Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 1.
(continued from page 3)
What We Ought to Do.
...read, and I agree entirely with his view. He has set forth what led him to this view in so thorough and clear a manner that I could hardly add anything. My observations would amount only to a repetition of what he has said, and I believe that a residence of many years in England, my acquaintance with English conditions and English character, may well entitle me to a judgment. I have also read the objections of Dr. Deiches in your issue No. 48 of 25 November, but they have changed nothing in my opinion. Dr. Friedemann has, in my view, aptly refuted them. Only to one of them, which he has not touched upon, I should like to return here. Dr. Deiches has no great opinion of the degree of education of the Jewish working masses in England. (He adds, justly, that absolutely no reproach attaches to them on that account.) Upon me, however, these masses did not make that impression. When I was in London in the year 1898, where Dr. Herzl delivered his well-known great speech in the "Great Assembly Hall" in the East End before some five thousand of that working class, not I alone, but also the well-known English writer Mr. Sidney Whitman, who was present (he described the impression received at the time in his report published in an English paper), was completely surprised by the bearing of this multitude, by the strained attention and the evident understanding with which it listened to this address, delivered in the German language, as well as to that of Father Ignatius which followed it in the English language. Both were received with great enthusiasm, the opposing one of a Jewish hearer with loud signs of disapproval. On the next day I was present when a deputation from English manufacturing towns called upon Dr. Herzl to obtain his advice in a matter concerning the "Zionist Federation", and again I was struck by the sensible, businesslike manner in which they stated their case. — This by the way.
I too have gained from the residence in England mentioned above the impression that the whole milieu there is so favourable a one as would hardly be found elsewhere. I am also convinced that a committee sitting in London would find with every English Government, be it the present one or one of the Opposition, a benevolent reception and, if not support by deed, yet support by good counsel. And I cherish the hope that through a tactful activity developed in London many of the influential elements who are now still opposed will in time turn their sympathy toward us.
I had already for a considerable time been of the opinion, and I believe it was shared by many of our influential adherents, that, if circumstances had permitted Dr. Herzl to take up his residence in London for a longer period, the movement would have made considerable progress, in any case greater than in Vienna, which also became its centre only on his account. I do not doubt that Dr. Herzl himself would have been of the same opinion.
A committee situated in London would, as a matter of course, have to remain in constant touch with one to be established in Germany for Continental internal affairs.
The Congresses and all official assemblies would have to take place, now as before, on the Continent. Thus the misgiving that English might become the official language of Zionism would also fall to the ground.
Hamburg, December 1904.
Respectfully Gustav G. Cohen.
If one looks about in many Zionist circles, one notices at every step the ignorance even in fields that are closely connected with the movement. One is a Zionist, that is to say, one pays one's shekel and a society subscription (or perhaps not), reads the title-page of a Zionist paper, and is vexed when one meets an assimilationist who provocatively gives loud voice to his conviction of the unmotivated enthusiasm of a Zionist. Naturally one argues with him, and just as naturally one often gets the worst of it. For a "trained" assimilationist flings fact upon fact, figure upon figure in one's face, quotes till one's hearing and sight forsake one — and to all this many have nothing to oppose. They can neither refute his data nor adduce any of their own in support of our cause, for the simple reason that they know nothing at all; and the finest, sincerest enthusiasm is of no avail there. Many will say: "Then one simply does not argue. Zionism to-day no longer has need of proselytising. Whoever is a proper Jew holds with us already, and assimilationist rabble we do not want in our ranks at all." That is very wrong. The Western Jews — and only of these is there question here, for the Eastern ones stand, almost without exception, with us — are for the most part opponents of Zionism from ignorance of the circumstances; assimilation is to them too only a means of despair, but they have once for all run themselves fast in it, often for generations, have at last won by struggle a few small advantages, which they naturally do not judge objectively, but according to the heavy price they have paid for them, and now they see in Zionism nothing more than a danger that threatens to rob them of these dearly bought advantages, true and imagined — what is more natural than that they will have nothing to do with it, that they combat it? With such people one can accomplish something only by a clear, pertinent exposition supported by many quite tangible data; and it is surprising how easily many an inveterate assimilationist is to be won in this way. Among the students especially much can be done in this respect, and I always think with a certain wistful pleasure of a curious little story that came to my ears this summer: A friend tells me that a certain acquaintance, a physician in a larger provincial town which until lately was a stronghold of anti-Zionism, has had his son baptised just after his school-leaving examination. "Why, what has come over him?" I ask, quite dumbfounded. "He always stormed so against baptism?" "That is a peculiar matter; he says that when the lad now comes to the University at Vienna, he will be caught away from him by the Zionists — and so he simply chooses of the two evils the one that is in his opinion the lesser. In this way he is at least sure that he will not come back to him a Zionist." That is certainly a fine testimonial for our Vienna students, but I must nevertheless find the good man's fear exaggerated — let one compare the number of Zionist students with the total number of Jewish students in Vienna! But I have strayed from my theme. It is my conviction that our movement would have a considerable increase to record if we only understood how to set the matter clearly before them and to replace their erroneous views by correct ones. But for that most are wanting in positive knowledge.
Meanwhile it is not to be denied that the movement to-day no longer stands so necessarily in need of a further increase, and that the chief weight is no longer to be laid upon propaganda alone, but upon work within. And here, no doubt, the ignorance of our Zionists makes itself