Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 49 · 8 December 1905
5printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 49. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…workers, among them many who for years had attended no meetings held on behalf of Jewish national interests. A general cry went through the crowd: "Give us arms, and we will hasten to defend our brethren!" A committee has been formed to raise contributions for the Jewish self-defence. Alongside that of the revolutionary party, a general Jewish self-defence is also to be created, to defend the goods and the blood of the Jews against the black hordes. Several young men have hurried to Russia to fight out the struggle in the front ranks. A Christian lady has spontaneously given a considerable sum for this purpose.

While among the immigrant Jews these horrible events threw into all too glaring and painful light the necessity of a Jewish national policy for the creation of a secure homestead — in Palestine according to some, in a territory according to others — our Western European providers for the people still seem closed to this insight, although some already let themselves be brought to the concession that the Jews must be removed from Russia; but to the end of scattering them like dust over the whole world, so that they may nowhere form a compact nucleus, which is regarded as an infallible panacea against antisemitism. This difference in the conception of the Jewish question came to light at the meeting convened on the initiative of Rabbi Lubetzky in the Russo-Polish synagogue, in which Dr. Nordau and a leader of French Jewry, Rabbi Netter, took part. After Rabbi Lubetzky had described in moving words the immeasurable misfortune that had been conjured up over our brethren in Russia, and had exhorted those present to immediate help, R. Netter took the floor. In solemn, unctuous sentences he sought to prove that there was still ground for hope and that a rosy future awaited the Jews in Russia. "Whoever shared in the sufferings will also share in the joys. The Jews may wait confidently for a better lot in Russia, for their cause is that of humanity, since the Jews are persecuted not because they are Jews, but because they strive after light. I myself," the Rabbi continued, "witnessed the outbreak and the savage orgies of antisemitism in Algeria. (R. Netter was Rabbi in Oran when the waves of antisemitism ran high there, and was removed from office by the Government in consequence of a speech delivered at the grave of a victim of antisemitism, in which he made unwelcome allusions to the antisemitic authorities.) Now," the speaker assured them, "all disown their former errors, and all the world now pets the Jews and caresses them and vies in courting their friendship. The venerable Rabbi did not content himself merely with Bible quotations to confirm the justice now dawning for the Russian Jews; he believed he had dealt the black horde its heaviest blow by hurling at it the words of L'Hopital: "Les droits de la conscience humaine sont impressibles"; ergo one should not strike the Jews dead because they are Jews.

The Russian Jews present, many of whom are mourning more than one relative and had just been reading heart-rending letters aloud to one another, felt instinctively and with foreboding the emptiness of these fine consolations. Their minds have not yet been ensnared by the current sophistical catchwords so as to share this sweet dream. And when Dr. Nordau thereupon took the floor, he seemed to have plucked his words of Jeremiah from their grief-laden hearts. Nordau's reputation as an orator needs no making. But this time he surpassed himself. In every one of his words all the woe of his unhappy people seemed to echo. With a voice shaken by inward emotion he lamented over his people and scourged its false prophets.

"To everything there is a season," he said; "there is a time to speak and a time to keep silence. To-day is not the time to make speeches. Every word is an insult to our brethren. It is not fine words that our brethren ask of us. The previous speaker has spoken finely and held out the prospect of a rosy future. I have not this fine calm, this fine faith in the love of mankind. What has now happened does not strike me as a pestilence after which new life grows green again. When Chmelnicky slaughtered hundreds of thousands of Jews two hundred and fifty years ago, at least no one spoke of progress. To-day men are proud of progress. But where is civilisation? We cry for help, but we are answered that no one can intervene in our favour because it might do us harm. We are thrown upon ourselves alone. If we will not help ourselves, no one will help us. For a long time now the demands of progress have been droned at us to the point of weariness. Then came Tisza-Eszlar, Konitz, and we were told that these were the last struggles of reaction. In the year 1881 the victims of the Russian persecutions flooded the West. Then people asked themselves: Is this possible? Why, it is contrary to progress! Then came Kishineff, and we were told: Wait! Now thousands more have been slaughtered, and again we are told: Wait, hope! That is the wisdom of our great men! The Russo-Jewish question must be solved in Russia! Yes, Russia is now solving this question in her own way. But we do not want such a solution! We are told of the dawning of freedom. Yes, we have always bled for freedom, but for the freedom of others, and everywhere we are treated as stepchildren. Perhaps this Messianic time will come after 3000 years. But I will not be a prophet. I am capable only of thinking according to the ordinary laws of logic, that twice two is four, that two points determine a straight line. Two years ago I said at the Congress of our leaders of the people: 'They have open hearts, open hands, but not open eyes.' After Kishineff they gave two millions. Now there has been plundering again. Now too everyone will give; the world will be astonished by their generosity, and everything will vanish again like a drop of water on a red-hot plate. Only the high-minded givers will grow poorer.

"At this moment we must provide for the widows and orphans of our victims. But at the same time we must see to rescuing our brethren who are still alive. Had we given half these sums for political ends, perhaps many of the dead who are now mourned would be sitting under their fig-tree and their olive. If these our brethren now lie as corpses, it is because we did not understand how to protect the living. We can only wish and pray that these new victims may open the eyes of our leaders of the people, so that they may see where salvation lies. War is possible also when we have a land of our own, but then we shall face the enemy with arms in our hands. And the self-defence has shown that we can defend ourselves. But women and children will at least be spared!"

Nordau's speech made a shattering impression upon the audience, and in view of the sad gravity of the hour a reverent silence followed it.

While the telegraph reported scenes of horror every day, proclamations bearing the inscription "Mort aux Juifs", in which the Russian massacres were glorified, were posted up in the streets of Paris. But the French police, which happily has no Trepoff at its head, destroyed them at once. It is noteworthy that even before the butcheries in Russia began, a certain activity among the antisemites here made itself felt, as if it