Die Welt · Vol. VII, Separate Edition · 26 August 1903
6printed page
scan 6 of 16

Page 6 — "Die Welt" — Special Edition. No. 3

(continued from page 5)

…united with Zionism. Moreover, in a report of our official organ it was once communicated concerning the negotiations about Palestine and other countries of Asia Minor, and all at once "other countries of Asia Minor" were drawn into our Programme. To-day we even have an Africa project at this Congress, upon this Programme which I quoted before and which reads quite otherwise. I am personally in favour of altering this Programme; but so long as it has not been altered, the A. C. has no right to negotiate about other countries. The speaker then argues against the late date of the elections of delegates in Austria.

Dr. Zweig. Mr. Lilien has raised reproaches against the A. C. The A. C. is not to blame for this, but the Austrian election committee. Mr. Lilien owes to this circumstance his seat in the Austrian delegation.

Rabinowitsch (Warsaw). In my own name and that of my friends I emphasise that we can be satisfied with all the undertakings of the Greater and the Lesser A. C.; but nevertheless we have the duty of touching upon some points which require explanation. First, what most astonishes us is that a great action of this kind was opened concerning El Arish 9 months ago, and no communication was ever made about it. But, what is still more important for the Zionist movement, we are accustomed to regard what the A. C. undertakes as dogma. Well, El Arish demanded great energy, and the result which the expedition has brought can be found in any encyclopaedia. I appeal to the juridical conscience of our A. C. that negotiations should be conducted only about Zion.

Chasan (in Jargon). The A. C. has the most duties towards us all, because it also has more rights than we.

Dr. Nobel-Leipzig: It is true that every committee needs opposition; but it is equally true that it has more need of thanks, recognition and confidence, of encouragement to fresh effort and better deeds. It has been said that we ought not to surrender the serious affairs of the Congress to a mood of intoxication; but still less do we wish to surrender them to the mood of the morning after, which has dominated the speeches of most of the oppositionists. On behalf of the large Misrachist group, and as its deputy chairman, I declare that we have the fullest confidence in the President of the A. C., and that in the East African matter we do not see a breach of the Basle Programme, since the President of the A. C. has only just consulted the Congress, and the reproach is in no way admissible that the A. C. has itself broken through its Programme without consulting the Congress.

This morning all manner of mystical hints were thrown out about a coming moment in which the A. C. will cease to place only the political and the economic in the foreground, when new cultural, artistic, perhaps even religious questions will stand at the head. We hope that this moment will never come. For this is the greatness and the strength of Zionism — this is why we rabbis who appear here could make the great sacrifice — that the national element, the political, the economic, and this alone, forms at the present time that which unites the whole Jewish people. (Great applause.)

President Dr. Mandelstamm announces the motion that during the speeches of the Russian delegates the chair should be handed over to a Russian colleague, but for his own person declines the honour.

Baljassy expresses his pleasure that Dr. Herzl intends to put an end to "secret politics," repeats the enumeration of Zionist successes according to the statement of accounts of Mr. Marmorek, architect, and wishes to read a letter from the board of the society which delegated him, but is requested by the President to have it printed.

Dr. Jacobsohn (in Russian) is of opinion that Dr. Pasmanik did not raise the relation of the Greater to the Lesser Actions Committee in the proper debate.

Bondi-Bohemia wishes that attention be paid to the promotion of common economic interests, and suggests the appointment of a commission for this purpose and the compilation of a list of commercial agents of confidence.

Weizmann: I associate myself entirely with the view of Dr. Syrkin. There are questions which, when they are spoken of, wound certain sections of our party. Out of regard for the integrity of the party such questions must be passed over in silence.

I should further like to put the question: Does the A. C. consider the El-Arish affair a complete failure, or does it believe that it can be taken up again? It would make an unpleasant impression on the outside world if, on cardinal points such as the question of colonisation, we did not exhaust every means of bringing matters to a good end.

A further point: elsewhere than at the Congress Dr. Herzl delivered a speech which was variously interpreted. The majority understood it to mean that Zionism, in consequence of certain circumstances, certain obstacles, had entered upon a stage in which it would henceforth concern itself only with, so to speak, external questions — I mean the collection of shekels and of shares — while all other questions which have hitherto formed an integral part of Zionism, e. g. the cultural question, were eliminated. Put forward by any ordinary Zionist, such a speech might be a matter of indifference. But spoken by the President of the Actions Committee the speech becomes a decree, and a personal view is thereby made the expression of Zionism as a whole. (Cries: Quite right!) The speech is just as little private as Dr. Herzl is a private person. Now, I should like to emphasise at this point that it is surely a mistaken policy, when a danger is approaching, to make it at once such concessions that perhaps the whole movement is robbed of its inner interest. Dr. Herzl promised us at the time that he would be cautious; I must say that he has not quite kept this promise. We truly cannot afterwards stand up for our cause with the same strength if we are thus disavowed before the Jewish public.

Mrs. Prof. Gottheil (in French) proposes a vote of confidence in Dr. Herzl and the Actions Committee.

Rosenbaum misses any communication about the activity of the Actions Committee as board of supervisors of the Jewish Bank.

President Dr. Bodenheimer remarks that voting on the motion of Mrs. Prof. Gottheil would mean the closing of the debate, and places it at the end of the order of the day.

Bergmann: The question has been discussed to-day whether we as Zionists agree to negotiations with the English Government concerning East Africa. As I may not speak on that, I ask your attention for another proposal. I ask that before we leave the hall a collection be made for the orphans of Kischineff. I am the first who will subscribe 10 francs.