No. 39 — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…eyes and bent back, wait eternally for its blows. Why it looks on with outcry, but without resistance, while law, authorities and population crowd the Jews together into an ever narrower space for earning a living, and while before every place of refuge surly, and soon hostile, watchmen are already encamped.
Well arrayed in the garb of the day, the congregational presidents and rabbis in all the synagogues beam with inner satisfaction and outward dignity before the numerously assembled congregation. Have they a right to receive the first good wishes, as thanks for the good deeds of the past year and as a spur for the new one? Can they — with the troubled heart that every sincere leader in Israel must now have in the face of the many evils creeping upon us, be he but a captain over a hundred — can they console themselves with an enlightened idea that brings help? It will come to pass if our New Year wishes for them are fulfilled: May a new year enter in among the lay presidents, that they may be bound to all Jews from the heart in love, and may be mindful of their people with faithful care, not only in the idle hours of their calling but at all times! A new year for the rabbis, that with an open and vigorous national word they may grasp their calling as gatherers and awakeners of the people better than they have done hitherto by diluting its culture and its historical teachings.
They must succeed in making out of our people once more those high-minded, proud figures who know how to find their way courageously before fate and life, their way out of bondage, out from among the nations. The whole mystic secret, the spell of our unhappy destiny, lies in this: that at our New Year we bless the bread and wine of others. We only buy them from them. But the true blessing for the people, for the family and for each individual among us lies in this: that, free of all dependence, our soil becomes our only master, that we win back from it wine and bread and strength and pride. Then the New Year can again be celebrated with bonfires from the mountains, such as were once kindled by the fathers as proud tokens before the surrounding peoples, whereas the grandchildren must take fright before their own neighbours because of their meagre glimmer of lights.
A New Year's greeting from the heart to all who are setting about kindling the mountain fires of their people!
—y.
Experimental Colonisation and Economic Penetration.
By Dr. Alfred Nossig.
In his essay "Large-scale Colonisation, Small-scale Colonisation and Security under Public Law" ("Die Welt" No. 37), Dr. Oppenheimer energetically advocated an immediate experimental colonisation out of the means of the National Fund. I consider this demand entirely justified. It cannot be supported emphatically enough. The manner, however, in which Dr. Oppenheimer has done so, certain arguments he has adduced, the whole programmatic form he has given to the proposed action, seem to me to contain certain dangers. In the interest of the healthy development of Zionism these points must not remain unrefuted.
* * *
Dr. Oppenheimer is a thousand times right when he insists on experimental colonisation and when he wishes to see the means of the National Fund applied to it without further delay. He is right, first of all, formally, for already the Sixth Congress resolved upon an immediate use of the National Fund for such purposes, and the Greater A.-C. accepted the detailed plan of an experimental farm as early as April 1904. It is formally quite inadmissible — unless the resolutions of our bodies are to remain an empty game — to overturn an action that has been voted, without any new obstructive fact having intervened, merely by pointing to the Turkish modes of land acquisition, which have long been precisely known.
But in substance, too, immediate experimental colonisation out of National Fund means is exactly as justified today as in April 1904, save that its undecidedness, thanks to the uninterrupted theoretical work of enlightenment and the programmatic development that has taken place in Zionism since then, ought by now to be evident to all. Whoever is so blinded by catchwords that even today he cannot grasp the difference between planless philanthropic small-scale colonisation and systematic, national-political colonisation on a rising scale; whoever even today will not see that it is not through securities under public law, or even mere Sultan's irades, that we must create for ourselves the possibility of action, but through our actions that we must create the possibility of securities under public law or of concessions on the part of the Turkish Government — such a man simply cannot be convinced by arguments; one must try to convince him by facts.
And that we can do today, now that the Congress has voted the programme of practical work by an overwhelming majority. We must not let ourselves be led astray by misgivings. Let us prove to the Turkish Government, through the economic successes of our colonisation undertaken out of the National Fund, that it has an interest in legalising the National Fund, and then it will do so.
This is also the place to remark that the fetish-like cult which we practise with our National Fund is as unjustified as it is purposeless. It is just as unjustified as the fear of the crowd that once held Alcibiades back from public speaking, and which Socrates dispelled by pointing out to him that an assembly is, after all, made up only of X, Y and Z . . . . If Baron Edmund Rothschild could sacrifice an uncontrollable number of millions for experimental colonisation, I do not see why a less well-to-do Zionist could not sacrifice five roubles and a poor one twenty kopecks for it. And if the rouble that a single Zionist gives to our cause is not at once worshipped as a national sanctuary, I do not see why the sum that X, Y and Z have brought together should be a noli me tangere?
I also call this cult contrary to its purpose, just like the coddling system in education. Guard a child against every breath of air, and it dies of every one. At all events it remains backward in its development. Our National Fund has "remained backward in its development" only because no one sees what he is actually giving for. Let the National Fund be converted into the acquisition of land and colonisation, and the ridiculously small initial capital will grow rapidly; and should a sum be lost in this fruitful, hopeful national work, the nation will quickly and gladly replace it twice over.
* * *
This brings me to that argument of Oppenheimer's which I consider the most mistaken and the most dangerous.
