No. 20 — "Die Welt" — 11.
(continued from page 10)
…welcome foreigners need fear no control, but a law of free movement for revolutionaries would truly be useless labour. (Lively applause on the right.) We hope that the authorities will discharge the duty which follows from the right vested in them with firmness and with the ruthlessness indispensable in such cases, even if in so doing they do not find the approval of all the parties of this House and of so-called public opinion, as the agreement of a certain number of newspaper scribblers is nowadays commonly called. (Lively applause on the right. Hissing on the left.)
Deputy Brömel (Liberal Union): I have myself inspected the files of a whole series of expulsion cases, and I was seized with pity for the victims of police caprice. It is painful to feel that such a thing is possible in Prussia at all. Two years ago the Imperial Chancellor himself spoke of foreign schnorrers and conspirators. Does this description apply even to the majority of the Russian refugees? The conditions laid down by the Minister under which expulsions are to take place do not apply in a single one of the cases submitted to me. The persons concerned were furnished with Russian passports, which, as is well known, would not have been issued to the politically suspect. In three hundred cases the persons concerned either held settled positions or possessed the necessary means of subsistence, even for a considerable time. Many have been expelled who were quiet, orderly and industrious workmen, who had an assured livelihood and would have had one in the future as well. Particularly moving are the cases in which the expulsions have summarily ruined people in their economic existence. That expulsions have been withdrawn proves precisely how frivolously the matter is being handled. The practical conduct of the aliens' police in Berlin and in the suburbs gives the impression that what is in fact at issue are mass expulsions, in which one proceeds at first without distinction and leaves it to chance or to the energy of the person concerned whether he will resist or not. The mass expulsion, in which the foreigner must first furnish proof that he has not made himself a nuisance, contradicts the express provisions of the law, according to which only troublesome foreigners may be expelled. The Schöne case, too, cannot yet be regarded as cleared up. It is to be hoped that judicial proceedings will be taken in this matter against the editor of the "Vorwärts," since only so can we obtain a judicial verdict in this affair.
Deputy v. Woyna (Free Conservative): The Jewish writer Hugo Ganz recently demonstrated very aptly that antisemitism in Germany sustains itself only through the continued immigration from the East. The gentlemen of the Left should take note of that. We shall not consent to a statutory regulation of the law on aliens. We intend to oppose the increasing Slavicisation (!) of Germany by every means.
Minister v. Bethmann-Hollweg: It is alleged that 400 cases of error have occurred. Such an assertion is easily made; I can only express my doubt that 400 cases have occurred. Further than that I can say nothing. What purpose does it serve that individual cases, regarding which I have admitted that errors occurred, are brought forward again and again? I really can do nothing other than admit that in individual cases mistakes have been made. With that the matter ought surely to be settled as regards these cases. (Applause on the right.) Herr Gyßling is dissatisfied because I declared a statutory regulation not to be opportune. In so doing I did, indeed, express my personal view, which I believe is shared by my colleagues as well. Various speakers have referred to public opinion. Everyone has a different view of what public opinion is. (Hear, hear! on the right.) We have already heard various definitions of it; I once read a definition in Scherr which I really hesitate to repeat here. He defines public opinion thus: "It is the confused noise produced by the clapping together of the boards, coloured this way and that, which men carry before their foreheads." (Great laughter.) Very often one sees as the herald of public opinion anyone who holds the same view as oneself. If I judge public opinion by the utterances of the press, you will grant me that in a large part of the German press, not only that of the extreme Right but also that which stands in the centre of the parties, the obligation of the Government is fully recognised, in the extraordinary circumstances of the pressure of Russian elements, to be on the watch and to see to it that those who in no direction enrich our German national life are put across the frontier. (Hear, hear! on the right.) You will grant me that this view is shared by a large part of the House.
Deputy Gyßling announces that the Jewish Relief Committee has authorised him to declare that the Committee does not agree with the contents of the well-known letter of the committee member Perlmann. The Protective Committee has hereby publicly disavowed the letter.
With this the discussion is closed.
A CORRESPONDENCE
Mr. Israel Zangwill has sent us, for publication in "Die Welt," a letter addressed by him to the Antwerp Zionists. This letter, which has already appeared in the Anglo-Jewish papers of last week, has prompted Messrs. Greenberg and Grünau-Grünzweig to replies, which we print below together with Mr. Zangwill's letter, whereupon the matter is closed so far as we are concerned.
Letter of Mr. Israel Zangwill to the Antwerp Zionists
Dear Sir,
Some years ago your Committee had the kindness to entertain me and to appoint me Honorary President of your Society, and I have always been proud to be connected, if only nominally, with its work. I was all the more surprised to hear that Zionist students in your city behaved in a rowdy manner at the close of Dr. Jochelmann's address on Territorialism, while it gives me heartfelt satisfaction to learn from him that you all condemned this disgraceful conduct. Unfortunately this is not the only occasion on which Zionism has allowed itself to be sullied by unworthy tactics, which, as I would hope, your movement in general will repudiate no less decidedly.
The Territorial Organisation was founded in order to make the attempt to save for the Jewish people one of the greatest chances offered to it in the course of its history, after the Zionist movement had flung it away. Mr. Greenberg has often asserted that the East Africa scheme ought to be handed over to a special body. The Ito has created this body, while it determined its attitude towards Zionism in a friendly spirit, leaving it entirely to the pleasure of its members to be Zionists or not. It brought peace into the Zionist camp by removing the cause of the dissensions and leaving Zionism free to continue its work for the winning of Palestine without being torn by internal discord. Although I myself could not see in what way further progress could at present be made in Palestine, I nevertheless peacefully left this task to those who possess that insight, while I pressed forward with my own work for the Jewish redemption. I have carefully avoided ever calling upon Palestine Zionists to leave their organisation, since I felt from the outset that in the nine-tenths of the Jewish people who had stubbornly turned their backs on Zionism, before us an extensive