Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 27 · 1 July 1904
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 27 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…to discuss the question, and it would take care that the land should not be alienated for ever, but that at the same time guarantees should be granted to those who wish to settle the land in the interest of British rule.

The Under-Secretary of State, Earl Percy, said it was an extraordinary debate. Several motions for adjournment had already been described as an abuse of the forms of the House. He would not call this motion so as well; it was evident that the motion rested upon a groundless assumption. The honourable Member had the right to oppose the grant of land in East Africa to the Jews; he was also free to raise the question by moving a reduction of the salaries of the Secretary of State's department when the Protectorate finances came up; but he had connected this question with the question of injury to the rights of the natives in East Africa, with which it has nothing to do. The honourable Member seemed to believe that he (Earl Percy) had treated him haughtily in his answers to the questions on the subject. But he felt himself entirely innocent. The honourable Member had first asked him what were the conditions under which land in East Africa was being alienated to a foreign people. He had then answered that there was no question of that at all, and that the conditions were now being worked out by the Secretary of State's department, for which reason they could not be brought before the public. Since then the honourable Member had repeated the question, asking on every occasion in this manner: What are the conditions of the alienation of the land?

The honourable Member had also asked him whether he had received complaints from the colonists. He had received and published a number of such representations, but they were all based upon the misunderstanding that the Government intended to sell land to the Jewish people. Nothing of the kind had ever been contemplated, and he did not see what other answer he could give the honourable Member.

Mr. C. Wason said that the noble Lord could surely say where the land lay and how large it was.

Earl Percy observed that the honourable Member, before making his motion, might surely have put the categorical question whether he could inform him how matters stood with the land, whether there were natives on it, whether their rights were infringed.

Mr. Wason answered that he had already done so several times.

Earl Percy said that the recollections of the honourable Member did not agree with his own. In July of last year there came to the Foreign Office a representative of the Jewish Colonial Bank, who was at the same time a representative of a branch of the Zionist movement, and inquired of Lord Landsdowne whether he would be disposed to consider the grant of a considerable territory in East Africa, preferably near the railway, for a Jewish settlement. Thereupon Lord Landsdowne said that he was prepared to support the proposal of the Jewish Colonial Bank, provided that a suitable area of land could be found, and that they were prepared to accept conditions regarding autonomy which would be agreeable to the Secretary of State. The representatives of the Jewish Colonial Bank had already proceeded to East Africa in order to examine whether the area of land offered them suited them. Until a report had been received from these gentlemen, it would be impossible to take the House into confidence on the matter. He would nevertheless say that the House must not believe the Government to be indifferent to the claims of the settlers. It admitted that men of British race had a prior right to the tracts of land along the railway line which can best be cultivated.

But the land offered to the Jews is not on the line at all. It lies in the region between Lake Victoria and Lake Rudolf, in the province of Naivasha, where there are no natives whatever. It is an absolutely undeveloped country, lying off the railway, and should the Jewish colony be founded in this district, it will scarcely have occasion to come into contact with European settlers at all. (Hear, hear!) The native question, to which the honourable Member for Orkney and Shetland had alluded, gains all the more in importance since it has unfortunately been connected with the resignation of Sir Charles Eliot. The question of native rights had always been a matter of the Government's solicitude, and no land concession had ever been granted without the rights of the natives having been expressly safeguarded. The question had gained in importance because, since the time when the Jewish Colonial Bank made its proposals, and when in fact no proposals for settlement came from elsewhere, a great settlers' movement had been under way, and the land along the railway had already been taken up. It had been necessary to consider carefully how these land concessions on a large scale could be continued without seriously injuring the rights of the natives, and Sir Charles Eliot was informed that he was to grant no new land concessions of any considerable extent in the province of Naivasha, near the tract where the Masai graze their herds. Apart from a concession of 320 square miles to the East Africa Syndicate,¹) who wish to invest their capital there, and a small concession to a private individual, no other concessions were granted, in accordance with the instruction, and the land was reserved until such time as the question of the rights of the natives should have been carefully considered, after obtaining the opinion of those who know the country and of those who know the temper of the Masai themselves. Those were all the facts which in his opinion could now be communicated to the House, and since the honourable Member was concerned only for the rights of the natives, and the Government had likewise done everything to safeguard them, he would surely withdraw the motion. (Hear, hear!)

Sir S. Gorst: Why did Sir Charles Eliot resign?

Earl Percy: Because on the question of the reservation of the land and the withholding of new concessions to European settlers he was of a different opinion from us.²)

Sir E. Grey said that after the speech of the noble Lord he would not suppose that there was any strong desire to press the matter, but he thought that his friend, Mr. Wason, had been perfectly within his rights in moving the adjournment. The mere fact that a public official had resigned without the reason being known was in itself cause for anxiety. The native question was a very serious one; the land question, bound up with the customs of the natives, was a very delicate one. A good deal turned upon the point that it was a question of a Jewish settlement. All knew what antisemitism was and whence it came. But there was yet another view of the Jewish people: that they are millions of human beings who have been persecuted for generations and are scattered, homeless and hopeless; he confessed openly that if it had been intended to offer this people a refuge on British territory, the plan would enjoy his full sympathy. (Loud applause!) Whether it was good


¹) We discuss elsewhere the syndicate, which has nothing to do with our cause and to which no Jew belongs. ²) Not, therefore, as was falsely asserted, on account of the Zionist project. The Editors.