Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 1 · 6 January 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20
Facsimile · scan 3 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 1. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)


...sphere, bring particular abilities. The branches of work that come chiefly into consideration are: diplomacy, agitation and organisation, and finance. Each of these activities needs a whole man, a special man. Hitherto we had only one single man of special abilities. That was Herzl. His activity was pre-eminently a diplomatic one. And truly, the portfolio of Foreign Affairs was in good hands. No less a person than Chamberlain lately praised the "great skill" of Herzl. But how do matters look in our interior? Have we won the masses for ourselves? No. Proof: the small number of shekel-payers. Is the Jewish educated class on our side? No. Proof: the weak following in the centres of culture. Is the organisation a taut one? No. Proof: the failure in the campaign against the communal bodies. Small the number of adherents, poor in educated men, slack the organisation. Such is the state of the movement. And why? Because the requisite measure of attention was not devoted to internal affairs, because no special department for the Interior was established in the central body. The main weight of the work was wrongly laid upon diplomacy, and men agitated only as well, organised only as well. The internal work sank to one of the second class. Diplomacy was trumps. Every green student held himself a born diplomatist, and if he had heard one course of lectures on international law, he withdrew in a superior manner from the internal work and trifled away his time, in a furor diplomaticus, with simple-minded combinations about foreign affairs, and believed that in this way he was rendering our cause a great service. And the finances? This department too was completely neglected. A financier was never elected into the leadership hitherto. And yet it was emphasised by it again and again that the beginning of the realisation of our idea was at present purely a question of money, that, in possession of sufficient funds, we could begin with the entry into Palestine. Ergo, an able financier ought to have sat in the Smaller A.C. The want of such a man makes itself felt, too, in the most sensible manner. Proof: the abnormally small progress of our banking institutions. That must now become otherwise.

I picture to myself the composition of the future Smaller A.C. as follows: It has to consist, now as before, of five men. One member must possess the special abilities not only to maintain our diplomatic relations, but also to extend them. The work within has to be undertaken by a man whose talent for organisation, together with an exact knowledge of Jewry, stands beyond doubt. The finances are to be entrusted not to a trader, but to a financier. At the side of these three men there must stand, as adviser, one who knows Palestine exactly. The chair in the college has to be taken by a man who is capable of representing our movement worthily. Only a harmonious and even co-operation of such men offers the full guarantee of doing justice in every respect to the demands made upon the leadership. However great the diplomatic successes that may be won, the movement will not and cannot advance evenly unless at the same time the organisation sets to work with equal energy, unless at the same time the financial apparatus functions with equal force. The necessity of creating the post of one exactly acquainted with the public-law, political and economic conditions of Palestine lies in the final goal of our endeavours. The unity of command within and of representation without is embodied in the chairman, the leader. The future leadership has

therefore to consist not formally of five and in fact of one man, but actually of five men as well, who must bring special abilities for the departments assigned to them. It is not the man who is to be elected, but the men. To each of these five men a secretary is to be assigned. A secretary, not a clerk. He is to be the fellow-worker and fellow-counsellor of the head of his department. The secretaries have to read the incoming correspondence of the several departments, to report to their chiefs, and to work out the drafts made necessary by resolutions passed. In this way the individual members of the Smaller A.C. will not only be in part relieved in their work, but a rising generation will be trained which will be able at any time to fill the gaps that arise in the leadership through death, illness or other causes, or to introduce another elected member of the A.C. into the work.

It is subject to no doubt whatever that the composition of a leadership in the sense suggested will meet with great difficulties. The finding of suitable men, the diversity of their places of residence, their material attachment to a particular place, and so forth, are certainly obstacles not to be overlooked. Yet with some good will and with the needful readiness for sacrifice the difficulties can be overcome. They must be overcome.

As concerns the seat of the leadership, every place furnished with modern means of communication, whose police regulations permit of quiet work, is suited for the establishment of the central body there. As a matter of course, therefore, London also. What has been advanced against Vienna has already been refuted. Nor is there any reasonable ground for altering what exists. In the course of the discussion that has been opened, Vienna too has been pleaded for. Yet most of the reasons adduced do not seem to me quite sound. I am for Vienna because Vienna is the seat of the Zionist educated class. Vienna has no fewer than eleven Zionist academic corporations. Four fraternities: Ivria, Kadimah, Maccabäa, Unitas. Seven societies: Bar-Kochba, Bar-Giora, Erez Israel, Jordania, Leo Pinsker, Theodor Herzl, Theologia. If one reckons the strength of each corporation at an average of twenty men, this gives, the Finkenschaft*) not included, an organised academic league of 220 students. If each corporation brings to our movement every year only one single serviceable member, this means an increase of 11 men yearly, who with the right training can be formed into secretaries, or as the case may be into leaders. Such favourable conditions for a constant rising generation in the leadership exist nowhere outside Vienna. Ergo, Vienna offers all guarantees for the stability of the seat of the leadership; ergo, Vienna is the natural seat of the central body.

My proposal, then, is: A purely Zionist leadership, consisting of four expert directors and a chairman, with its seat in Vienna.

Dr. Maximilian Piekarski.


Vienna or London.

Esteemed Editors!

The two articles by Dr. Friedemann which appeared in No. 45 and No. 52 of the "Welt", in which he advocates the removal of the centre of gravity of our movement to London, I have with the greatest interest


*) Finkenschaft is the whole body of the students not organised in the fraternities.