Die Welt · Vol. IX, Separate Edition 3 · 31 July 1905
9printed page
scan 9 of 16

No. 3 Special Edition — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 9.

(continued from page 8)

…took place. In the course of these years we have done almost nothing but one thing: we have debated and quarrelled over it. Our literature, our meetings, our conferences of delegates — all were devoted to this question. And whoever has not yet formed an opinion about it will learn nothing from the speeches at the Congress now. If, however, I have taken this task upon myself, if I have followed the wish of my friends, it was only out of the duty of making our standpoint clear here and of defining those conclusions which follow from this general standpoint. I have one further duty, to deal with a concrete question, and that is precisely the Uganda project.

On Uganda I shall not need to say much. The reports that have been laid before us, and which were also published in the "Welt," have made this work very much easier. As you know, there are differences among the reports. According to the most favourable, we shall, after the expenditure of the greatest forces and means, perhaps have 20,000 souls settled there after some decades; according to the report of Prof. Kaiser, barely 5000 souls; and according to the last, not even that could be attained. You will all well remember what hopes were bound up with this project at the last Congress; what hopes the friends of this project awakened among our unhappy and starving people. And what, in the end, is the result? If we expend forces and means for decades, we shall at best attain one-fifth, perhaps one-quarter, of what our emigration from Russia alone has yielded annually in recent years. To Zionism as such it has no relation. One might think: the charitable or emigration societies will wish to concern themselves with it. You know that steps have been taken in this direction. Herr Wolffsohn entered into very wide contact with all the societies, and only a few were found who were willing even to deliberate upon it. That too is easy to understand. These societies have not the idea upon which we rest. Without such an idea, colonisation projects on a great scale are never practicable. So they, too, do not want it. Only one thing remains for us: to decline the project, but to decline it with thanks.

Mr. Shire was, in my opinion, very much in the wrong yesterday when he sought to reproach the English Government with having acted in its own interest in this matter. Gentlemen! We build political Zionism, indeed, not only upon the interest of the Jewish people, but in a certain measure upon the interest of all peoples. We know well enough that in some countries we are not much liked. Only, the peoples have hitherto applied but one method: to oppress and persecute us. England is the first nation to have understood that the best way is to help the Jewish people to its homestead (applause). Let us hope that what England has understood the other peoples also will understand, and then it would be much easier for us to reach our goal. We hope for still more: when England perceives that we see our goal only in Palestine, she will assist us toward that goal (great applause), and that in the interest of the English people as well. Of Uganda, then, we need speak no more. We will and can only decline it with deep thanks.

Now comes Mister Zangwill and asks: I too am inclined to find that Uganda is not altogether suited to us. But a better, larger country might be proposed to us; what will you answer then? Gentlemen! The answer, I believe, Mister Zangwill could already have understood at the time, in the hall. But I will now tell it him, clearly and distinctly, in the name of all Zion-Zionists: No (Bravo!) Another country we do not want and cannot accept. Why?

To give the grounds for this I must unfortunately now enter into a theoretical discussion. I must give the grounds of our standpoint, at least briefly. I cannot now enlarge upon it as fully as the subject demands. But I will at least state the fundamental reasons.

The kernel of our programme is that we wish to create for the Jewish people a publicly and legally secured homestead in Palestine. How do you picture to yourselves a "homestead for the people"? Do you really think that we shall gather together again at one point the whole people, which is scattered over all the continents? Such a concentration of the whole Jewish people is, let us allow, possible. But that is a very far-reaching task, which we naturally cannot discuss now. Our next task, however, is this: to create a homestead for a part of the people, but such a homestead, and in such a country, that it will fundamentally change the situation of the whole people, of all its scattered parts (Bravo!)

The Jewish people suffers in two ways: it suffers morally and physically, politically and nationally. Since we lost our home we are everywhere in the minority, everywhere in an exceptional position. Therein lies the cause of the specific political sufferings, of the specific material Jewish distress, which makes up our fate. Beside this stands the second. The Jewish people has a strong, unbending spirit; it cannot assimilate.

Our history has fully proved it. And since in the Diaspora, in all countries, it has to deal with foreign and often strong cultures, it suffers spiritually in all countries. It is not easy to say which sufferings are the heavier. Our honoured President, Dr. Nordau, rightly said in his speech at the first Congress that "the moral Jewish distress is yet more bitter than the physical, because it afflicts more highly differentiated, prouder and more finely feeling men." Consider these words, and you will agree with me that even if the situation of our people in the Diaspora should improve, the moral Jewish distress will grow yet stronger. The freer we become, the prouder we become, the more the national consciousness develops, and the more we shall suffer.

How is help to be given here? If we wish to save the Jewish people, we must work in both directions at once. And what is to be done?

The assimilationists, who before us gave thought to the Jewish people and laboured for its welfare, preached as follows. We must assimilate; then our exceptional position will gradually become less noticeable; we shall simply not be noticed and persecuted everywhere. As for the national spirit, it will gradually die away; we shall be absorbed, dissolved into each separate milieu. That was the situation we found, and the remedy which was proposed to the Jewish people. Then came Zionism and proclaimed: No, not to die, but to live! A full life, a full spiritual and physical life, a free life is what we will strive for and attain! And since we cannot imitate the way that Moses took when he tore the whole people out of slavery and gave it freedom and land, we must