Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 4 · 22 January 1904
13printed page
scan 13 of 20

No. 4. — "Die Welt" — Page 13.

(continued from page 12)

…emancipation was almost everywhere followed hard upon by assimilation, emancipation has, by an identification of the post hoc with the propter hoc, been set down as the sole cause of assimilation; indeed, the reproach was raised, and is raised still, against the champions of emancipation, that they "obtained by stealth" this "gift of the Danaans" only through tacit concessions in the matter of nationality and religion, and had thus by their labours paved the way for the assimilation so ruinous to Judaism. Against this the author rightly points out that a conservative spirit pervades the literature of emancipation, and that the views of those who held radical reforms to be inseparable from civil equality, because they beheld in emancipation the end of all sufferings and the true redemption of Israel, did not set the course for their time and took no root among the people. Did not even Gabr. Riesser, the most liberal literary champion of emancipation, insist that, to obtain it, not one jot of religion might be surrendered, and that not the most insignificant ritual ceremony might be sacrificed for naturalisation, were it obtainable only at that price? And when German governments and towns, at the offer of Jews forgetful of their honour, demanded as the condition of equality "enlightenment," renunciation of "superstition," abandonment of the Talmud and of the Messianic hope (!), Riesser branded such traffic in matters of conscience as a disgrace.

No less instructive is the retrospect the author offers us of the attitude at that time of the decisive factors — the people and the Government — towards the Jews. For there are so many among us who, as Jews, can never do enough in their enthusiasm for the year 1848, who believe they owe their equality solely and entirely to the "noble" "people," misled until then.

Against this the author — with all esteem and recognition for individual men who were then truly liberal, such as Rieger and v. Ziemalkowski — points to the equivocal conduct of most of the deputies, who wavered so long between fidelity to principle and fear of their constituents, and postponed the decision upon precisely those §§ which were decisive for the lot of the Jews so long, that the dissolution of the Reichstag relieved them of their embarrassment.

And the second factor? By the Constitution of the year 1849 equality was granted to the Jews, and soon afterwards for the most part taken away again, although the Jews rightly pointed out how grateful they had shown themselves for this "gift of grace." Only the catastrophe of the year 1859 brought about a change in favour of the Jews. It was not love of mankind, then, nor grace, that "freed" the Jews, but "the hand of God, it hath done it." It must not, however, go unmentioned that the reactionary governments of the 'fifties found accomplices in our own camp. These were the reactionaries in our midst, the die-hard Orthodox led by the Court banker Deutsch, who denounced their "liberal" brethren — among whom was reckoned, for example, even the strictly pious Landesrabbiner of that day, Abraham Placzek — as friends of the revolutionary parties, and who gladly renounced the rights withheld from the Jews, provided only that the police power of the State helped them to preserve "religiosity" and their own power within the congregation.

The most important event within Austrian Jewry since the emancipation of the Jews was the reconstitution of the congregations which followed upon the law "concerning the external legal relations of the Jews," sanctioned in the year 1890. However much the author emphasises the blessings of this law — by which order was brought into congregational administration, and the number of disputes over competence, as well as of interferences of the State power in the internal affairs of the congregations, was diminished — he does not omit to point out many a defect in it. The greatest may well be this: that the law, carried out to the letter, not only means no organisation of Austrian Jewry, but could even lead to its atomisation. For the congregation is not regarded as part of a whole, not even of the "Israelite religious community," which is mentioned in the law only once — almost by accident. A congregation, then, which confined itself "to providing for the satisfaction of the religious needs of its members" and excluded from the sphere of its religious interests the concerns of its co-religionists, would be like — says the author — a bough sawn from the tree, a limb severed from the body.

A real, viable organisation, however, was not and is not possible on this path — from "above" downwards, and upon a religious basis within Jewry, and Austrian Jewry in particular. And yet there already exists an organisation, not merely of Austrian Jewry but of the whole of Jewry, but — on a national basis.

And so the author closes the chapter of his work devoted to the organisation of Jewry by pointing to the national movement, which sets itself as its aim "the union of the individual congregations with the body of Israel, for common and vigorous action, for the concentration of the Jewish national spirit, for the ennobling of the distinctive character of Judaism, for the increase of its vitality, for the cultivation of the Hebrew language and literature, for the development of Jewish art, and for the employment of all the achievements of the present in the service of nationality." What a welcome contrast to the official programme of the "Kultusgemeinden"!

Nor does the author confine himself to setting forth the national movement, its programme and its achievements hitherto, but in a special section he describes the course of development of Zionism so far, from Kallischer to Herzl, or rather to the Sixth Congress.

An exceedingly valuable and welcome contribution to his work the author receives from our distinguished fellow Zionist, Prof. Dr. S. Kraus of Budapest, who describes "the present state of Jewish literature." The picture presented to us is not a pleasing one. The Jewish public and the Jewish scholars stand as strangers to each other. The latter must work without finding or hoping to find sympathy or interest. Dr. Kraus, to be sure, does not acquit them — the scholars — of all blame either, since they occupy themselves more with literary history than with real literature drawn from life and serving life, inasmuch as they devote their attention and labour — almost exclusively — not to the present, its struggles and questions, but only to the past. A contrast in every respect gratifying to these conditions of the West is formed by Russia, where there is a Jewish (Hebrew) reading public and an ever more flourishing Jewish-Hebrew literature. The existence of a Jewish literature in the West is due solely and entirely to the idealism and unselfishness of the disciples of Jewish learning.

In timeliness — by which this work is so distinguished — it gains still further through its appendix, which contains a polemic of the author's, as learned as it is witty, against H. St. Chamberlain, whose falsifications of history and curious Biblical exegesis are brought to light.

And so we can and must commend this instructive and substantial book, whose contents we have merely sketched and by no means exhausted, most warmly to the attention of all who wish to gain a survey of so interesting and timely a piece of Jewish history — the history of our most recent past.

Dr. Simon Friedmann.


Feuilleton.

The Science of Judaism.

As in the economic and political sphere, so nowadays, and rightly, associations of those striving towards the same end are formed in scholarship also, in order to master the ever-growing material with united forces. Specialisation makes constant progress, and the separate disciplines are broken up more and more into detailed researches. The strictest limitation to his special subject is made the exact duty of the individual scholar, and he who works on mediaeval history is regarded by the investigator of antiquity as a layman in that field, and likewise the other way about.