Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 34 · 24 August 1906
9printed page
scan 7 of 22
Facsimile · scan 7 of 22
Scan of p. 9
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 34 — "Die Welt"

(continued from page 8)

...small budget, in doing so much, especially as its hands were tied by the percentage provision. We must not load so much upon this poor Society. Purchase of land, schools, information, Oscher, public-welfare expenditures, Gau-Schmuel, etc., etc. — that is surely asking somewhat too much. The Society has such small receipts because it has created nothing tangible, because it everywhere merely lent a hand and nowhere undertook anything independent, because we are not in a position to point to something and say: See, that is the work of our hands. The Committee must be something or must cease to be. We must occupy ourselves with one thing, but wholly, and not with many things in part. If the committee to be elected wishes to be held for something, then let it also do something whole and visible, and not crumble itself away. We must put the question of schools and of information on its proper footing and point the whole world to it; then we shall have accomplished something and our receipts will increase.

After several more speakers had declared themselves for and against a far-reaching programme, the speaking time on the question of the programme is fixed at ten minutes and the evening sitting is closed.

Tuesday Morning Sitting

Lilienblum: Just as the poet said: "Nothing human may be alien to man," I maintain that nothing Palestinian may be alien to us, the Zionists, the Palestinophiles. We may remove nothing that concerns Palestine from our programme. An exception here might be philanthropy. This can and must be removed from our programme, although we may not wholly succeed in this at first. About 15% of our budget we shall nevertheless have to spend on philanthropic purposes in Palestine. Lilienblum explains the small receipts by the war, which tore many members away from the P.-S., by the pogroms, emigration, etc., external circumstances which have nothing to do with the work of the Committee, and remarks in conclusion: We must co-ordinate our activity with other analogous societies and go hand in hand with them, as, for example, the Zionists resolved in Brussels.

Schuchmann and Salzmann point to deficient agitation on the part of the Committee. The latter reads out letters from the provinces, addressed to him as head of the "Kadimah" publishing house, from which it is evident how greatly the provinces long for pamphlets on Palestine, and proposes that the Committee should publish cheap agitation pamphlets on Palestine.

Granowsky is in favour of the Committee's occupying itself only with the question of schools and information, because the Zionist Organisation is at work in all other fields.

Boruchow: Until now we had members who stayed with us or came to us although they were Zionists; now members come to us because they are Zionists. Until now our Committee consisted mostly of people who called nothing in Palestine their own and had never been there. Now it will be otherwise. Why should we Zionists play the comedy of pretending that we are coming into the Palestine Society in order to conquer something? Is it not our own cause, which we love and have always loved? Naturally the Society will adopt our programme, because we, and only we, are its members. We do not wish to co-ordinate our activity with the Palestine Commission, as some here have proposed; rather, we wish to be one with this Commission. We Zionists should found such societies throughout the whole world, and where such already exist, as, for example, the "Esra," we ought to see to carrying out our programme there.

Drujanow: We have no need to speak of co-ordination of activity, for we had our representative at the First Congress and at the Minsk Conference. We were the first to support the Palestine Commission with funds. The first advisers of the Committee, without whom nothing might be undertaken, were the members of the Zionist A.C. Our Committee agitated with its means for Zionism. Of victories and conquest only those can speak who came to us but yesterday and are not acquainted with our activity.

Schabotinsky: The Palestine Society can be useful to us only if it is not one with the Zionist Organisation, but will be an organisation with an end of its own. Precisely because our Society has a considerably narrower programme than the Zionist Organisation, and in consequence appeals more to many practical people, we must let these practical men do, through this Society, what will in the final aim benefit Zionism. There is, besides, much that the Zionist Organisation. as such may not undertake, because it must exercise consideration, while our Committee can do it very well. The Zionist Organisation must proceed with the utmost caution in every respect, which is not necessary for the Palestine Committee. The Committee can and must be made use of for every experiment that will be useful to Zionism, and is not dependent upon the sanctioning of its activity by the Congress. We must therefore endeavour not to become one with the Zionist Organisation, but a support of it. Loyal and free — that is the watchword we must give the future Committee for its three years' road. Loyal it shall be to the Zionist Organisation, and free — independent of it — in its actions.

Ussischkin speaks of the Committee's activity hitherto and is likewise of the opinion that the Committee has done too little for agitation in Russia. He then sums up the four opinions expressed on the future activity: 1. we should pass the same resolutions as the previous General Meeting, that is, everything should remain as before; 2. the Committee should be given carte blanche; 3. the budget should be fixed, with the exception of the purchase of land; 4. the Committee should occupy itself merely with certain matters and with nothing else; and he then continues: We must not restrict the Committee nor give it any definite instructions whatever for the road. If we occupy ourselves only with schools or only with information, we shall not be able to accomplish anything great here either. The Committee must not take over one special matter in Palestine; it must rather be, so to speak, the leavening element for everything that is to be done in Palestine. The Palestine Committee must become an organ of the Zionist Organisation for practical work in Palestine, serving it and at the same time independent.

The debates on general tactics are thereby closed, and the following resolution is adopted by all votes against 2:

In view of the necessity of bringing the future activity of the Society into harmony with its altered statutes, the VIth General Meeting recognises that the basis of this activity must be made the endeavour, co-ordinated with other like-minded institutions, towards the systematic strengthening of the Jewish element in Palestine and Syria by the following measures:

  1. The all-round exploration of the country;

  2. the support of agriculture, industry, etc., keeping chiefly in view the interests of the working masses;

  3. the cultural and economic organisation and elevation of Palestinian Jewry, through the introduction of new intellectual forces;

  4. the obtaining of administrative and legal concessions in Palestine.

The General Meeting is, however, at the same time of the opinion that any unsystematic and philanthropic colonising activity is inadmissible.

Tuesday Evening Sitting

On the order of the day stands the question: "Purchase of Land in Palestine." The report is given by

Ussischkin, who argues roughly as follows: We have many institutions which are supposed to occupy themselves with the purchase of land in Palestine: the Colonial Bank, the Anglo-Palestine-Comp., "Geulah," the "Palestine Society," the National Fund, which has already acquired land in Palestine for about 170 000 Frc. On the National Fund, however, we cannot for the present count in this respect, for it can acquire no land so long as it lacks the legal guarantees which secure to it the piece of land acquired. But we must endeavour to transform the dead National Fund into a living institution, while it must always remain the National Fund, and this must be carried through at the 8th Congress. The legal form for the purchase of land will be found. Has not the Colonial Bank found the form, in that it itself acquired land in Palestine and found it possible to repay the Geulah ³⁄₈ of the value of the land? The Geulah has sold shares for 55 000 Rbl. The land acquired by this company is not yet sold, because the "Geulah" can sell only for cash, while those who wish to buy mostly do not possess so much. It is difficult to enlarge Jewish landholding in Palestine through private property; through philanthropy it is utterly impossible. In order really to promote the passing of the soil of Palestine into Jewish hands, an Agrarian Bank must be created. The Jewish Colonial Bank ought above all to strive to lay the foundation for the creation of the Jewish Agrarian Bank in Palestine. The Colonial Bank ought to acquire shares of the Agrarian Bank for 500 000 Frs., half of this sum having to remain without interest for some time. The Bank can do this without great difficulty if by it, for this purpose, the 38 000 Rbl. for unredeemed shares and 80 000 Rbl. for uncollected