No. 28. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.
(continued from page 8)
…pressed, namely in Thesis III, where the unity of the leadership of the Zionist organisation and of the political party is spoken of. The wish of one group of Galician Zionists even goes so far as to move the Party Conference to resolve that the organisation itself should engage in domestic politics. Is agreement possible on the basis of a theoretical programme? One agrees upon demands. Do not demand that only Zionists lead you; admit others to the leadership as well. (Protest.)
Dr. Thon (Cracow): I agree with the theses in principle and shall vote for them. Zionists should become the spiritus movens of the new organisation, because they are nationalists par excellence. The Zionist organisation is a world organisation. At the Congress non-Austrians are in the majority; it is clear that we cannot let directives for our domestic policy be prescribed to us in Basle. Therefore, alongside our Zionist national organisation, a separate political organisation must be created. At the first onset, I believe, failures cannot fail to occur; but Zionism as such, the Zionist organisation, must not suffer by them. . Jewish policy has been made up to now as well, but "behind heavy curtains." Now we want to make real Jewish policy. Such a policy will benefit the Poles too. Thus it was intended to make the Poles a present of a German mandate, because 150000 Jews took it into their heads to give "German" as their colloquial language. It seemed finer to them to say, instead of "Jech," "Ich" (laughter). The statistical data on the colloquial language of the Jews of Galicia are nothing but a linguistic forgery (assent). A nation must not be regarded as a means, as the Jewish politicians have done hitherto, but as an end in itself (applause). I am not, however, of the opinion that only full-blooded Zionists should be admitted into the party. The leadership, to be sure, must be Zionist. (Lively applause.)
York-Steiner: The theses really contain only hopes, views and wishes, against which I have nothing to object. I move their adoption en bloc and, in agreement with all the authoritative persons, such as Dr. Schalit, Deputy Dr. Straucher, A. Stand, who co-signed my motion, the following addition, which is to precede the theses. The addition reads: "The Zionist Conference declares that the Zionist national organisation is not a political organisation, and therefore recommends the following theses." Then follow the same. I ask you to adopt this compromise motion.
AFTERNOON SESSION
Chairman Bechert reads several telegrams of greeting, among them also a letter from Dr. Poles, President of the Cracow Jewish Community. The general debate is continued.
Dr. L. Kahn (Vienna), continuing after some personal remarks: I am not against political action, for at the time I advocated the Jewish electoral curia and agitated for it to the best of my powers. But I did it as an Austrian citizen and national Jew and not as a Zionist. Since then many a thing has changed — a proof of this is today's Party Conference. We have already pursued Jewish policy, as Zionists. Herzl's work was Jewish policy in the grand style. (Lively applause.) But as Zionists we have nothing to do in the land. (Oho!) I have looked at the draft programme and found the following: they have gone to the Liberals, Social Democrats and cultural pioneers and made a scrambled egg out of all the programmes. Our policy has nothing to do with the Congresses' resolutions on present-day work, to which appeal is made. We do indeed need to concern ourselves with politics; but why derive it from Zionism, from the Basle Programme? Why the Drasch? Politics is unclean. Are electoral frauds to be committed in the name of Zionism? (Great commotion and protest.)
Deputy Dr. Straucher: One must have clean hands everywhere! Everywhere, Herr Doktor! . . . Zionism, the speaker continues, is defined by the Basle Programme. Internal politics, the politics of the land, is not touched by it. . . .
The debate is broken off, and two general speakers, pro and contra, are chosen.
Dr. Ringel (pro): We all feel instinctively that something must be done. We want to, and must, intervene in political life. Since we are now the creators of the new-born party, we wish to remain its guardians — not the Zionist national organisation, but we — the Zionists of Austria. We are convinced that every national-Jewish party must come to Zionism. I recall the Jewish People's Party, which did in the end become Zionist. But we cannot rely merely on development; we must also create guarantees that the domestic-political party undertakes nothing that offends against the Basle Programme. (Applause.)
Dr. Rosenheck (contra): The short sense of the long speeches is that we are faring badly. Who is called upon to intervene here? We take the standpoint that no solution of the Jewish question is possible in the Golus. But distress is rising, and the people look to us for something urgent to be done. The speaker declares himself in favour of allowing non-Zionists also to belong to the new organisation.
Docent Dr. Mahler, Prague (pro), turns chiefly against the demand that the political party should not be Zionist. Can we then pursue politics as non-Zionists? Can one even for a moment cease to be a Zionist? (Stormy applause.) Zionism is indeed a view of life. Are we to play hide-and-seek, are we not to show our colours openly? Why then the game of "here Zionism, there national Judaism"?! (Lively applause.) Yes, it was said that the failures of the political party may harm Zionism. But, permit me the expression, I can do without people who let their devotion to Zionism be guided by successes or failures. (Applause.) It was thought that we would sully Zionism by unclean means. But we will surely not resort to such means! (Lively applause.) In conclusion, one more remark. Do not believe that we of the West are worse Zionists. We had to struggle hard before we reached the firm rock of national Judaism. Let us not, therefore, emphasise what divides East and West. (Applause.) In this respect we are of one mind with our Galician fellow Zionists. Speak plainly and clearly of Zionism, and teach the world respect for the child that is to be born. (Applause.) Do not let the moment slip by. Wherever the theses say national-Jewish, put the word "Zionist," and let the flag of Zion fly high! (Sustained applause.)
Dr. Reich (contra). I can comprehend two points of view: rigid Palestine Zionism and the standpoint that everything must be done only here in the Golus. But to keep silent about Zionism and content oneself with a political programme! Only the Zionists are the legitimate representatives of Jewry, and as Zionists we should take political action. (Interjection: Is that a contra speaker?) Failures have never yet stained an idea. Is Socialism discredited because Daszynski was not elected to the Diet! We shall conduct clean elections (applause), and even if we are defeated, Zionism will only grow stronger. (Lively applause.)
The general debate is closed. In the name of the Credentials Committee, Editor Julius Löwy (Prague) presents the report. 196 delegates have been elected. Present are 135 delegates from 53 localities and 3 representatives of the Poale-Zionist organisation. In the number of its delegates the Zionist Conference is the largest of all that have so far taken place. No election is contested. — The report of the Credentials Committee is noted.
Taking the floor, as representative of the Poale-Zion, for a declaration in the name of his party, is
S. Kaplansky-Kaplan: The debate of the Zionist Conference has taken shape as a unanimous demonstration by all Austrian Zionists in favour of vigorous participation in the political organisation of the Jewish masses. You will resolve — this can be foretold — to found a Jewish party. The position of the social-Zionist workers towards political action is clearly given. The Poale-Zionists will not join this party. (Stir. A cry: Very clear!) Permit me to give my reasons briefly. The development through which you are now passing, the Jewish workers went through long ago, but in the reverse order. It is the victory of the revolutionary idea (very true!), which binds the satisfaction of everyday cares with the struggle for the future into one indissoluble whole, that is now breaking through among you as well. You will call into being a party for the protection of the interests of the broad masses of the Jewish petty bourgeoisie. (I do not believe that you will win the Jewish upper bourgeoisie.) The higher community of interests that exists in Zionism and at the Congress recedes here in a policy of interests in the Golus. We have long been an independent workers' party, and the founding of the Jewish party can change nothing in that. You will undoubtedly create a democratic and very radical party. The contrast between you, radical social reformers, and us, Socialists, remains always great enough. (Fr. Löw: Quite right!) You will understand our distrust if you recall the words of Dr. Margulies, who thought that one could not know whether, in the course of development, national-Jewish water might not get into the Zionist wine of the new party, what compromises you will be compelled to make. (Dr. Braude: You are right! But it is sad.)
