No. 4 — "Die Welt" — 5
THE "BUND" PRO — THE "COMRADES" CONTRA
The "Bund", or, to give its full title, the "General Jewish Workers' Union in Russia, Poland and Lithuania", recently held its sixth general conference and on this occasion passed a resolution which we reproduce in its main points below:
"Considering that national oppression in all its forms darkens the class consciousness of the proletariat, . . . it is the duty of the Social Democrats to fight against every national oppression, be it direct or indirect; only Socialism will bring liberation from every national oppression. Meanwhile the Social Democrats must already now, within the limits of the capitalist order of society, endeavour to attain the maximum of safeguards against national conflicts. These safeguards . . . . lie only in the creation of such institutions of public law as make possible for every nation a free cultural development. And since a territorial demarcation is not possible in Russia, the said institutions of public law must find their expression in the form of a national-cultural autonomy.
Accordingly the Bund formulates its programme on the Jewish national question in the following points:
- Full civil and political equality of rights.
- A possibility, guaranteed by law, for the Jews to use their own language in local, territorial and state intercourse.
- National-Cultural Autonomy. Exclusion of national-cultural questions (popular education, etc.) from the competence of the state and of the local administrative bodies, and transfer of the functions relating thereto to the nation itself in the form of special institutions. The nation takes part in the establishment of these institutions on the basis of universal, equal and direct suffrage.
Beside these resolutions we would set the demands of the Austrian Zionists in the present electoral campaign. According to the latest formulations *) they run approximately as follows:
Considering that the questions of nationality and of national culture must be removed from politics by way of free national autonomies, which shall be left to the individual peoples to decide independently; considering further that a territorial demarcation such as is planned will not do away with national strife, it must be demanded:
- The creation of national autonomy with recognition of the Jewish nationality.
- The creation of Jewish electoral curiae in the event of the introduction of general national electoral curiae.
And in conclusion we now let follow a Lemberg telegram of the organ of Austrian Social Democracy, the "Arbeiter-Zeitung", which reflects the mood of the Austrian, that is to say of a great part of the Jewish, Social Democrats of Austria. In doing so we refrain from going into the distortion of the facts in this report. The telegram, which is headed "The Zionists Sent Packing", reads:
Yesterday evening four Zionist meetings were to have taken place here, at which propaganda was to be made for the latest Zionist sport, the Jewish curia. At three of the meetings Social Democrats also appeared. One of these meetings, the best attended, was not opened at all when the conveners saw that the Social Democrats had the majority; the second was closed by them after ten minutes, the third closed when the Social Democrats appeared in the hall. With Social Democratic workers the Zionist humbug simply does not take.
* * *
Jewish life, and above all Jewish political life, is rich in tragedy, richer still in a tragicomedy which must wring a melancholy wonder even from the coolest historian, but which at times wrings the heart of the sympathising Jew to whom the fate of his people is dear.
Truly, if one chooses to take the matter cheerfully, one may enjoy the juxtaposition we have given above like a delicious humoresque. Let us recapitulate briefly: The "Bund", perhaps the most dogmatic of all the Social Democratic groups of Russia, demands in the name and from the spirit of Socialism the creation of a Jewish-national autonomy for Russia. The Zionists demand Jewish-national autonomy for Austria. And again "in the name and from the spirit of Socialism" the Austrian (more correctly, the Austrian-Jewish) Social Democrats combat this autonomy as "Zionist humbug", break up meetings, and so forth.
Let us first make a clean distinction, lest we be misled. It is not the programmatic content, not the spirit of Socialism, that is to blame for Jewish Social Democrats on this side deriding and assailing what on the other side they raise upon their shield. Austrian Social Democracy has known perfectly well since the Bruenn party congress that it is among the duties of Socialism to recognise and protect national individualities and values. More than that, Austrian Social Democracy, which divided itself into national groups according to the several races of Austria, was even, in theoretical and practical respects, the teacher of the "Bund" when it set about transforming itself from a non-national into a Jewish-national socialist organisation. Neither the "Bundists" nor the Zionists have better grounded the importance, the necessity of the separation, the development and the protection of the national element within the social than did the Austrian Social Democratic deputy Pernerstorfer. It is not Socialism, then, not the foundation of Austrian Social Democracy, to which we owe the farce on the political stage in which the Jewish Social Democrats of Austria furiously curse what the Jewish Social Democrats of Russia emphatically swear by; it is the Jewish element in the matter that bursts the material asunder and hurls its parts in diametrically opposite directions. That is the humour of it — the historian would say.
The thing looks paradoxical, and is so. But to one who knows the circumstances better it is no sensation of today.
A few recollections from the history of Austrian and of Russian Jewish Social Democracy — the theme, treated exhaustively, could offer a psychologist of the "political" Jews of our day an almost inexhaustible store of material — will soon make much intelligible.
When the Jews entered Austrian Social Democracy and took their place at its head, they brought with them, in spite of their socialist profession, entirely the psychology of the Austrian Jewish-assimilationist bourgeoisie. This bourgeois psychology revealed itself not only in the renunciation on principle of everything in any way connected with Judaism, in the treatment of Judaism as an embarrassing, loathsome infirmity; it went down to the smallest externals. Just as, for instance, the Jewish bourgeois had himself baptised in order to become an officer or a judge, so they had themselves baptised or declared themselves "without confession", in order thus to create the fundamental condition of their party career. Nothing is more characteristic than that even the leader of Austrian Social Democracy, Dr. Victor Adler, had himself baptised — a procedure which in the bourgeois, "by nature unscrupulous", appears ugly, but in the socialist downright repulsive. And just as the bour-
*) Cf. Dr. Schalit: "The Political Future of the Jews", Nationalzeitung.