No. 10. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…offers the best security that the Jews can be preserved as Jews for the world". But why, then, an experiment upon another territory?
And while on page 3 you expressly emphasize that "East Africa can in no sense be a rival of Palestine", that only "in Palestine and only in Palestine" can we "again become a nation", on page 5 you describe the settlement of East Africa as a means for us "to become once more a great people — great in the best sense of the word". You will grant me that it is difficult here to make out your opinion.
How heartily do I agree with you when you write: "It seems to me, however, that in every case where the fulfilment of prophecies has been demonstrated with mathematical exactness, human labour has played a considerable, an essential part therein."
But I beg of you, honoured fellow Zionist, do not divert this human — in this case Jewish — labour, which is to make the prophecy "Palestine for the Jews" a reality, away to Uganda, so that the close of your letter, "the attainment of a home for the Jewish people in Palestine, recognized by public law, the rebuilding of Israel as a nation", may very soon be fulfilled.
With Zion's greetings I am your most devoted Dr. Felix Pinkus.
Berne, the 15th of Adar 5665.
The National Assembly of the Orthodox in Hungary.
(Continuation.)
First Day. Evening Sitting.
After the opening of the sitting Dr. Révész speaks, amid continued disturbance, upon the draft statutes. He is indeed willing to concede to the rabbis the sole decision in all religious questions, but would wish to see the autonomy of the communities, gravely endangered by the draft, preserved at least in administrative matters.
After the obligatory scene of uproar Rabbi Fuchs (Nagyvárad) replies that no sure boundary can be drawn between the religious and the administrative affairs of a community. The speaker demands full confidence in the rabbis. "We are no officials, but men learned in the things of God!" He moves that the draft statutes — which are undoubtedly faulty — be referred back to the Committee of Thirty-one, which had drawn up the document, but that the committee be enlarged by 18 members to be elected from the assembly. Let the committee modify the draft statutes in the manner desired, but above all let it word the paragraphs bearing upon the election of the national president, so that at least the settlement of this most important item of the order of the day may be assured.
Hirsch (Kolozsvár) finds this motion altogether illegal and demands that the election of the president take place only after the whole draft of the statutes has been debated. This served the assembly as the signal for a well-nigh endless disturbance, which spread even to the presidential tribune.
At length they struggle through to a vote, which results in the adoption of Rabbi Fuchs's motion. This resolution, to be sure, had been dictated by the conviction that the assembly, hostile to all discipline and under the direction of a helpless presidium, was incapable of any profitable deliberation.
Hirsch hands in a protest against this resolution, which was misunderstood as a protest against the loyalty of the congress altogether. Thereupon renewed uproar, to which the presidium, after half an hour's vain struggle, could at last put an end only by closing the sitting.
Second Day. Morning Sitting.
The congress assembles in a very depressed mood. The preceding day of proceedings had inspired everyone with the fear that the congress would be totally incapable of work. Moreover, the daily papers, and chiefly those in the Hungarian language, contained the most unedifying judgments upon the assembly.
Before the order of the day, therefore, Rabbi Kutna (Eisenstadt) appeals to the Jewish feeling of those assembled and most earnestly entreats them to be peaceable. But when the speaker is about to pass on to the definition of Orthodoxy, a misunderstanding occurs which once more sets all lungs in motion. The aged rabbi quotes a tolerant utterance of the preacher Mannheimer, with the intention of arguing against it. In the belief that Rabbi Kutna identifies himself with this utterance, the tiny liberal minority bestows demonstrative applause, which is answered by the majority, fifty times its superior, with thunderous contradiction, and the desperate exertions of the presidium are unable to make possible the continuation of one of the few speeches of this congress worth hearing.
Dr. Révész, when quiet has been restored, protests against the calumny of the daily papers, as though the Orthodox were lesser patriots. They would be ready to sacrifice life and property for the fatherland. (General stormy applause.)
Rabbi Schreiber (Beregszász) wishes, sans façon, to proceed at once to the election of the president. (Is rejected.)
Hereupon, in accordance with the resolution passed on the previous day, the supplementary election to the Committee of Thirty-one is held, and the assembly, since this committee was to work in the afternoon, is adjourned to the next day.
Third Day. Morning Sitting.
After the opening Dr. Schächter (Budapest), in a motion of urgency, demands the immediate discussion of the paragraph on the court of arbitration, and further makes the declaration that he has never been a candidate for the office of national president.
Hereupon the secretary Marton reads the modified paragraphs bearing upon the election of the national representation, which are accepted en bloc.
Passing to the item of the election of the president, the chairman, Rabbi Reich, devotes warmly felt words of remembrance to the departed president Leopold Lipschitz.
In the further course of the proceedings Bárkány (Lebes Kellemes) gives notice of a protest against the accepted election statutes. (Uproar.)
Rabbi Fuchs finds occasion in this to turn in vehement fashion against the idea of a union with the Neologues. He declares in the name of the assembly that the gulf between Neologues and Orthodox is unbridgeable, and that these may indeed go beside one another, but never and nevermore live with one another in peace. (!!) (Stormy applause.) Korcin speaks very effectively on the patriotism of the Orthodox.
It is resolved that only such members may be elected to the national committee as keep the Sabbath holy, and the sitting is closed.
Third Day. Afternoon Sitting.
On the order of the day stands the election of the nominating committee, which was to lay before the assembly a proposal of three names for the election of the president. But as on this