No. 34 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…came up, he thought it right to oppose Dr. Herzl — not openly, mind you, but behind his back — by fighting everything that Herzl did, by striving everywhere to disparage him and his policy, and by doing his utmost to scatter the seed of discord wherever it seemed at all possible to him. Even at the third Congress Dr. Gaster sought to undermine Dr. Herzl's position in the movement. Indeed, it is certain that what he calls the "clumsier hands," which sought to deal Herzl one blow after another — that these "clumsier hands" were very near to Dr. Gaster's own pen when he wrote the phrase down. His motives may well have been of the highest and the purest; the East Africa question has nothing to do with them.
It is absolutely and utterly false to assert — and I contradict it most emphatically — that anything whatever in the East Africa affair was undertaken without Dr. Herzl's direct instruction, and without his knowledge and approval. The words which Dr. Gaster caught up in Vienna, as though they had come from Dr. Herzl's lips, are entirely apocryphal, for Dr. Herzl was honest and open-hearted. Some weeks ago Dr. Gaster publicly made certain confused and thoroughly false statements concerning the East Africa project. When I felt bound to contradict him in every word, and called upon him to prove the correctness of his assertions, he sought refuge in silence. And now, doubtless relying upon the short memory of the public, he repeats them at great length, without producing the least proof. Every Zionist will surely recognise for himself the worth of this sophistry, even if he is little acquainted with Dr. Gaster's method of darkening reason with phrases.
I do not intend to open here a discussion upon the wisdom or other merits of the East Africa project; but I enter once more my most earnest protest against Dr. Gaster's attempt to besmirch, in the eyes of Zionists, all those who approve of the project, by asserting that they are less anxiously desirous than he and the opponents of the plan to see our people restored as a nation in Palestine, and that they are less devoted to the Zionist ideal. After the assurance given by all Zionists who favour the project, that they do so only because they see in it merely a means towards carrying out the Basle Programme, such an assertion on Dr. Gaster's part would place him beyond all discussion, were I not certain that in Dr. Gaster's case his attitude towards those who differ from his views has no worse — or no better — cause than a somewhat exaggerated opinion of himself, and his constant and ungovernable desire to parade everywhere as the right and perfect man!
Dr. Gaster at the same time declares himself a true friend of the movement and a true promoter of Dr. Herzl's work. With all my heart I could wish to confirm this his own estimate, for the harvest is heavy and the labourers are few. But the tree must be known by its fruit; and when I think of all that has happened, and of the path which Dr. Gaster for years thought fit to tread, then I say: may God preserve the movement from many such "friends," and the work of Dr. Herzl from many such "promoters"!
Yours faithfully, L. J. Greenberg.
How We Are Fought.
Some days ago the First Congress of Jewish University Students from the South Slav lands was held in Osijek. A detailed report of its proceedings already appeared in the last number of "Die Welt," but in truth it gave only a faint picture. Only those who were in Osijek on those days can tell of the general enthusiasm that reigned among the Jews there. In every tobacconist's, in most of the shops, one saw Dr. Theodor Herzl's portrait draped in crape, Zionist emblems and books, and at every step one met people whose breasts were adorned with the blue-and-white ribbon or with Herzl's likeness. And then the Congress itself! Fifty young Zionists, full of hope for the future, from those lands in which until lately there was no Zionism at all, and beside them the small handful of Croats of the Mosaic persuasion. It is true that before the Congress feeling in a part of the Croatian academic youth was hostile to Zionism — our gentlemen opponents had, after all, represented us as enemies of Croatdom — but at the close of the Zionist day, after the Congress, we had the sympathies of most, and of the best, elements of Croatdom on our side. The assimilationists enjoyed full freedom of speech; but when they had read off their pronouncement, and it had been proved to them that Judaism absolutely requires Zionism for its preservation, it was a certain Mr. Felix Kohn who spoke the memorable words: "Judaism is lost. Get yourselves baptised! Let us all be baptised, or it will come to a Kishineff!" The word had fallen, and a platform for the struggle was found: the upholding and propagation of Judaism through Zionism, or its dissolution through assimilation and baptism. It occurred to no one to prove that assimilation and baptism do not mean a dissolution of Judaism, nor a solution of the Jewish question, for that was no longer necessary to the victory of Zionism. Seven so-called Croats of the Mosaic confession did indeed applaud Mr. Kohn's proselytising words; but against them stood a new factor, one denied by the assimilationists: the Jewish people. All who were present at this meeting, and who had come with the most hostile feelings, now found satisfaction in one cry alone: "Long live Judaism, long live Zionism!" This cry spread through the whole town, through all the Jewry of Osijek — and on the following day Mr. Felix Kohn appeared at the Zionist Congress and declared that those words had escaped him only in a moment of absence of mind. The seven others, however, who applauded, have made no declaration, and so remain by assimilation and baptism — but against them, on Sunday afternoon, there were 500 Jewish citizens who cried out: "We were and we are Jews, and therefore we will be Zionists!" In that moment the Zion idea conquered for itself a mighty, strong fortress, from which it will set out upon its triumphal march far through the lands on the Drave, the Save and the lower Danube.
What, then, do the assimilationists do? At the meeting they were as still as mice, and no voice of dissent was raised when all declared for Zionism, all for the founding of the Zionist society "Osijek." But revenge there must be, and a Zionist success must not be permitted. If it cannot really be slandered, then it must be done through the press. On Saturday, after the scene with the court probationer Kohn, the chief of police had dissolved the meeting on account of the general excitement — but on Sunday, of course, the second day of the Congress and the imposing citizens' meeting took place.