Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 33 · 18 August 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20
Facsimile · scan 3 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 33. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…ish understanding the seventh Congress has left a heavy task; for the commentators and interpreters the wheat is now in bloom. And it is of importance that even now the still fresh impression of the Congress be recorded, and the first returning echoes of all that has rung out into the distance be caught, before the commentaries have made the matter over-plain or obscure.

We absent ones of the Congress have, then, from the reports first of all gained the impression that the seventh Congress was the most programmatic since the one that created our fundamental programme; the one which, of all the successors of the first Congress, occupied itself most with the fundamental question of the movement, and pointed most mightily and decisively to the goal. It set the most impatient and the most tenacious adherents of the Jewish renaissance face to face, and by a series of violent thunderstorms dispersed the obscurities and ambiguities that had settled like mist over the highway and the bypaths of our movement. At a high price it created what one might call, borrowing from conditions familiar to us Austrians, the single language of command of political Zionism, and drew the outermost limit for the expositions and interpretations that have attached themselves to the Basle Programme and might attach themselves in future. The seventh Congress has proved the first right, has secured Palestine and its neighbouring lands as the immovable goal of the movement, and has rejected every other goal, just as it has averted the danger of a return of petty colonisation. The solemnly reaffirmed Basle Programme receives an important support in practical Palestine work, held, however, within precisely defined limits. All ideas and projects that lead away from the pure Basle Programme are excluded from official standing. The organisation of Zionism remains a closed chain, to which thoughts foreign to Palestine may attach themselves, but into which they cannot be incorporated.

I spoke earlier of a high price which the Congress has paid for having raised, out of the battle-cries of the most impatient and the most tenacious, out of the proposals and projects of those without responsibility, a guiding idea for which — be it practicable or not practicable within a foreseeable time — political Zionism can take the responsibility, and for which, under conscientious and considered leadership, it may claim the loyal following of the Zionists. By the high price, however, I mean the spectacle, not without its dangers in face of the world of our enemies, of a passionately quarrelling and divided Congress. Us, the absent ones, the outbursts of temperament of a Jewish parliamentarism run wild have alarmed. To be sure, at what assimilationist scorn gossiped in the coffee-houses — that at Basle there had been a Zionist Kramarz who wanted to treat convictions by police methods — at that we only laughed. Still, we were not prepared for such explosions, and one or another asked himself whether it would really not have been possible to keep cooler blood. But after all is said and done — we Jews are no coolly northern people that conducts its politics in a whisper. And our Congress sits for us and for our national interests, and not for strangers, and not for the conduct-marks of uninvolved schoolmasters. We, the absent ones of the Congress, know well enough: deep and manly convictions fought at Basle openly, honestly and with character. Loudly and unruly at times, as convictions are which are too strong and decided to be over-courteous and mannerly into the bargain, and to allow the plane of a compromise to smooth them to drawing-room polish. Nor does it occur to us to reproach the one with his tenacity, the other with his impatience. We tell ourselves that the men whom our confidence sent to Basle were sufficiently worthy of that confidence to judge whether the terrible gravity of the questions dealt with in the Stadtkasino justified the picture, so tempting to our opponents' mockery, of stormy Congress days.

The storm is over, the mists are dispersed. And the movement, that which has hitherto been understood by the abbreviated term, remains as before the one, undivided movement. Under the shadow of the historic flag, which years ago, in a memorable hour, was saluted by a free people, the regular army of Zionism marches on towards its hopes.

The others are a corps of free-lances, valiant hearts, irreproachable men of honour — beloved brothers, who would like to pitch their tents somewhere at the boundary-mark of the attainable. And I have so firm a faith in the unshakable vitality of Zionism that I regard the question whether we may permit ourselves the luxury of party divisions only as a question of time, not of essence. A poet and an engineer may easily be of different opinion on that point.

The most important thing is: Zionism remains. If will-less Jewry could remain — and that was a miracle — then so much the more surely does willing Jewry remain — and that is a matter of course and no miracle. Jedua.


The Verdict.

They still cannot break themselves of the habit! Irrevocably, after every Congress, the same little songs appear, from which we learn to our astonishment how badly things really stand with us. One really ought for once to examine the assimilationist papers closely, to see whether these articles and paragraphs against Zionism were not simply copied out from the time before. For they always say the same thing: schism, discontent, the end. We console ourselves with the facts, which follow the popular saying that it is precisely those pronounced dead who live longest. With a contempt cooled by habit we watch the journalistic dyers at work, see them retouch the smallest fissures into abysses, cover up the successes and belittle the aims.

Zionism is the stepchild of public opinion, in so far as that opinion is made by a quite particular kind of stagnant Jews. English and Aryan politicians — that is, politicians politically schooled and brought up in manly pride — do indeed muster calm and conscientiousness enough to comprehend our necessary tactical turns, even to value our differentiations, because these are a sign of abundant life, and to praise without reserve our final aim, a free and worthy life for the Jews, because that aim coincides with humanity and morality. But certain individual Jews, who happen to possess the power to do so, have taken it into their heads to poison us with printer's ink; and they dishonour themselves and Judaism, in that they otherwise gladly support every movement for freedom of every people, and only zealously help to barricade the one road by which the Jews can win for themselves proud equality of rights as citizens of the world.