No. 3 Special Edition. — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…El-Arish or not. The East Africa project was something utterly strange to us.
Not only do we not know what we shall have to deliberate upon; we do not know what has happened. I recall here once more the custom in other parliaments, when certain negotiations — whether successful or not — have been concluded or have reached a certain stage of maturity, of distributing detailed reports to the members of parliament. I note, to be sure, with satisfaction that Dr. Herzl has proceeded far more frankly towards this Congress than usual: we have learned more at this Congress than at all the others together. I would therefore recommend the Congress to request the Actions Committee that in future reports on concluded negotiations, at least in general form, be laid before the delegates.
I am quite willing to share with you the expectation that in most matters the Actions Committee has in fact conducted the negotiations in a fitting manner. But one example showing that there are cases in which, from the standpoint of the Congress, some other course might perhaps have been more correct, is the El Arish affair. I was most painfully affected by the way in which the originator of this idea has been treated. (Dissent.) — Cries: Why do you anticipate the verdict of the commission? — Syrkin is the originator. — It would have been finer and more dignified, instead of denying Mr. Trietsch all competence here from the tribune, to mention quite calmly that he has occupied himself with this idea. (Cries: Close.)
If the Congress does not wish me to speak further on this, I will pass to another question. (Cries of "Close!")
The President has stated that the A. C. took the El Arish matter in hand in a very earnest manner, in that it sent out a commission of exploration thither. A passage in Dr. Herzl's speech makes this despatch appear to me in another light. He mentioned frankly that it was the English Government which had left it to the representatives of the A. C. to send out the commission of exploration. But when the representatives of the A. C. came to England to negotiate about El Arish, they had no thorough knowledge of El Arish. Their whole knowledge was at that time, after all, confined to the articles of Mr. Trietsch. He took the trouble to travel there twice; the A. C. only took the trouble to read through his works. (Applause, cries: Close!) For me and my friends this project is something of very great significance, and we should be sorry if we too had to regard the project as a failure, as the President has said. I do not share this view, and I have my reasons; for I have received word from persons who know the matter that it was perhaps conceived in an exaggerated form, and that if it is approached more modestly, in a certain sense, one can succeed. I recommend you not to content yourselves with the report of the A. C., but to appoint a commission once more to study the matter thoroughly. (Bravo! Cries!) I have heard that the original El Arish project was enlarged by the A. C. in an entirely comprehensible manner, in that it was thought to join the Pelusian plain to the tract of El Arish. It then turned out that the Pelusian plain could not be settled, because Nile water would have to be diverted, to which the Egyptian Government cannot agree. Give up the Pelusian plain and content yourselves with El Arish, for which sufficient irrigation could be obtained. I come now to speak of the actual positive programme of political Zionism, of what ought to be done in the question of colonisation. Of all the possibilities which the President mentioned in his speech, the one that appealed to me most was precisely that which, on the strength of his personal authority, he rejected in the negotiations with Turkey in the year 1902. When Dr. Herzl was negotiating with Turkey concerning Palestine, he saw himself obliged to break off these negotiations, out of regard for the Basle Programme, which positively demands the public-legal securing of Palestine. But when he afterwards negotiated with the English Government over the East Africa project, the Basle Programme again stood in his way, since it proscribes a settlement outside Palestine. This time, however, he disregarded it. From this it follows that, of the two things — settlement in Palestine or a charter — the charter appears to the President the more important. I am one of those to whom settlement in Palestine, even without a charter, appears far more important.
I do not enter into details, and I share the view expressed by Dr. Herzl and the representatives of the delegations, that this is a matter for whose discussion we are not prepared. But this much is already perfectly clear, that for us there is but one single goal: Palestine and the surrounding lands. You will say: Without a charter we can carry on only small-scale colonisation, and that is an outworn petty-bourgeois standpoint, as someone reproached us yesterday.
There is, however, a small-scale colonisation which is political. That depends upon the system. I should like to set before you the example of England. She carries on small-scale colonisation in Africa, which proceeds unnoticed. Today she wins a territory without bloodshed by virtue of a treaty with a negro chieftain; tomorrow she buys mines in the Transvaal; the day after she has dervishes in the north-east cut down by Lord Kitchener or Lord Roberts (Cries: The Jews may not!) and establishes herself there (Laughter). One day we suddenly learn that England has linked two very remote settlements by a railway, and one day again that she links the whole of Africa all round with a railway and possesses the entire continent (Laughter).
We are no great power and no conquerors; but I believe we should do well to win our small old fatherland by the same road. We ought to direct our attention to obtaining from His Majesty the Sultan, first of all, the repeal of the prohibition of immigration, and to turn this gain to account by founding colonies and buying land in Palestine. The question of the charter and of autonomy ought not to be regarded as a conditio sine qua non.
For the work of rescue the neighbouring lands should be made use of. (Hissing and applause.)
President Dr. Nordau reads a motion of order by Sulzberger: It is resolved that all speakers be limited to 15 min. speaking time, and that no speaker may take the floor a second time on the same matter before all the other registered speakers on this question have been heard.
Dr. Syrkin. There is undoubtedly in every political movement a difference between opposition and opposition. I too belong to the oppositionists, not only at the Congress but in my Zionist work. But the opposition whose representatives here are Mr. Trietsch and Dr. Nossig — this opposition I do not share in the least. (Bravo.) I will not inquire how far the opposition of these two gentlemen is conditioned by personal motives, but in substance this opposition is of such a kind that one must indeed advise these gentlemen to develop somewhat further in Zionist thinking (Quite right, Bravo) so as first to attain the height of political Zionism, in order that I may take the gentlemen seriously at all. (Bravo.) When these gentlemen come to us as oppositional Zionists with the idea of small-scale colonisation, we tell you that they belong to the backward oppositionists. I personally have no need to expound before the Congress the other oppositional current in Zionism, which is making its way more and more, although there would be a greater right to do so, because in reality great currents are already stirring which represent other ideas in Zionism. But the time has not yet come to appear before the Congress as a closed party and to steer the whole Zionist movement into our course. I must say something further with regard to the speeches of Dr. Herzl and Dr. Nordau, and here my political tact tells me that questions upon which, in the nature of things, no discussion is admissible should as far as possible always be avoided in any speeches whatever; and against this the speech of Dr. Herzl has offended. There are questions which it is better to pass over in silence than to discuss in public. I have in view here a particular passage, of which my friends know, and which it would have been better to strike out; it is the passage which cannot well be discussed here. On the speech of Dr. Nordau I remark that he in particular on two