"Die Welt" — No. 2. — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
...understanding found ever more and ever more clearly. I believe that each of us has had the feeling that that which moves us in our inmost heart, the thought of the restoration of our people and its settlement upon our Jewish soil of Erez Israel, is the strongest bond that holds us together and that is able to help us over all outward difficulties. That we have arrived at this conviction is due in no small measure to the self-sacrificing self-denial of the members of the Smaller A.C. I hold it to be our duty, after the manifold attacks that have been directed against the Smaller A.C., to declare that we have gained full confidence anew. I express to them the hearty thanks of the Greater A.C.
The Chairman, Architect Marmorek, closed the conference of the Greater A.C. with a few words of thanks to the members present for their readiness to make sacrifices and their friendly co-operation in the national work.
The East Africa Question.
The English offer has called forth continuous and lively debates in the Anglo-Jewish press. Articles pro and contra appeared in all the Jewish newspapers of England and America; even in such as had borne themselves coldly or indifferently towards Zionism. But we will single out only a few voices, and begin with a Zionist one. In the last number of the "Maccabean" we find an essay by Mr. Israel Zangwill on "Zionism and the English Offer." As is known, Zangwill is a zealous advocate of the East Africa project, and this essay of his, too, culminates in the sentence: "Better Zionism without Zion than Zion without Zionism." He exhorts the American, the "practical" Jews, to join Zionism in order to prevent the formation of a Palestinian majority at the Congress. The American "Jewish Comment" has, in genuine American fashion, instituted a kind of inquiry among the most eminent Jews of America. Of all the answers received, that of the well-known American-Jewish diplomatist, Mister Oskar Straus, deserves our particular attention. After he had declared that he was no Zionist, but that he was interested in the welfare of the "suffering brethren of his people in Russia and Roumania," he said: "When I heard for the first time of the offer on the part of Great Britain of a large territory in East Africa for Jewish settlements, I was highly pleased. I believed that this offer would be received by the most prominent Jews in England with due recognition and attention. If the Zionist movement brought forth or occasioned this offer, then we must at last admit that Zionism is no longer merely a dream. It has also a practical side and extends far beyond the borders of Palestine or even of Asia; it extends as far as Africa. Indeed, the first thought must be the following: Is the land capable of colonisation, and can it, so far as the conditions of the soil, the climate and the situation are concerned, inspire hope of success? The responsibility for the decision is great, since the leaders who by their counsel or influence should bring about such a settlement would commit an inexcusable act.
I learn that a commission has been sent out for the purpose of investigating the territory. I know nothing of the competence of the commission. But assuming that it is really competent to undertake the necessary investigation and to make a trustworthy report, then we must await this report before we come to a decision... Should all questions be answered by the report in a favourable sense, then the second question arises: Can people be found in Russia and Roumania who would be willing to become colonists, and who would be physically fitted for it? If this question, too, should be answered with Yes, then I am for such a colonisation. It matters little to me now whether this colony be independent, autonomous, or a crown land of Great Britain. I should in any case be content. I am even inclined to believe that it would be better if the colony were at the beginning not an independent one. Let the future shape itself. I doubt, too, whether the colonists who could be obtained would, especially in the first years, be capable of assuming the responsibility of government. That will appear only later. It is not enough that there are some Jews who were or could be governors of provinces; the class of population to be governed is to be taken into consideration." Then Mr. Straus thinks that, if there were several such countries as the United States to which the Russian Jews could emigrate, East Africa would be unnecessary, which, however, is not the case in view of the first condition. Then he expresses his confidence in Mr. Zangwill and his abilities, and admonishes him nevertheless not to forget, in his zeal "for the fifty or hundred thousand co-religionists," the millions of Jews who are also "patriots" and wish to be full citizens of their country... All's well that ends well!
Partly in connection with this, the "Jewish Chronicle" of the 6th of January discusses the East Africa question in its leader. "Whither?" asks the English paper. "I have, namely, spoken with Dr. Hildesheimer about the situation," said Dr. Adler in the meeting of the "Anglo Jewish Association," and he rightly remarked that the only question which must now fill the Jewish mind is the question of the "Whither?" The truth of this remark is clear. It is the dominating question for the Jews of the whole world. It touches the people at every stage, not only the unfortunate ones who are driven in masses into foreign lands, but also the more fortunate "Israelites" who dwell in freedom-loving countries and whose peace is endangered by the arrival of their poorer brethren. Wherever we are settled, we cannot free ourselves from this endless question. For years already a redistribution has been going on within the Jewish people. Oppressed and starving in one land, it breaks into a new land. In this year of grace 1905 the Continent is filled with Jews, although they scatter in unceasing search for freedom. The Jewish fugitives stream unceasingly across the frontiers, to be here derided, there threatened, there again held up by thousands, as is now the case, and their brethren meanwhile support them by charity.
The Jewish Luftmenschen crowd upon the ships that traverse the ocean, and seek a new home. The leaders of the people come together to discuss the emigration crisis. And to the cry: "Whither?" there resounds towards them from hundreds of platforms the demagogic cry: "Not hither!" The whole history of the world has nothing to show that would be like this bewildering drama of many millions of human beings who are either condemned to the most cruel torments or must wander among the nations which slam the door in their faces. One must doubt whether the Western nations in general comprehend what is happening around them. The Jewish tragedy remains uncomprehended by the Christian world, since it is not played upon one stage in its whole dreadfulness, but in separate