No. 35. — "Die Welt" — 7.
(continued from page 6)
…Bank were not tied up afresh, on any considerable scale, outside Palestine. The speaker then touches upon the amount of the Bank's expenses, and finally turns against Advocate Rosenbaum-Minsk with regard to the Bank's dividend policy. The Bank must, as far as possible, pay a minimum dividend of 3%. Only then could an influx of new capital be expected.
Thereupon the President replies that it is the wish of the Board of Directors and of everyone to pay a dividend. As regards the expenses, it had not been possible this year, in spite of every effort, to reduce them, since this time the expenses of the branch in the East End were added to the ordinary outlays. Concerning the passage in the report that the Russian business is the basis of our activity and is to be resumed in quiet times, the President points out that the present balance-sheet was printed in March, when the general situation was different from now. Our engagement in Russia amounted in March to about 1 200 000 roubles and has since been considerably reduced.
Moser is of the opinion that regard must be paid to the wishes of so important a Federation as the South African. He complains that the information which he receives as a member of the Board of Supervision is insufficient.
Dr. Mossinsohn complains that agitation for Shares is made impossible by the fact that the Bank carries on no Palestine undertakings whatever. But do you know why shares cannot really be sold anywhere? Because we cannot have confidence in the Board of Directors. A Director, Mr. Joseph Cowen, declares publicly that he calls upon the shareholders to vote against the resolutions of the Congress, and this very Director sits in London and has the greatest influence upon the Bank. No bank in the world would tolerate one of its Directors coming out against the resolutions of his colleagues. He would simply be compelled to resign, or else he would withdraw of his own accord in order to pursue his policy outside the Board of Directors as a private person. But with us neither the one nor the other has happened. On this matter he demands an explanation, not from Mr. Cowen, but from the Board of Directors as a whole. He moves: "The General Meeting calls upon the Board of Directors to take steps so that such things shall not occur again in future."
Wolffsohn declares that the Bank's participation in the relief fund had in fact taken place at the instance of the Board of Supervision. As regards the founding of branches, it must be pointed out again and again that the capital of the Bank is still far too small to make it possible to tie up the considerable sums which new branches would require. It is self-evident that we should first establish branches in Palestine. I would moreover draw your attention to the fact that it represents a quite considerable achievement that in the course of three years we have established three new banking offices in Palestine. The speaker would personally be in favour of establishing agencies of the Bank at other important points as well, but he warns against exaggerating in either the one direction or the other. As regards Cowen's attitude, he too does not find it justified. Cowen was, however, quite entitled to express his private opinion, and he did no more than that. The speaker too had originally been opposed to the alteration of the Articles and is not in favour of it even to-day. But since the Congress had resolved upon it, one must in loyalty abide by it. The speaker then comes once more to speak of the history of the alteration of the Articles, and says: Dr. Gaster related in London that he had spoken with Herzl and had reproached him that the Articles had at the time been drawn up in Vienna not in accordance with the resolutions of the Congress, in that, instead of Palestine, every part of the world had been defined as the field of operations. I repeat that the Bank Committee met in London, where Advocate Bentwich laid before it the Articles in their present form, as drawn up by the English lawyers. The English lawyers declared that it was by no means advisable to restrict the Bank's field of business to one particular country, because it would then be impossible to undertake even the smallest operation anywhere else. The draft Articles adopted in this form had been sent to Vienna. Herzl and the Vienna A.-C. had at once protested against this form and demanded that the Articles be drawn up exactly in accordance with the resolutions of the Congress. After long deliberations, however, the present form had nevertheless been retained on the proposal of Dr. Gaster, Dr. Gaster having declared that the gentlemen abroad, who after all did not know the English laws sufficiently, must defer to the opinion of the English jurists, because the Bank was domiciled in England.
Cowen turns against the reproaches made against him and declares that he knows nothing of an imperative mandate. Even as a Director he could not let himself be deprived of his private opinion, and least of all when he was of the view that the contrary would be to the injury of the Bank. At the second Extraordinary General Meeting in London he had acted entirely loyally, in that, although he himself was against the alteration of the Articles, he had by the adjournment prevented the motion for the alteration of the Articles from being rejected. The majority of the meeting had been — at least in his opinion — against the alteration. He sees no reason whatever to resign his office.
Dr. Weizmann regrets that the debate has taken on a personal character. He declares himself in favour of a greater business activity of the Bank in Palestine and turns against the establishment of branches in other countries. It had always been our view that the Bank is first and foremost an instrument of the movement. That holds good even at the risk of the Bank doing less good business. He addresses to the Board of Directors the request that, so long as it is not possible to establish new branches in Palestine, at least smaller agencies be set up, which could later grow into branches.
In view of the fact that the English Board of Trade would, on account of the alterations to the Bank's Articles, obtain the opinions of experts, and since, so far as he knew, Mr. Cowen would be one of these experts, he asks Mr. Cowen whether in that case too he will give his opinion against the admission of the alteration.
Cowen: I did not expect that this question would be put to me, and it would have been in the interest of the Bank if it had been left unasked. But since I am asked, I answer that, if I am approached by the Board of Trade for an opinion, I shall declare myself, in accordance with my conviction, against the alteration of the Articles.
Schenkin raises the reproach that the position of the Anglo Palestine Company is represented as worse than it is, in the interest of the Jewish Colonial Trust. It must be known that the A. P. C. has to pay 4 % interest on its capital to the Jewish Colonial Bank. By so much, therefore, is its gross profit greater. The speaker comes to speak of the oft-proposed founding of a branch in Haifa. The Board of Directors takes a sceptical view of this foundation, but meanwhile other banks have founded branches there. He further complains that the A. P. C. has not complied with the wish of many Palestinians that it should issue debentures for house-building, although half of the debentures would have been paid for by the applicants. Finally he asks why the shares of the A. P. C. are not offered for sale. They rest in the portfolio of the Colonial Bank, which meanwhile receives its 4 % from the A. P. C.
Kann proposes that the report of Mr. Lewontin on the A. P. C. be heard, whereby many of the questions etc. brought forward in the course of the debate would be disposed of.
Dr. Mossinsohn turns sharply against the statements of Mr. Cowen, which meant nothing other than a disregard of the resolutions of the General Meeting and of the Board of Directors. It is necessary to compel the Board of Directors to respect the resolutions of the General Meeting, so that it may not appear as though it were a matter of entire indifference to the Board of Directors what the General Meeting resolves.
Advocate Rosenbaum likewise turns against Mr. Cowen's view that a Director may act in Bank matters according to his private opinion. He is convinced, however, that if this were to happen, e.g., in a financial matter, the Board of Directors would not put up with it.
Feiwel addresses to the President the question whether he would not take measures, through suitable publications, to see that the shares of the Anglo Palestine Company, in view of the increased interest in Palestine, are made accessible to the public for purchase. As regards the fact that the shares of the Bank are so difficult to sell, the blame lies (apart from the fact that the Bank's shares are not an Exchange security and are at present repurchased neither by the Bank nor by private persons when they are offered) with the circumstance that our Zionists of large means make no effort to increase confidence in the Bank. The deposits of the Zionists of large means unfortunately lie not in the Jewish Colonial Bank but in other banks. The speaker asks whether the President has undertaken anything with regard to attracting the private capital of Zionists.
Podlischewsky asks the Board of Directors to proceed only very cautiously with the establishment of new branches. Every branch demands the tying up of a considerable part of the Bank's capital. But care must be taken that sufficient reserves are present in the Bank at all times to be able to meet even the greatest demands without a stoppage.
2*
