Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 31 · 29 July 1904
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 31 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

He was a writer of great gifts, and had he been able to concentrate himself, to give himself wholly to his art, he would have risen high in German literature. He could have won a place of the first rank. But I do not know whether he would have become the first writer of his epoch.

He was an excellent speaker: calm, witty, simple, measured and always in good taste. He commanded a form of faultless elegance, even in improvisation. His presence of mind never failed him. Perfectly master of himself, he thereby became master of the most excited assemblies and the most passionate debates. But he distrusted himself and preferred to improvisation the written preparation of his speeches, which he read aloud, which naturally lessened somewhat their immediate success, and his wise, reasonable, convincing word only rarely had that mighty breath which uplifts and intoxicates even the sceptic.

He had a fertile, creative imagination, which could devise solutions for every difficulty and conjure up pictures of great beauty. But with all his power of imagination he did not surpass Georges Eliot, whose "Daniel Deronda" is preferred by some to "Altneuland."

He had a keen practical understanding, and he proved it by the organisation of the Zionist movement, of the Congresses, of the Jewish Colonial Bank and of the National Fund. But in this direction, too, the great Jewish financiers, industrialists, merchants and administrators may regard themselves as his equals.

Less a poet than Heinrich Heine, a lesser orator than Disraeli, less imaginative than the Christian woman Eliot, smaller as an administrator than Baron Hirsch, he was nevertheless greater than any one of them, because he was all these things at once. And he was something else besides. His mind was nourished and adorned by the most modern, most highly developed culture of Western Europe; his heart beat in the same rhythm with the Jews of the most traditional Eastern Europe. He placed the reasonable, deliberate method of the statesman, of the coolest of calculators, in the service of the most poetically daring conceptions. And, to pass over nothing, he was favoured also by outward appearance and by those accessories which have so great an importance in human affairs. He was handsome, he was tall and well-formed, he had a noble, thoughtful brow, a black, commanding eye, an enchanting smile, a warm, strong voice that carried far. He was born and grew up in easy circumstances, and his innate pride never knew the humiliations of poverty. His eye was ever accustomed to look at the other straight and full, were it an Emperor, a King or the Pope. Material independence stiffened his backbone, which never learned to bend in servility.

The Jewish people has produced many talents; but they were egoists or fragmentary talents. We had a Heinrich Heine; but he sang of love, of the Rhine and of the pilgrimage to Our Lady of Kevlaar; we had a Jehuda Halevy, but his Jewish longing spent itself wholly in harmonious lyric verse; a Disraeli, but he created British Imperialism; a Manasseh ben Israel, but his ideal was confined to obtaining permission for England to be opened to the Jews; a Simson, the "born President," but he had himself baptised in order to preside over political assemblies in Germany; a Mendelssohn, the apostle of Western civilisation, but he taught contempt for traditional Jewish values. And for the first time after two thousand years the Jewish people brought forth a man who was an equally admirable European and at the same time an enthusiastic Jew, who had the most radical ideals of progress and at the same time a wonderful historical sense, who was poet and statesman for the Jewish cause, who was President, orator, organiser, dreamer, man of action. Cautious where he could be, bold where he had to be, ready for every sacrifice and even for martyrdom, in so far as it concerned himself, and indulgent, of inexhaustible patience towards all others; proud, magnanimous, dignified and yet modest, brotherly towards the simplest and the humblest.

This man was Theodor Herzl, and he was only forty-four years of age when he was lost to us.

* * *

We know what killed him. Let us not speak of it. I will not become bitter. My anger shall not join itself to my grief. I hear people murmuring around me: "A public man must have a thick skin. He must be armoured against attacks and calumnies."

Unhappy people! Had Herzl been unfeeling, would he then have felt the Jewish pain so violently that he lost his peace over it, that he turned away from the literary career which smiled upon him and flung himself instead into the furnace of militant Zionism? His exquisite sensitiveness made him the originator and leader of Zionism, but it also made him feel cruelly all the wounds which his brutal and treacherous enemies dealt him. And at last it has shattered the poor tormented heart.

* * *

And the future?

I keep all my hopes, but for the moment do not ask me about the future; my tears still prevent me from seeing it clearly.


A Letter from the Grand Rabbi of France to Dr. Alex. Marmorek.

6 July 1904. Wildbad (Württemberg).

Dear Doctor Marmorek!

I keenly regret that my absence from Paris prevents me from attending your great meeting on Saturday evening.

I should hold it my duty to join in the noble demonstration for the deeply lamented Dr. Theodor Herzl.

His untimely death has grieved me deeply. You know on what cordial and friendly terms I stood with him from the beginning.

I congratulate myself today on having known closely this valiant apostle of the cause of Judaism, who sacrificed everything — fortune, position, the love of his family, rest and health — for the triumph of the great idea which he had grasped and of which he became the untiring, convinced and eloquent defender.