Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 16 · 20 April 1906
6printed page
scan 4 of 20

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 16.

But of it holds true what the Russian says of the whole Russian people, that it always comes to its senses too late. Too late, likewise, has the "Union of Russian Writers" come to its senses with its protest against the pogroms. The protest is an honourable testimony to their good will, a historical document from the time of the wildest orgies of the bureaucracy. But as a weapon against the Government, as an attempt at help against the popular instincts stirred up by the Government, it comes, as has been said, too late. Not a few months after the pogroms, but twenty years before the pogroms, should these same writers, who have the foremost Russian newspapers at their disposal, have stood up for the Jews by word and pen.


HOW MUCH LONGER?!

By Julius Simon (Mannheim)

Not long ago Dr. Moses published in these columns an appeal for the founding of a society for the economic development of Palestine. One might have expected that a long and heated theoretical debate would attach itself to the proposal. That at least was the opinion I expressed to the author, together with the fear that amid all the theorising the main thing would be forgotten: "that something practical must be done." The author of the article, however, thought that an understanding of the necessity of placing the Palestine Commission on a secure financial footing had already penetrated into wide circles of our fellow Zionists. He knew well, he said, that his proposal was not an ideal solution of the present precarious state of affairs. But there was nevertheless enough incentive in the project to call forth an eagerness for action on its behalf among many Zionists. — —

Well: to-day we must state that we have both proved wrong. With the exception of a few local groups in Germany and Austria*) no voice whatever was raised, either for or against the project. The urgent appeal has simply died away. Is that not deeply shameful?

Most of the local groups seem not even to have found it necessary to deliberate upon the appeal, not even to inform their members. They have apparently not even — which would surely have been the minimum — circulated a list among their members with the modest question whether one wished to become a member of the proposed society.

Was the proposal thought mistaken? Where, then, was the zealous striving after something better that one had a right to expect? Where, then, were the good counsels for amending the proposal, which were to give it a "more practical" or a "more attractive" form, if one understood the matter better? From all sides at least this one thing ought to have resounded, as proof of how keenly all feel the present state of affairs. But nothing of all this happened.

Then, too, Professor Warburg's article appeared in the "Welt." It was an urgent confirmation of how unavoidable is the creation of an organisation of regular contributions on behalf of the Palestine Commission. But over all the tree-tops is rest. — —

How is this to be explained?

No one who works in our movement is surely in any doubt about the importance of our Palestine Commission. Be he himself a quite exclusive "politician-only." I am certain that not a single propaganda speech goes forth in which its activity is not remembered with a few proud words. Because we all understand how necessary it is that we should do some practical work, how everyone expects such proof from us. Was not the whole Congress enthusiastic when the Palestine Commission rendered its report? And yet that report was not much more than the demonstration of an abundance of "possibilities," of possibilities that might ripen. But only, after all, if one gives this Commission

*) And in Russia (Editor's note).

the necessary means for its work. Everything possible is offered it: love, hope, confidence, pride . . . but not the necessary material support.

Each one of us feels how his loyalty to Palestine deepens ever more and more. Just now, once again, a strong longing for the soil of the homeland is passing through our ranks; we can positively see how it spreads within us and around us. A veritable Palestine fever. Not only in the East. We hear also of heart-refreshing proofs of how many of the wanderers are drawn to Palestine. A new, a strong, healthy class of emigrants, the very best. We hear and see how many of those who wander to the West must positively tear themselves away from the East. And what it costs them to tear themselves away from their beautiful dream, when reason commands the heart! I myself lately witnessed a harrowing instance. Shall we be angry with them? May we be?

I must say that I cannot even rightly rejoice over those who were strong and hopeful enough to land at Jaffa nevertheless. Not even over the financially independent among them, who surely must mean a strengthening of our position. For how much will they advance matters over there?

Has everything, then, already been prepared by us? How many possibilities of an industrial and commercial kind, for instance, are as yet so ripe, so seriously weighed and examined, that reliable counsel would stand at the side of the immigrants.

What has been done for this so far?! — —

That is by no means a reproach against the leadership. Upon us, the troops, alone the reproach falls.

And now there comes a call to a new organisation, through which very large sums could flow together with a small annual contribution from each individual, against which no strong objections of principle exist (where would one ever have heard them?), whose pressing necessity must be clear to everyone, and — with but few exceptions — everything remains silent and idle.

Once more: How is this to be explained? I know the first explanation of those who do not see the Palestine sentiment now swelling ever higher in Russia: Conditions in Russia are sad, they say. The mighty sounding-board of our movement is not at present working as strongly as before. The powerful impulse from the East is lacking; hence the apathetic silence. →

Perhaps I am unjust. I know how much we, too, in the West still all stand under the paralysing impression of the dreadful yesterday and the terrible morrow, which touches us otherwise, moves us more deeply than those who feel themselves bound to the "brethren in faith" there only by a spiritual tie. But one might well be a little unjust oneself in the urgent, storming, cruel necessity of our days! — Our community, the Zionist community, reaches across the whole world. Should Western Europe, America, South Africa not be able by themselves to make a beginning with the raising of funds for so important a cause as the development of Palestine, for one of our most significant institutions, such as the Palestine Commission is?! That is nothing which our propa-