethren. They need no Zionism, for they have never lost their Zion; they care and fear, fight and strive for it unceasingly, and have done so for centuries. More than half of the Szamosujvar "Armenia" is filled with enthusiastic descriptions of Armenia and its people, and likewise in London and Marseilles, Paris and Boston, Vienna and Leghorn, and in many, many other places besides, there appear periodicals and newspapers, mostly in the Armenian language, which labour continually and inexhaustibly for the knowledge, liberation and regeneration of Armenia. No one on that account accuses the Armenians of treason to the fatherland; and even if many of the Hungarian, Italian, Roumanian, etc., Armenians do not think of a return, they are none the less colonies and outposts of Armenia, their ancestral home, in a foreign land. All of them, however, hope firmly and confidently for Armenia's freedom, for they know well that a people cannot be robbed of its homeland for ever!
Armenians and Jews are often compared with one another, and yet the resemblance is only an outward one. The Armenians have everywhere remained an independent nation; the Jews have everywhere tried to attach themselves to the other nations. The Armenians are therefore everywhere respected and powerful, the Jews hated and oppressed; the Armenians have never lost their ancestral homeland, even though it came under foreign rule, whereas for the Jews only Zionism can and will create a homeland. Then, however, we shall no longer have to regard the Armenians with such admiring envy as is now, alas, the case.
Lavoslav Schick.
Zion and East Africa.
A Speech by Mr. Greenberg.
On Saturday, 14 November, a great Zionist public meeting took place in St. James's Hall in London, at which the Rev. Green presided and Mr. L. J. Greenberg was the principal speaker. The chief content of the speech was a polemic against Dr. Gaster, who in the October number of the periodical "Ost und West" had published, under the title "Zionism and Neo-Zionism," a trenchant article on the East Africa affair.
Mr. Greenberg began by declaring once more the aim of Zionism, which strives for the creation of a publicly and legally secured home for the Jewish people in Palestine. Mr. Greenberg declared that Zionism holds fast now as ever to this aim, from which it has never departed. "We remain," the speaker said, "faithful adherents of our hopes and ideals, and strive now as ever to establish our home in Palestine, in order to begin there a new life in Judaism and to burst the spiritual and bodily fetters which our people bears in the Dispersion. We would plant the banner of Judah upon the battlements of Zion, create a true rallying-point for the scattered of our people, put an end to the Jewish distress, and from there send forth to mankind the glad tidings of an era of freedom, equality and justice." These words come from our learned friend, the Chacham Dr. Moses Gaster. I quote them as an expression of my own feelings, to show that between the opponents of the latest development in Zionism and its advocates there is, in the end, but a slight difference; I subscribe to these words of Dr. Gaster's with my whole heart. These words form the conclusion of an excellent article which he published in the periodical "Ost und West." I wish to direct attention to this article, for it was sound in content and in scope. It was written with all the mastery that distinguishes Dr. Gaster, and I declare here that in all I have to say I shall not forget the immense services which Dr. Gaster has rendered to our cause, nor forget the high position which Dr. Gaster fills with dignity, nor yet the esteem which he enjoys not only in our community but among the Jewry of the whole world.
Dr. Gaster began his article with the remark that one must distinguish between the "Jewish Question" and Zionism. He said: "The Zionist question and the Jewish Question are not equivalent concepts. They cannot simply be exchanged one for the other. The one is bound up with the Jewish distress; the other is independent of it." Now, at the very outset I take the liberty of being of a different opinion from Dr. Gaster. If the Zionist movement is to have any practical significance at all, one must come to know precisely the position of the Jews, whether it be a wretched or a happy one. One must study the Jewish Question precisely, and I am the more convinced that I am right since Dr. Gaster himself, a week later, said at the Anglo-Jewish Association: "I hold fast to the view that the only solution of the Jewish Question is Palestine alone." Now, if after a week Dr. Gaster abandons the position he had taken up and declares that Zionism has to concern itself with the Jewish Question, then the foundation of the article to which I refer is shaken, for it proceeds from the assumption that Zionism is something quite different from the solution of the Jewish Question in its economic and social aspect. Dr. Gaster says in his article that Zionism must pursue aims which have nothing to do with the position and the present conditions of life of the Jews. I have let Dr. Gaster speak against himself. It was the best thing I could do. But I ask whether it is possible to conceive that the Zionist movement could accomplish anything for the world, for Jewry, without taking account of the present state of the Jewish Question! Although the aforesaid article, like everything Dr. Gaster writes, is excellent, I must nevertheless make one reproach against it. Dr. Gaster always assumes the air of infallibility and admits no opinion differing from his own. He has a short and sharp method, with
