Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 8 · 23 February 1906
5printed page
scan 3 of 22
Facsimile · scan 3 of 22
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 8 — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…all other considerations carried off the victory . . . But the French direction of the Alliance contrived to arouse the discontent of the non-French members. It pursued a one-sided, inexpedient policy. And to that extent the German members of the Alliance were fully entitled to withdraw their confidence from the Paris direction. But was the way out which they have found the right one, the only possible one? Is the policy inaugurated by the Berlin gentlemen also the expedient one? It is, after all, merely a German, perhaps somewhat deteriorated, edition of the Paris Alliance policy! In Paris they made French policy — but at least with method, on a grand scale. The character of the German Alliance, its relation to German policy in general, scarcely permits one to expect anything similar from the "German Bureau of the A. I. U."

The "Kölnische Zeitung" rejoiced at the resolution of the German A. I. U. And from its own standpoint it was right, too. Why, a mere correspondence from Tangier in this newspaper, a gentle admonition proceeding from this journal, sufficed to put Commercial Councillor Goldberger and the other gentlemen of the Alliance into a fright! Whether German diplomacy has anything profitable to expect from the German A. J. U. is questionable. But beyond doubt the Jewish people will gain little. Some German papers take quite another view of the question. Thus, for example, the "Reichsbote" in Berlin writes: "Are we to rejoice that the Oriental (Russian, Polish and Galician) Jews are all learning German? The consequence will be that they will turn more and more towards Germany, and that settlement in Germany will be made considerably easier for them once they have learned German. But that we can wish as little as that they should be regarded in the East as Germans and, by their well-known conduct, throw the hatred of the Orientals upon Germandom! Let the Jews be taught the language of the country in which they live!" Herr Goldberger will surely soon be sobered and shaken awake from his German dreams of expansion. Gratitude has seldom been the leading motive of policy. But the only fruit, the real yield of the resolution passed in Berlin on the 16th inst., is the crumbling of the Alliance, the splintering of the Jewish forces. We have nothing to fear. In recent years the Alliance has done far too little to secure for itself the glory of a Jewish institution. And should the Jews of the other countries also follow the example of the German Jews, should the Alliance perish of splintering and inner friction, — we shall shed no tear for it. It has long since ceased to be a centre of Jewish life, of Jewish policy. — In its place new, purposeful Jewish organisations must now step. Indeed, they have already done so. "There is a time to build up, and there is a time to break down."

The Veterans. A Jewish newspaper in Vienna, the "Nationalzeitung," recently published some interesting expressions of opinion by Austrian politicians on the national autonomy of the Jews. The answers are in part favourable, but in part also unfavourable. And it will be well worth while to go more closely into this or that utterance and to illuminate it from our standpoint. Some politicians are adherents on principle of Jewish autonomy in Austria — and these, understandably, are the representatives of the nationalities which themselves have a hard struggle to wage for their national individuality, — that is, above all, the Ruthenians and the Czechs. The attitude of the Ruthenians is, of course, well known. Deputy Romanczuk was indeed one of the initiators of the movement for the autonomy of the Jews in Austria. It is understandable that the Czechs, who see in the Jews dangerous allies of the Germans, regard the national autonomy of the Jews as the most natural way out. But they also know their Jews and know how hard these are to win for a Jewish policy. And in this respect the letter of the Czech Deputy Dr. Sileny is particularly characteristic. He writes: "I have heard in many places of the demand for a Jewish-national autonomy, but I see that this plan finds no favour. The Jews of Moravia continue to hold with the Germans, and it is to be ascribed to them that the one-quarter of Moravian Germans, as against three-quarters Czechs, have held the preponderance in the land and in some places where they (the Jews) stand in opposition to the Czech parties, as, for example, Leipnik, Göding, Lundenburg. In the German localities the Jews count upon the good will of the Czechs, while everywhere they behave as Germans. In consequence, the hatred of Jewry naturally cannot diminish, but grows. Under such circumstances there are no prospects that the national autonomy of the Jews will alter anything in the conduct of these people towards the Czechs of Moravia. One need not first wait to see how the Jews will behave under the new Diet electoral law, towards the national register at the Diet and municipal elections, at enrolment in the schools (vide lex Kvicala), etc."

No less interesting is the utterance of the Young Czech deputy to the Reichsrat, Erwin Spindler. To the question of what his attitude was towards the idea of a Jewish nationality, he answered: "Long years ago, much earlier still, before the Zionist idea had begun its triumphal march, I maintained in my paper 'Podripan' the existence of the Jewish race, of the Jewish people.

"In my polemic at that time with the organ of the Czech-Jewish assimilationists, 'Ceskozidovské listy,' I pointed out that the Jews, although they had had the misfortune to lose their fatherland, form a specific whole, distinct from all other peoples. Neither the Diaspora, nor the loss of the national language, nor any other circumstance can alter anything in this fact. My view on this point and my full conviction entitle me to the assertion that the Jews not only form a separate nation of their own, but even belong to an entirely different race from the Christian nations of Europe, and that they are therefore to be regarded and respected in the Kingdom of Bohemia as the third nationality."

He also expressed his "sincere sympathy" with the just endeavour, the only one possible for the Jewish nation," for a Jewish electoral curia, and promised "to support the same as far as possible, should it be brought before the forum of the Reichsrat."

Not so think the Liberals and the Freethinkers. The Reichsrat deputy Dr. Ludwig Vogler, a representative of the Liberalism of '48, wrote to a Zionist society in Vienna:

I know in politics only "voters," not "Jewish voters" and "Christian voters," and therefore will no more go to a meeting of a Zion society, which regards the Jews as a separate group, than I would attend an "antisemitic" one.

It is quite possible that my views on this point are to-day regarded as antiquated. But I have come out of an older school of political life; at the time when I attended the University there prevailed, happily, another spirit and other views than nowadays! And if the times have changed since then, I must not be reproached for being unwilling to change myself.

Nor can I at all presume to wish to convert to another view those Jews who see their salvation in the pursuit of the so-called Zionist aspirations, since I am a non-Jew, and therefore to me, if I against Zion-