Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 51.
(continued from page 5)
…perception of given advantages, without however making the slightest concession to the surrounding world at the expense of the national cult — that, they say, is the ground of the eternal enmity between Jews and non-Jews.
But however that may be, this much is certain and undisputed: that the hatred of the Jews has indeed existed for more than 2000 years, but that there is still no prospect which would justify the hope that it will shortly vanish from the world. In whatever situation we have found ourselves, there has every time been a means to burn us. And henceforth too, the bloody watchword of Charles IX. from the Paris Massacre of St. Bartholomew holds good against us Jews, the gruesomely monotonous cry: Kill, kill!
* * *
In view of the above, one may compare the fresh outbreak of a Jew-baiting with the sudden darting shaft of fire that flickers up beneath an ever-damping ash until the blazing sheaves of flame leap upward. It is now nearly a full quarter of a century since such a shaft of fire burst into flame, since the last great Jew-baiting raged that truly did honour to its name. In the autumn of the year 1879, Heinrich von Treitschke, disdaining the scanty mask of hypocrisy, gave the herald's signal in his "Preussische Jahrbücher," in finely rounded and full sentences, to unleash a storm upon German Jewry. It would be quite wrong to award Stöcker the praise of having made this movement. At that time the social-political reformer, lamenting his adverse fate with a woebegone mien, had arrived in the silted-up harbour from which vigorous and rising parties had long since drawn off the water. The Christian-Social daily, the "Deutsche Volkswacht," which bore upon its brow as motto the Mosaic word "Love thy neighbour as thyself," had died a gentle death. The Christian-Social party treasury, on the other hand, had been plundered to the last pfennig — namely by Stöcker's friend and comrade-in-arms, the tailor Grüneberg. Only then came, most welcome to him, the antisemitic tidal wave, which helped to carry his stranded little ship out again onto the high seas of the politics of the day.
Treitschke, however, the eloquent, had once again, in his accustomed manner, been able to feel clearly while writing down his lines that he had taken the word out of the mouths of many others. He had chosen a favourable time for his "objective" discussions of the German Jews. Behind the noisy agitations of the day, he said, there lay hidden not only trade envy, the baseness of the mob and hatred of the company-promoters, but the unerring instinct of the masses had recognised in the preponderance of the Jews in Germany a grave danger to the new German life. It was no empty phrase when one spoke to-day of a Jewish question. A hail-thick series of counter-declarations, pamphlets and newspaper articles followed this thrust, and confirmed the established fact of the Jewish question.
Treitschke's appearance found on the one hand the thunderous applause of the great mob; on the other it aroused angry offence that the professor should have broken the ice of prudish silence on this delicate question. Very rightly does an impartial judge remark on this, in an excellent polemic against Stöcker, that it is too absurd that one should be allowed to write publicly about God and the world, about State and Church, about everything that moves between heaven and earth, only not about the effects, in contemporary history, of the emancipation of the Jews. For a full year the battle surged on unabated, waged with ugly bitterness and unheard-of passion — it was, after all, a matter of the Jews. All at once the glistening amber varnish of new-German tolerance and humanity burst, and it was seen that these had after all been only "foreign words."
In his essay Treitschke had said that only a few months before, the reverse Hep-Hep cry had still prevailed in Germany. Whoever had ventured to speak, however moderately, of an undeniable weakness of the Jewish character had been branded a barbarian by the entire press. By no means, answers a colleague of his at the time at the Berlin University, in his rejoinder as calm as it was decided — by no means was this agitation in the newspapers only a few months old; it dated from the year 1875.
He proves this among other things by a quotation from the Ultramontane "Germania," which in its refreshing naïveté recalls the merry Pückler style: "We must soon write Jew-articles again, for the Jews are beginning to grow wanton anew." Treitschke, however, replies to him in his rejoinder that the movement against the Jews was in truth of much older origin; he had seen it growing in silence for more than a decade — whereby it is incidentally admitted by himself that the true ground of the Jew-baiting does not lie "in the great share of Semitism in the impudent greed of the company-promoting mania." According to Treitschke's testimony, then, the beginning is placed as far back as the sixties, in which decade a man who looked into the hearts and reins of his contemporaries with astonishing penetration wrote down the words: "The instinctive race antagonism is mightier in Germany than any reasoning." And as a racial struggle almost all the adversaries conceive the whole development of the Jewish question, as Treitschke too did from the outset: the Jews are to become Germans, without prejudice to their faith and their old sacred memories, even though he later contradicted himself. In this, at least, they remained consistent.
Hence, too, the concentrated outburst of his Teutonic hatred was directed against the historian Graetz, whom he cannot forgive for the fact that his history of the Jewish people is regarded as a standard work. This "arrogant, provocative despiser of Christianity and of the German people" is struck by the resounding blows of a consummate rhetoric. There we hear the lovely natural notes of an elemental hatred in their unclouded purity … "It cannot absolutely be denied that the Jews in Germany are more powerful than in any other country of Western Europe."
In this repugnant combating of the Jewish historian another colleague is at one with Treitschke, who, unlike all the others, judges and criticises the attacks of the "Preussische Jahrbücher" from the standpoint of the confessional question. This scholar, who in his pamphlet regards "Palestine at most as an opportunity for travel," falls into grim agitation over the man who cannot bring himself "to attune himself to the natural tone of the people with which we wish to merge," and so he asserts that Graetz has achieved a frightful perversity of judgments of feeling. With these bombastic phrases the man is lectured to whom, between the lines, a certain recognition, however reluctantly, cannot after all be denied — in impotent wrath, or, as Lessing would say, with a gnashing sigh that sighs at being only a sigh.
It is, however, the deepest and truest justification of Graetz's standpoint when Treitschke himself, in the course of the continuing polemic, admits that a complete fusion of Jewry with the Western nations could never be wholly achieved. He does not even wish it, the Prussian professor; "Mixed marriages between unbaptised Jews and Christians," so