Die Welt · Vol. X, No. 35 · 31 August 1906
14printed page
scan 14 of 24

"Die Welt" — No. 35.

As regards the future activity of the Palestine Commission, it will depend essentially upon the state of its finances. This year not even enough money has come in to pay the debts of the last years, let alone to pay out the budget voted by the Congress for the two years 1903—1905. Although this year too we have spent only three-quarters of the budget due to us, the debts of the Commission are at present greater than last year, and with the small receipts from the shekel moneys a liquidation of the debts from that quarter is not probable, while a fulfilment of the Congress resolutions concerning the budget of the Palestine Commission appears altogether out of the question.

Our view is that the shekel moneys should remain reserved solely for purely organizational and propagandist purposes, and that for the Palestine work a special Palestine contribution must be levied, which must for the present be voluntary but should later be made obligatory by resolution of the Congress; there would then be a party shekel and a Palestine shekel to be paid every year. The German federation has already recommended a voluntary Palestine contribution to its members; the other national federations should follow this example. Only in this way shall we succeed in giving our Palestine work a healthy constitution for the long term, and perhaps in time even in creating a fund from which, should it become necessary, large investigations could also be defrayed.

Ussischkin is the first to speak on the report. He puts forward various wishes, among others that "Altneuland" should carry, besides scientific articles, articles of a practical and informative character as well. He relates that the Odessa Committee has resolved to set up Palestine courses, first in Odessa and then in other towns of Russia too, and invites Professor Warburg to open the first of these courses in Odessa in person. He expects good results from the production of maps of Palestine. The delay in the establishment of the experimental station leads him to ask the Palestine Commission not to wait until the Ica has at last settled the cession of the land. It would be better to try to establish the station in Chedera. He supports the motion before the meeting of Professor Schatz, to grant the Bezalel school ground for a school building on loan. The museum could also be housed in this building. He is against the establishment of a gymnasium if this is possible only in conjunction with another society. Experience has taught, he says, that such agreements impair, or render impossible, the national foundation of the schools, which we regard as a matter of course for our schools. The subsidy to the National Library must be paid in any event. It is a debt of honour, and it must be met before other expenditure is incurred. He welcomes most joyfully the preparatory work of the Palestine Commission in the matter of the Palestine Syndicate; he regards this activity as one of the most important and most fruitful tasks of the Commission. The Palestine Commission, he says, deserves our fullest confidence; its work is exceedingly deserving of thanks.

Scheinkin doubts whether Atlith is the suitable spot for the experimental station, because malaria occurs there. As regards the gymnasium he is entirely of Ussischkin's opinion. He complains that the Palestine Trading Company in Hamburg seeks its field of activity outside Palestine.

Podlischewsky is also in favour of procuring a house of its own for the Bezalel, but the means for it should be taken not from the moneys of the National Fund but from the fund of the forfeited shares of the Jewish Colonial Bank. With regard to the gymnasium he is not of Ussischkin's opinion. A higher school is an urgent need for Palestine, and if it can be created with the help of other organizations, that is certainly much better than if we renounce its establishment altogether because we lack the means. Nor does he believe that the Hilfsverein in particular will put overly great difficulties in the way of a national basis for the school.

Sokolow emphasizes the importance of the Palestine work, which is altogether the most important means of maintaining our organization. Unfortunately we have hitherto done very little in this direction, and even that was incomplete. Expenditure for Palestine we must regard as productive expenditure, because it wins us new adherents, because under present circumstances it is altogether the most effective means of bringing fresh blood to our movement. Our debts to the various institutions in Palestine we must pay on the spot. It is a crying injustice that we should incur other expenditure at all before we fulfil our obligations towards Palestine. The speaker believes that it is quite possible to work together with the Hilfsverein in Palestine. It has been shown that the Hilfsverein endeavours to adapt itself to the requirements of the countries in which it works. And the active work of the Hilfsverein in Palestine permits the expectation that, so far as it can, it will not hinder our national aspirations.

Feiwel demands that in the Palestine question the political points of view from which we must carry on our Palestine work be considered first and foremost in the debate. We must point out that the Palestine question is the vital question of our movement. If in the diplomatic and political sphere we cannot yet operate with tangible successes, then we must lay the emphasis and the centre of gravity of our work upon Palestine. It seems that the view of the inner A. C. on this question is not unanimous. We have no right to doubt that, with respect to political activity, the inner A. C. pursues a firm and uniform plan; but this we can all see, that our Palestine work is not directed from broad points of view. Certainly our goal is limited to the attainment of a home secured by public law. But this limitation must not go so far that we do nothing at all. Unfortunately we lack a fresh, strong initiative with respect to the work in Palestine. Above all, our information does not stand at the level which the situation and the interest of our movement demand.

The establishment of an information office in Palestine was set on foot privately, but not by the A. C., although precisely such an institution, in view of the heavy immigration of the past year, would have been the most urgent requirement. The A. C. is evidently not clear enough about the significance to be attached to this immigration. It has not observed that the heavy immigration into Palestine and the economic activities newly unfolded there have formed the most gratifying feature of our movement within the past year.

The immigration into Palestine this year was one of the most significant facts the Zionist movement has ever known. And it would have been not only easy, it would also have been a duty, to make it serve the Zionist movement. But the impulse is lacking for this work, which I hold to be eminently political. It seems as though a secret resistance to all Palestine work prevails among some members of the A. C., and so long as that is the case, things will not improve.

The speaker finally recommends most warmly the motion of Prof. Schatz.

Chairman Dr. Marmorek: I must emphasize that I know nothing of any secret resistance to Palestine.

Dr. Weizmann: I agree fully and entirely with the remarks of my friend Feiwel. But I fear that we are talking here quite to no purpose, because the gentlemen to whom we are really addressing our words are not here now. That a positive resistance to Palestine prevails in the inner A. C. cannot, to be sure, be proved. But it is a fact that wide circles among the Zionists, and a large part of those present here, are of the opinion that a passive resistance exists here and that there is an antagonism between the feeling of the Zionist masses and the leadership. Often now even the slightest work in and for Palestine is condemned as Chowewe-Zionism. I can understand it if one regards some piece of work done in Palestine as insufficient or as mistaken. But the gentlemen politicians, who are always speaking here of their loyalty to Palestine, may not content themselves with giving no initiative whatever for the work in Palestine and afterwards declaring with emphasis that the work of the Palestine Commission is not good. I am not one of those who condemn political work as such; on the contrary, I am entirely in favour of making use of every political possibility in order to come nearer to our goal. But the inner A.-C. does not express itself clearly on all these questions. We must say it for once: we do not know clearly where we stand. We leave political work to the inner A.-C., but neither do we see anything of activity in Palestine. And that is why misunderstandings prevail in our movement. The inner A.-C. ought once and for all to issue a clear and precise order. It is wrong, and it has a confusing effect, when one, with fold-