Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 12
(continued from page 1)
…eral representatives of the Berlin community, in the year 1905, between Shrovetide and Purim.
The strong man for whom there has been such long clamour has arisen at last! It was high time! — The noble champion with the flail in his coat of arms had been, in misapprehension of all popular instincts and in grievous violation of the commandment of the Bible, muzzled at the threshing — the false doctrines of freedom of thought and of the right of free expression of opinion are gaining more and more ground. Scarcely the most hardened reactionary still ventures to-day to advocate exceptional legislation. And so the strong man had first to arise from among the Liberals, openly and frankly demanding, as a liberal postulate, exceptional legislation against the adherents of unpopular ideas. I fear that even Herr Lenzmann, who is far too enlightened to be merely an antisemite, will find this liberalism somewhat astonishing — but perhaps Herr Kopsch, should the case arise, will have nothing to object to the election of this Jew.
But let us carefully follow the train of thought of the Professor which has led him to this triumph of the liberal spirit.
The keynote of his reflections is given, as he declares, by the fact that after the death of Theodor Herzl heartfelt lamentations were raised for the departed in Galicia and Russia. In Germany, he says, only numerous private societies held memorial services. — Here already one stops short! — In what way does this fact give the keynote? I will not even speak, for the present, of the fact that it is absolutely untrue that in Germany the official representatives of Judaism for the most part disgraced themselves by holding aloof from the mourning! — Nor will I speak of how noble natures can mourn the passing of a noble man, even when they are averse to his plans. That is evidently something which is incomprehensible to Professor Geiger. — I can only take his words to mean that this unheard-of national mourning, which in his opinion prevailed only in the countries mentioned, disquieted him in the highest degree, showed him how deeply the idea embodied in Herzl had taken root, and that he therefore sees himself compelled at last to make an end of it. But that would only have sense if that mourning had been observed in the same way in Germany too, which the author denies; against the mourning in Russia, etc., he can have nothing, since he immediately afterwards admits that he is prepared to declare Zionism justified in those countries. — And so it would seem after all that the author knows full well that among us, too, in the days of mourning, it was demonstrated in the most convincing manner how wide are the circles into which our idea has penetrated — circles that embrace an infinitely greater area than our organisation occupies. — And the recognition of this, which he shrinks from admitting, has called forth that article.
But what, after all, is the meaning of recognising Zionism as conditionally justified for those countries? If Zionism is really, as the author further seeks to prove, a logical absurdity, inwardly unjustified — if its foundation, a Jewish nationhood, is a lie — how can it then be justified in other countries? — From this it would seem after all as though it were not inner reasons that keep the author away from Zionism, but rather the specifically German conditions. If, then, exceptional legislation were to be introduced here in Germany, Zionism would appear justified even to Herr Geiger. And so we might almost be grateful to him for wishing, by the exceptional laws he proposes, to give us the legal foundation which in his opinion is still lacking.
Professor Geiger lays stress on making it clear that he is expressing only his personal opinion — I believe others will lay still more stress on this statement! All the more disturbing is the manner in which the author sets himself up as the type of the German Jew and seeks to generalise his knowledge and his way of thinking. One understands no Hebrew — one attaches no meaning to one's prayers — and so forth. — One is involuntarily reminded of little Marta's well-known composition on babies: "Where babies come from, one does not know." Giving expression, then, to his entirely personal opinion, the author declares, with the customary invocation of Goethe — of "the old master Goethe" — that he wishes to sweep only before his own door. Yes, but, worthy Professor, that is precisely the question: which is one's own door! We Zionists maintain that the great Jewish question is the most intimate concern of all Jews — we maintain that we are working not for any alien purposes, not for our "unhappy Eastern brethren," but for the Jewish whole of which we form a part. The point now is precisely to determine whether we are right or wrong in this — whether it is our own door before which we sweep. You now come forward, pompously announce that you will prove the contrary to us, and begin thus: I cannot be a Zionist, because that means sweeping before other people's doors! — Thus the conclusion is taken into the premise and the whole logical edifice is turned upside down. — This recalls the story of a rather dull boy who was nevertheless to deliver his Drosche at his Bar Mitzvah. To make it easy for him, the following question was chosen: Why does one take hold of the Lulaw at the bottom, where it is thick, and not at the top, where it is thin? — The answer was to be: Why, the Lulaw pricks! — But when the time came, the boy recited: Why does one take hold of the Lulaw at the bottom, where it is thick, and not at the top, where it pricks? — and there was no further answer!
Professor Geiger has the same compassion to spare for the suffering Jews that he has for German women and children who went down in an American ship. Since he warns against putting this compassion into action in the one case as in the other, we need not be indignant that he begins to take an interest in his unhappy countrymen only after they have gone down. He is against every relief action, since, for one thing, often only the idle are supported and "real misery is destroyed" — a turn of phrase whose meaning is not clear to me — but since, further, — mark this! — schools that are set up may be burned and teachers who are appointed may be massacred. Now I do indeed believe that with a similar argument one could arrive at frustrating the undertaking of any thing whatever, be it a political enterprise or the arranging of a game of skat — one could neither build an organ-synagogue, for it might close for want of worshippers, nor appoint a communal librarian, for he might have himself baptised — but on the other hand the thought that the Jews are not to be helped by charity and the mania for societies does contain something very true. Yet it seems strange to turn this against us. That is just what we preach. I almost suspect that the Professor overlooked this trifle, otherwise he would not have quoted our own maxim. — So it sounds quite good Zionism when he continues that every nation can obtain salvation only through itself — otherwise it deserves to perish. — He does not, to be sure, speak of a nation, but puts in its place "every fraction of a nation"; but what holds for the part must surely