Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 33 · 17 August 1906
7printed page
scan 5 of 22

No. 33 — "Die Welt" — 7

(continued from page 6)

...for the Jews be regarded, and should this not be possible at a single stroke, then it must take place gradually, but as rapidly as possible.... At any moment other nations, too, may wish to colonise the country (which is in part already happening even now). Finally, the fact of purchases of Palestinian soil contributes considerably to strengthening the confidence of the Jews in the future of the Zionist idea.... And so the Congress... must also elect a committee for the colonisation of Palestine, to which, according to statutes to be drawn up, all the colonisation societies of every country are to be subordinate. This committee is to study the land of Palestine closely and in detail, with the help of the colonisation societies to purchase larger tracts of land fit for agriculture, and there first to found a number of colonies with those Jews now in Europe and Palestine who are fitted for it. The greater the number of people capable of colonisation becomes, the more and more colonies can be founded....

M. Moses-Kattowitz at that time proposed the founding of co-operative societies for the acquisition of rural estates in Palestine.

Dr. Schnirer-Vienna, who delivered the official report, expressed himself as follows: "... Our colonies in Palestine, however, are of enormous importance for our movement.... The greatest weight must therefore be laid upon strengthening those colonies which are not yet firmly established. New colonies, on the other hand,... are to be founded only from the human material at present available in Palestine, whereby, it goes without saying, no illegal or unlawful means whatsoever are to be employed."

Finally, the following motions of Gross-Bambus-Rosenberg were adopted as suggestions on the point of Palestinian export and import:

  1. The founding of trading companies, wherever expedient.

  2. The establishment of a warehouse or permanent bazaar in Jaffa, in which the products of Jewish industry and Jewish skill shall be held ready for sale at home and abroad.

  3. The founding of an agrarian and commercial bank.

To remedy the distress of the labourers:

  1. By the promotion of home industry.

  2. By decentralisation, that is, the transfer of the artisans and labourers who are superfluous in certain towns, notably in Jerusalem, to the towns and townships of the interior which are but scantily supplied with an artisan class.

W. Bambus at that time delivered a speech in which he stated, among other things:

"... Our whole colonisation... is to this day an experiment and must long remain one. One cannot in 20 years colonise a country such as this, which has not been explored agriculturally. A colonisation on a large scale, even if no legal difficulties exist, cannot well be carried through. It will take many a year yet. An agricultural experiment lasts for years. We have made such experiments and ought to go on making them. I believe that the first condition lies in our continuing the experiment. It is the preliminary work, which is absolutely necessary...... We can at present promote trade and industry, while we must suspend agriculture...... It surely cannot be our task to promote trade and industry in the Holy Land by way of charity; rather one must ascertain which branches of livelihood are the most useful, and take care not to paralyse initiative and bring everything under one central office. We are obliged to awaken the Palestinian initiative of the individual, and we can do so, too, if we do not proceed by rote, but stimulate the necessary competition through publication in the newspapers and by placing our help at the disposal of every private person......"

The second Congress, too, again brought discussions and motions on the subject of work in Palestine. First let the motion of the Colonisation Commission be singled out, which ran:

"The Congress, which regards the colonisation already begun in Palestine with sympathy and wishes to further colonisation, declares:

  1. By 'expedient settlement' of Palestine is understood that colonisation which is to be carried out after permission for it has been obtained from the Turkish Government, and according to a plan and under the direction of a commission elected by the Congress.

  2. The first steps in colonisation are to be undertaken with the Jews residing in Turkey.

  3. The activity of the Colonial Bank shall contribute to obtaining a permit for colonisation from the Turkish Government.

  4. The Congress pledges the Zionists to use their influence to the end that all colonisation societies endeavour to work according to a plan conforming to the above resolutions."

This motion, too, was adopted.

W. Bambus spoke on the question on this occasion also. He declared, among other things:

"... "But one branch of colonisation is open to us and to all with little capital, and that is industrial colonisation, and that will be the task which will fall to the Colonial Bank. This industrial colonisation is also the only colonisation which can in reality achieve something effective for the great masses of the Jews already in Palestine. In certain circumstances we can lead hundreds of Jews out upon the land and let them become peasants, but not the great majority. For that the present generation lacks the physical strength. For it, an effective means is the erection of factories, the creation of independent livelihoods and the awakening of private initiative. If we Western European Jews would think thus, far fewer difficulties would be made for us. So long as we do not possess the private initiative to go over ourselves in greater numbers, to create factories and an industry, and to give the people, besides the necessary funds, the intelligence also, in particular the technical intelligence, which the people over there lack, the activity of the Colonial Bank, or of any other institution, or of a great society which is compelled from above to colonise and to install officials, will lead to no decisive result......"

Dr. Heinrich Loewe expressed himself as follows:

"First I should like to state that I am an adherent of colonisation, but that by colonisation and immigration I would understand two different conceptions, which we must not confuse. We must and can colonise, but in the first place, as the resolution of the commission says, with those Jews who are already settled in Turkey to-day, and who are not to be brought into Palestine by underhand ways."

Mr. Mozkin, too, touched upon the problem, remarking:

"... for, even though I always stand up again and again for the public-legal system of Zionism, I am entirely in favour of endeavouring at the same time to create as many alleviations as possible for what already exists, and if this is pursued consistently, it will also be possible to carry it through."

Finally, a motion of Rajnowski concerning the establishment of model farms, and a motion of Bujes concerning the founding of agricultural schools, were at that time referred to the Colonisation Committee.

At the third Congress Dr. Kohan-Bernstein was the first to take up the subject, setting forth the following:

"... As regards the support of the colonists in Palestine and of the various colonisation societies, we [understand: in Russia] have resolved... and have not for a moment ceased to work for the colonisation societies... When I speak of colonisation societies, I mean exclusively the great Odessa Colonisation Society or the like. We in any case dissociate ourselves entirely from the smuggling Zionists, from the colonisation Zionists, from the 'salted' company."

The same Congress brought forward the following motions of the Colonisation Committee, rapporteur Dr. Tschlenow:

I. The Congress recommends the Actions Committee, both itself and through the commission to be mentioned below, to enter into relations with the existing colonisation societies and to remain in constant touch with them, but to recommend to them that they confine their colonising activity for the present to the Jews living in Palestine.

II. To support the Actions Committee in this task, the Congress elects a commission consisting of 11 members. The commission has the right to co-opt new members.

III. This commission, in agreement with the Actions Committee, is to establish a bureau in Palestine which has the following tasks:

  1. to carry out the exploration of Palestine and Syria in scientific, cultural and legal respects, it being remarked that it is most expedient to draw in, for participation in these labours, a jurist thoroughly acquainted with the Turkish laws;

  2. to establish by scientific means the basis for the rational cultivation of the various districts of Syria and Palestine in agricultural and industrial respects.

IV. The Actions Committee is to procure the necessary means.

These motions are adopted.

At the fourth Congress Prof. Bjelkowsky expressed himself in the official report as follows:

"... "Turkey... which surely, in the very first place, great advantages from the cultural opening-up of its fallow territories

2*