Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 10
(continued from page 1)
...support it with enthusiasm. During this time together I came to know and admire his great general learning, his wide outlook, his large range of ideas and his sound view of the world.
Of his professional skill we were able to convince ourselves within a quarter of an hour of setting out upon our actual journey of study. Scarcely had we left El-Kantara, the real starting-point of the expedition, when he dismounted from his camel, turned up the sandy soil with his hoe and at once pronounced a judgment upon the kind and nature of the ground. And the excellence of this judgment, and its validity for the whole eastern part of the Sinai Peninsula, was confirmed by a later microscopic examination. His expert opinion was the kernel of the whole report which the El-Arish Expedition delivered, and it is a model of clarity and precision.
Another quality he displayed in high measure throughout the whole duration of the expedition: an indestructible humour, to say nothing of an amiability which nothing could cloud. Many a hazard and unpleasantness did the expedition have to undergo, by which its members were made sullen and dejected. A whimsical remark, a good jest of Laurent's, delivered with inimitable originality — and good humour had returned once more to the circle of the expedition's members. Although he commanded no language but his beloved French mother tongue, he nevertheless knew how to win the greatest popularity even among the Bedouins.
In the summer of 1903 he had again been chosen by the Belgian Government for a scientific mission to the Congo, to ascertain there the conditions for coffee and cocoa plantations. Shortly before our last Congress I received a letter from him in which, before leaving Europe, he took his leave and asked me to write to him about the course of the Congress. From the Congo I received several letters in which he inquired about the fate of the East Africa project. Lastly, precisely on the 1st of January, a card of good wishes reached me from the Congo, in which he joined to his personal wishes his wishes for the success of the Zionist movement...
From the Paris "Temps" I now learn, quite unexpectedly, that Laurent, on the ship that was to bring him home again, was stricken by a terrible attack of malaria, and succumbed to it off Sierra Leone.
Science loses in him a disciple of still great promise — Laurent was scarcely 40 years old — all who knew him will mourn the amiable, good man. The Zionist movement has every reason to preserve an honourable remembrance of the well-disposed friend who placed his services at its disposal.
Oskar Marmorek.
The Tschlenow Circular.
Dr. Tschlenow of Moscow has sent to the Zionist societies of his district a circular in which he subjects the situation since the last Congress to description and criticism. The voluminous document is also meant to serve, in the eyes of the societies, as a justification of the conduct of their district leader. How far Dr. Tschlenow has attained this end by his undeniably skilful grouping and presentation of the relevant material, the societies will have to decide. But since this circular, which is intended to give the impression of a calm and logical exposition, advances a whole series of incorrect assertions, we must attach to it a few remarks intended to set the facts right.
First, a few words on our own account. Dr. Tschlenow points out that the cries of "Down with the traitors" (sc. the "Charkow men") found their place chiefly in the official organ, "Die Welt." One or another of the Hebrew scribblers has already on an earlier occasion made known to us, by a similar reproach, his dissatisfaction, so painful to us. At that time it left us cold. We told ourselves that a penny-a-liner who wishes to fill a given space in a paper will clutch convulsively at anything which may relieve the fullness of his inkpot and the barrenness of his thoughts. The matter is different when such a reproach is raised by members of the A.-C. To this we would reply: "The partisan attitude of 'Die Welt' may best be recognised by reading over the discussion of the East Africa question in its columns. In the difficult situation in which the editors of 'Die Welt' then found themselves, it would hardly have been possible to proceed more impartially. In the Charkow affair, too, 'Die Welt' published nothing until we had been informed from a trustworthy quarter. And even this publication was expressly given as a report, without any comment being attached to it. There was all the less reason to reject the protests against the Conference, since declarations of approval of the Conference were also published — and indeed all of the latter, whereas of the former a great number remain unpublished to this day.
"Thus the polemic, which was carried on with far greater vehemence on the ground of the organisation of Zionists loyal to the Congress, found a very muffled echo in this paper. To pass over the whole affair in silence was, understandably, impossible for 'Die Welt.' The matter was too serious for that, and too dangerous in its consequences. If anyone has cause to complain, it is 'Die Welt,' which in certain Russian circles has from the first not merely been left unsupported, but has been openly and secretly disparaged as the organ of 'Vienna.' On this chapter we shall, we hope, yet be permitted to express ourselves more unequivocally before a competent forum."
But if the defenders of the Charkow Conference unjustly display so grave a sensitiveness to every criticism, it is all the more interesting to see in what manner the struggle against Congress resolutions which do not please them, and against the lawful representation of the Congress, is carried on in the circulars of members of the Greater A. C. We refrain from entering into a polemic with the circular which Dr. Tschlenow has dispatched to the societies of the Moscow district. But some things from the text of this pronouncement we will nevertheless quote. Above all we wish once more to make clear the state of the facts, which in this circular and in other declarations of Dr. Tschlenow's colleagues is obscured, probably unintentionally.
